Software
Houzz Logo Print
davisgard

chalk paint vs.milk paint

15 years ago

I've seen the rave reviews on chalk paint and I wonder how it compares to milk paint (the real stuff, not a latex version). From what I've seen, the application and finish look similar. Has anyone used both? How do they compare?

Comments (7)

  • 15 years ago

    Have not yet used the chalk paint but have used milk paint and can tell you it is a complete PITA to work with. It's difficult to mix and get all the powder dissolved, it has to be continually remixed while you're working with it because it separates and once mixed it has a very short shelf life. If you make too much you are basically throwing out what you don't use immediately. It you make too little you pretty much don't have a prayer of matching what you mixed originally to finish your project. But don't let me talk you out of it!!

    I'm really looking forward to working with the chalk paint. I'm doing a chalk paint seminar with a few girlfriends.

  • 15 years ago

    Miss Mustard Seed tackled this topic, and frankly, I didn't see a huge difference except that the chalk paint is has a more reliable finish (sometimes the milk paint dries with a crackle finish). She didn't mention what dlm2000 said about milk paint, so I appreciate that info, especially the part about not being able to match it. But I've never used either, so I really have no idea.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Miss Mustard Seed milk vs chalk paint

  • 15 years ago

    The concept of using milk paint is more for historical purposes. Real milk paint is color based from earth pigments. This is why it looks so natural. It is also why faux painting came to be...trying to duplicate the wonderful and subtle finishes created.

    I was in awe of a NM home which used this on the interior adobe walls, trim, doors... and had a story of each color/painted room. It is how they create such beautiful bright colors for homes and artist paintings. Matching the same colors wasn't what one would need to do. Part of nature's landscape.

    Other than seeing the finishes, I haven't used it. The chalk paint I am still curious about. Even on large projects I use acrylic craft paint and swear the chalk paint is the same in application and finish. Craft paint goes on so smooth and never had an issue with wear.

  • 15 years ago

    Jan, did not realize those were chalk-painted. They look gorgeous. I was hoping to paint over the summer on a dresser we have, but I ran short of time. I guess I could make it a weekend project since it's in the guest room and not really being used.

  • 15 years ago

    I have used milk paint, so I am familiar with it (just not the chalk paint). With the milk paint I painted a bed and a rocking chair.

    I didn't find it that difficult to work with. In fact, I see it as very forgiving. It is true that you have to guess how much you will use since you can't save any unused paint once it is mixed (and I did end throwing some out). I love the milk paint finish--just wondering how the chalk paint compares.

  • 15 years ago

    One town over from us is a little mom and pop primitive furniture store. A friend of mine decorates that way so I went with her to one of their sales. The husband does all the painting and uses only milk paint applied using a spray gun. The pieces all have a wonderful finish. I wish I could remember the brand and all the steps he does in painting them. It made me want to try it.