My girlfriend just drew one on her own....it was basically like a heart shape at the top and came down to form two root like shapes...Like a W only she rounded the bottom points a bit. She made them from leftover satin fabric and just added a little pocket on the front to put the tooth in. She added a hanger so the kids could hang it from a dresser knob. It is small and easy enough to do (quick too)....so rather than a whole fancy pillow maybe a little tooth shaped item will do......I think the whole thing was 6" long and about 4" wide. Just a suggestion. Budster

Here you go! My daughter just turn five and checks for wiggly teeth every day :).

Rebecca

Here is a link that might be useful: Tooth Fairy Pillow pattern

I found by far the cutiest Tooth Fairy Pillow ever!!! I was so excited I had to share. They even give you the option to sew it yourself,, a letter, tooth brush and other things. For boys and girls and well, you just have to visit this site and see what I mean!!! I am ordering one for my grandson and one for my granddaughter who both turned five in July (one day apart)! Thanks for the help! Brittsgrams