Software
Houzz Logo Print
cindaintx

Really light stained cabinets anyone?

15 years ago

My plan for many months has been to have my new shaker style maple cabinets stained dark, almost a milk chocolate color....marble counters, light backsplash. We have red oak floors throughout the downstairs that have a natural finish with no stain. There will be a maple butcher block top (already ordered) on the island.

Well, the cabinets were installed last week and are beautiful. Now I'm questioning the dark route. Will they be overwhelming in dark brown? They are so beautiful in their unfinished "blond" state. Does anyone have very light maple cabinets? with light floors of another wood?

(and yes, part of the problem was that I didn't know enough to insist that the cabinets come from a shop who finishes them in their spray room, and that maple is hard to stain - especially to get it dark. GC lacks experience with stained cabinets but I didn't learn that until too late.)

Comments (5)

  • 15 years ago

    Have you seen the bright wood kitchens thread? There are some pictures of really beautiful natural wood kitchens. Will your island be stained or painted to be different from the maple cabinets & butcher block? I think that could be very pretty.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Show me pics of your bright, wood kitchens!!

  • 15 years ago

    Few things....

    You are correct, maple is hard to stain dark. "Hard" isn't really the word - most dark stains will be blotchy on maple and will simply look bad. For a maple vanity I'm currently building, that was originally going to be light, I am using wood dye (dark walnut) instead of stain to get it dark and my test batches look good. So if you must go dark, I would consider using a dye. However, if your cabinet maker is not experienced in dyes, well, maybe it's not such a good idea.

    MAKE SURE that you run some test batches on matching maple wood that is not part of your cabinets. The cabinet builder should be able to bring over some scrap wood with examples of stains or dyes.

    Some like the look of maple that has simply been finished (not stained). However, you will see a lot of color variation in the wood, and the look is more casual/country than sophisticated. Depends what you like.

    I cannot imagine why any cabinet builder would install unfinished cabinets and then finish them. Many or even most cabinet builders have spray booths that make the finishing process much easier, plus they can use the catalytic finishes that look great and are really really hard and durable. Heck, I built my own cabinets and I finished them before I installed them. I had a room set up with no air circulation - I didn't spray, but I did control the airflow and dust so my brush-on finish would not have dust in it. I would *insist* that when they apply the finish they allow 24 hours of no air circulation in the house to minimize the dust.

    Below are my lightly stained finished cabinets. The color we used was Salem by General Finishes (you can get it at Rockler or Woodcraft stores). The flooring is bamboo (Teragren Synergy Java) which has light highlights that pick up the cabinet colors.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks vate for your beautiful pictures, and to jessicaml for the link -yes I have looked obsessively at those kitchens, the thread seemed to move into bright kitchens no matter what the cabinet color was...in fact. I saw my inspiration Jennifer Gilmore kitchen there, dark cabs and all. I was hoping for a few more blond wood light cabinets and light floor people. But all those in the thread are beautiful!

  • 15 years ago

    We had maple cabinets with just a clear finish, no stain. Over time, the wood tends to yellow with exposure to light. We have partial overlay cabinets and after a few years, you could see where the wood had yellowed when you opened the cabinet doors. We loved the original light finish, not so much the yellowed version.

    We are in the process of updating our kitchen and have refinished them in a medium/dark color. Yes, maple will blotch unless the finisher has a strategy to deal with it. Our first finishing contractor said he knew how to handle it, but ended up nearly ruining the cabinets. Six weeks of work later, after we repaired his mistakes, our second contractor did a fantastic job. He tried a variety of techniques on scrap wood till he found what would give us the color we were looking for. Ours was a little tricky as we had both the original cabinets and some new construction that had to be finished to match.

    We talked to at least 6 finishing contractors about doing the job, and each one had a slightly different method of getting the color right. Using a wood conditioner to control blotching, doing a light pre-stain then adding color to the lacquer coats, using dye instead of stain, or sealing the bare wood then putting color on only with the lacquer coats were some of the methods suggested.

    Just be sure to get the test samples done on your scrap wood to make sure the color is what you want.

  • 15 years ago

    Anna, thanks for sharing your experience. That's what I am afraid of. You probably saved me a bunch of money down the road when they turned too yellow.