Software
Houzz Logo Print
needhamgardens_gw

Andersen Renewal vs. Andersen Woodwright

18 years ago

We have a 90 year old colonial and am looking to replace 24 original windows with wood (or composite) replacement windows. Does anyone have experience with either of the 2 listed Andersen windows?? Both are expensive and similiarly priced - is there some other good wood window out there, maybe a bit less expensive??

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    I just had Andersen Woodwright insert windows installed. When I was comparing I liked Marvin Ultimate the best but the cost was almost $200 more per window. But you still may want to try Marvin - the costs do vary by size/options.

    I'd also look at Pella - I didn't like them as much as Marvin and Andersen. I never got a price on them since they seem to operate like Andersen Renewal - sending a manufacturer related sales person to your home to do a quote.

    If you are in the Northeast US then Harvey seems to be the "budget" wood window replacement. But I didn't think the quality compared to the others. Still worth taking a look - I only had 16 DH windows - plus an awning window for the bathroom and a french door.

    - Dennis

  • 18 years ago

    I'm not sure on the price comparison, but Anderson owns a company named Eagle, and I think it is Anderson's "luxury home" product line. However, we've had clients request pricing from Anderson in the past, and we didn't notice a big difference. However, this was only on a few occasions in the past 5 years, so things may have changed.

    Eagle, Kolbe and Marvin all build fairly comparable products in their upper-end product lines. Unless I'm mistaken, they all utilize extruded aluminum in their construction. This differs substantially from Anderson's vinyl extrusion and Pella's roll-formed aluminum.

    Remember, this cladding material is designed to protect the wood beneath it and is therefore very important. It is my opinion that unless it is extruded aluminum and using proper extrusion joinery, you'd be better off with an all wood window and keeping up on the maintenance.

  • 18 years ago

    I had 17 double-hung Andersen Woodwrights installed in September (our house is about the same age as yours...built in 1911.) We love these windows so far. I never looked at Renewal, but I did look at many others over nearly 2 years, and the Woodwrights were my ultimate choice. LOVE. THEM.

  • 6 years ago

    Scottek, could you please give an update on your Woodwright double hung windows. How are they holding up?