Software
Houzz Logo Print
beyondcalimari

Exterior painting problems -- whose fault?

19 years ago

I hired some painters to paint the outside of my house. They pressure washed everything before they started, and they also scraped. On the gables of the house, there was a lot of old paint falling off. They didn't sand the area smooth first; they told me that they don't use power sanders because they eat up the wood and do more damage than good. The paint job came out looking really cheap. It has an alligator like appearance from all the old half-pulled off paint. The painters refuse to fix it, saying that the only way to fix it is to put up new plywood, which would cost me $400-500 (per gable, although only one gable is really visible from the road and to visitors to the house). The other option would be to spend more $$$$ and put up hardi-shingles on both gables (I had shungles put on the front gable only - the one facing the road).

I'm pretty ticked because I was under the understanding that the gables would be sanded smooth before painting. I went back and looked at their proposal, which said that all cracking and peeling paint would be scraped and sanded, and that any cracks would be caulked. It should have been apparent to them that just scraping (and light sanding) would not leave a smooth surface, and I would think that they would have to warn me of that before they started so that I could make adjustments to make it look right. They never mentioned that it would come out looking "textured". (They even told me later that some people LIKE the alligator-texture look!)

So am I wrong for failing to see the issue before they started and pin them down on the final look, or are they wrong for either failing to warn me of the final look or trying to get away with doing an inexpensive paint job? I don't want to cause too much of a fuss if I'm in the wrong, but I'm paying almost $3000 for the job, and I didn't expect to pay an extra $400-$1000 to have it look well done.

Comments (5)

  • 19 years ago

    I agree that power sanders don't belong on wood exterior. I had to finally chase a painting contractor away because he made the house look much worse than it started out looking. If you wanted to do your job and get it down to bare wood first, they could have used chemical strippers. We finally went that route. It was a lot more expensive, but we had to do it to try and get the lead paint off the house. It did look like new wood (except where it was chewed up by the power tools). Recently we resided with Hardiplank and installed Andersen windows. I wish we had done that 15 years ago.

  • 19 years ago

    I have a brick home with board and batton ends similar to yours. Yours is plywood with one-by battons. When painted plywood gets as bad as yours appears, your choices are to replace it or cover it. Your picture does not show what I presume are louvered vents on the gable ends of your home. These would play a part if you plan to cover your gable ends. Re sanding, it would require a belt sander as any type of rotary sander would leave this thin plywood with swirl marks. The reality of the situation should have told you that the gable ends were beyond a very expensive total sanding and painting especially on what appears to be 1/4" of 3/8" plywood.

  • 19 years ago

    I tend to agree with the two previous posters. The wood gables on your house look as though they needed replacement.

    I guess my other thought would be, that if you got someone to pressure wash, sand and paint your house for under $3,000 -- you got either the bargain of the century, or a really cheap paint job. You'll have to be the judge.

  • 19 years ago

    Did your contract indicate sanded smooth (or) sanded? Obviousbly sanded gives the new paint good adhesion, sanded smooth is a different story (which you didn't get).

    It is so difficult to understand any contract or intent as the painter probably had good intent and you probably didn't ask enough good questions.

    I never ask enough good questions, that's why I wait a while , read the contract and then write down my questions. What I visualize is never what I get.

  • 19 years ago

    i'm also in the process of getting estimate for exterior painting. i was looking at one of the contractors that burn off the previous layers of paint until they get to bare wood....only on portions of the exterior that's wood sided. there was another house on the same block that used this contractors and they had a really excellent paint job. i'm not sure about the cost yet but i think they are $2000 extra compared to regular painting contractors. otherwise cover the wood siding with hardie planks, but the problem with hardie was that other owners mentioned that there's more maintainence with hardie, more frequent caulking and therefore painting than regular wood siding, probably every 5 years vs. every 7 to 10 years for a good paint job.

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations