Software
Houzz Logo Print
saw50st8

The Kitchen That Made Me Cry

14 years ago

Our friends just did a major home remodel and bumped out the back of their house to do a kitchen/master bedroom/master bathroom remodel.

We went to check it out on Saturday. I wanted to cry when I saw the kitchen. Not the good kind of cry either!

The kitchen is extremely large - I would say something like 25'X18' plus pantry off to the side and a separate eating area. Its a U-shaped kitchen with a center island. They have really nice fridge/freezer columns. Next to them is a dishwasher, followed by a sink then another dishwasher then another sink (its a kosher kitchen). Right behind those 2 sinks (with about 3.5' clearance) is another sink. So 3 sinks right near each other. On the other side of the U, there is no sink and its a FAR walk around.

The base cabinets are all 24" cabinets with doors and the kicker - 2 12" drawers above each one! It looked like there was a huge sale on 24" base cabinets because they had 7 of them lined up. It looked TERRIBLE.

The cabinets went all the way to the ceiling - sort of. There was a 12" flat piece of molding above the cabinets before the crown molding starting. It looked awful.

It almost made me literally cry for them. Its so not functional. They paid all this money for a kitchen that will be so hard to cook in.

My husband (who did very little research regarding flow and function of our kitchen) was flabbergasted when he saw it. It was that bad. There is not much nice I can say about it except they had nice granite.

Comments (18)

  • 14 years ago

    wish you'd pulled a linelle and snapped a picture!

  • 14 years ago

    Yikes! A neighbor of ours has the same floorplan as we do. The previous owners knocked out the peninsula and put an island. So you have to walk all the way around the island to get from the fridge to the sink. I think a designer told them "Islands are in" and they just went with it with no regard to the island being IN THE WAY as opposed to aiding in the flow.

  • 14 years ago

    It's just another problem with the disease known as TKO. This will not be the last one of these you see.

  • 14 years ago

    It's just awful that we can never look at a kitchen the same way again! :)

  • 14 years ago

    so true. Kitchen tours kind of bore me now. I used to like them, but then GW schooled me. And now, I'm usually just horrified at what the designer is swooning over while talking about his/her creation. And my dh is whispering "don't say a word" as he guides me out

    :0

  • 14 years ago

    It's just awful that we can never look at a kitchen the same way again!

    So true. Sometimes it makes me angry what designers and builders do to kitchens... and the people who use them. But most don't even know it's bad, so no use creating disappointment.

  • 14 years ago

    It sounds like that's a kitchen that had a lot of room to work with and could have used a better use of the space. I'm guessing that its a pretty high-end kitchen as well.

    That said, when I look at other kitchens, I really try to keep it in perspective of what the budget was and if its a remodel to the existing space. Moving load bearing walls and windows is not an inexpensive task. Sometimes you do the best you can with what you have to work with.

  • 14 years ago

    re: 24" cabinets with doors and 2 X 12" drawers -- oh, that DOES sound terrible.

    RE: fridge and sink on opposite ends with island in between.

    I see this a lot, or else stove and sink on opposite ends with an island in between.
    Is this considered good kitchen design as long as there is a prep sink to create a mini-work triangle?

    Or maybe the concept of 'work triangle' is passe?

  • 14 years ago

    It makes me sad because with that budget their kitchen should have been AMAZING. I wish I had asked to see their layout to critique!

    I didnt have my camera on me. If they post one of facebook, I will totally show it here. Its a sad looking kitchen.

  • 14 years ago

    Mini work triangles, or sometimes rectangles ;-) create zones, which are very 'in' and in my own experience, work wonderfully... The one single work triangle is not the most efficient, especially in large kitchens, as described here, or often in kitchens with islands, so you could say that is passe. The single work triangle tends to be a one-person workspace, and requires using one sink for every task. It also means there could be lots of cross-traffic as more than one person, cook or not, try to access the fridge, sink, or whatever. Some kitchens don't have room for anything more.

  • 14 years ago

    2 12" drawers above each one!

    *ACK* That sounds like my hubby's house when I met him. Except he only had 2 drawers, and they were that small. I wasn't even TKO then, but I could see the kitchen was a dog. I asked him, "How do you even fit all your flatware and utensils in here?" I was glad that he sold that house to his brother after we married.

    Only two piddly drawers?? The horror! ;)

    On the brighter side, what kind of granite did your friends have in their new kitchen?

  • 14 years ago

    Sorry, I'm a newbie in the middle of my first construction project (kitchen/mudroom/powder room gut)...what is a TKO??

  • 14 years ago

    TKO = Totally Kitchen Obsessed
    I had to look it up when I was a newbie too but oh, how quickly we all become TKO.

  • 14 years ago

    I think it took about a week before I hit the TKO stage.

    My friend is building a new house, but just moved out there where it will be. It was a sudden thing. I have tried my best to convince her to post her plans here, the sketch she drew for me was a big kitchen that could be fabulous if it works right.

  • 14 years ago

    Is your friend happy with her kitchen? That's what really matters. Just because you don't like it doesn't make it a bad kitchen. People on this forum are definitely obsessed and often snobbish about other people's kitchens.

  • 14 years ago

    This forum embraces kitchens at any budget. However, it does have a bias against poorly laid out and/or non functional kitchens. That's a far cry from snobbish.

  • 14 years ago

    'And my dh is whispering "don't say a word" as he guides me out'

    lol! so funny! I can just imagine it too.

    It didn't take me long here to find out how much I didn't know about a kitchen. One of those rooms I've spent a huge section of my adult life in. Even a lot of my younger yrs. I was cooking at 8 or 9. but we always just had to make do with whatever the kitchen was like when we moved in. I never even knew of anyone who 'redid' a kitchen until about 4 yrs ago! (other than repaint walls and cabs, new flooring).

    it's amazing what there is to know to get a good kitchen!

  • 14 years ago

    They haven't really used their kitchen because they just moved back in.

    If they had only turned the island sink so the faucet was on the other side, it would make the kitchen 1,000 times more functional.

    They did tell me they feel like their kitchen designer didn't listen to them at all. I was wondering why they listened to her then and ordered the cabinets.

    I believe the granite is Bianco Antico.