Software
Houzz Logo Print
smmc_gw

Help with kitchen design, cabinets, and etc!

17 years ago

Help! Things are getting complicated! The project started out as simply replacing our old appliances, and installing new flooring and countertops, but the new appliances looked so good that we decided to check into ditching the 50 year old refaced cabinets too.

We have been using Home Depot, and are impressed with our kitchen designer. We have a 10x18 room and the existing kitchen covers only 10x9 of the space, so ideally we expand into the current unneeded eating area. We want to minimize relocation of walls, appliances or utilities to reduce costs. The KD came up with a design that moves only the sink and DW. However, that puts our triangle at about 27 feet with 12 feet from cooktop to sink; the KD thinks that is ok given our layout, but weÂre not sure so weÂve added a bar sink at the opposite end. We are looking at using Kraftmaid cabinets in cherry, cost for 23 cabinets not including install is about $17,500 after promotions and before tax. Its 15% more if we use painted or glazed, which we like and are considering.

So here are the issues we are grappling with, any assistance that you helpful folks can provide is much appreciated:

--How can we improve the design, and should we revise it to reduce the triangle and remove one or both doors which we can live without. The HD designer doesnÂt think that it can be done without a lot of structural changes, additional cabinets and other expenses. HereÂs the design illustration:

">

--Lots of folks here advise checking into custom cabinets and other cabinet makers. To do that, HD says it costs $500 to get a copy of their plans, right now we have only printouts of their design illustrations. Or can we do it with just illustrations? Any recommendations on specific cabinetmakers & designers here in Marin County CA, or how best to find them?

--How do we minimize the install cost on this? The current approach is to get a detailed bid from HDÂs contractor (in process) for construction and installation. With the HD bid, we expect to shop around with other contractors and subs, and to figure out how much we can DIY.

Thanks!

Comments (11)

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with the addition of the prep sink. It creates 2 different work zones so tasks and workers can happen/work simultaneously.

    Could it be advantageous to swap the fridge and oven with the stove so that you can take advantage of the bumpout space and get the stove a little more protection from traffic? I worry a little about the dw door being open in front of the garage entrance, if it's used a lot. It's also unfortunate to have the cleanup area and dish storage at the far end of the room from your dining space...

    Oh, I guess you weren't actually looking for layout critique, so I hope you can get more of the answers you're seeking.

  • 17 years ago

    I think the triangle is too big and having to cross the path to the garage would annoy me. The work triangle is right in the middle of a larger traffic triangle. I would reduce the cost of cabinets, appliances, and whatever else to move walls and get a good layout. But then, I'm not selling you the the cabinets or the appliances.

    Would you consider IKEA cabinets? There are downloadable kitchen planners.

  • 17 years ago

    I would go to the ikea website and download their kitchen planner and play around with moving stuff around. It is quite challenging to design a small kitchen and you want to make sure you have given this enough thought.

  • 17 years ago

    Definitely switch the refrigerator/ovens w/the range. Right now, the range is in one of the most used paths through the kitchen. It's also at a "pinch point" at the corner w/the peninsula...not a situation you want while cooking w/flame, hot foods, steam, etc.

    When designing a kitchen, one of the primary things to attempt is to protect the range/cooktop. In this case, the move would be even better b/c then it will be near the prep sink...no crossing aisles to drain boiling pasta water and convenient for prepping near the range.

    This move will also put the refrigerator & MW closer to the periphery of the kitchen so outside snackers will not interfere much w/the work going on in the kitchen.

    I have some concern about the DW...it opens into the Garage doorway...dangerous if it's open while people are coming/going through that door.

    As to cost....in our state (MD), if you purchase both the cabinets/appliances and installation through a place like HD there's no sales tax...so you will be saving there if that's the same in your state.

  • 17 years ago

    Which one or two doors can you remove? Does that include the garage door? Where would access to the garage be? Closing off a doorway basically involves some extremely minor framing, drywall, and paint. Would you need to construct a new one (also a small job as long as no plumbing's in the way or other special problem)?

    On the face of it, I would tend not to want to close off the door to the living room as that would make it effectively a dead-end space (in most cases undesirable for a variety of reasons); but, again on the face of it, getting garage traffic out of your kitchen work area could be a real plus.

    Oh, by the way, agreeing with what others have said, the plan presented would not work at all for me without a prep sink. As is, prep would be done at either the sink area or the stove area, moving between those two critical points, with forays over to the fridge and peninsula gathering junk mail. I know I wouldn't be working there, because it's out of the way and would have me perambulating constantly to and from it to the critical work points. So, I'm thinking a prep sink would be critically necessary for this plan to create that a complete prep area at that end.

    I also agree with moving the stove to the fridge side. But...CAN you lose that garage door to some nice functional other place? With a continuous counter, you'd have a very smooth and functional pantry/fridge to prep counter to stove to cleanup flow.

  • 17 years ago

    can you push the pantry back into the closet area? then run the cabinet/counter to the right of the sink over to the 'new' pantry door? move the dw to the right of the sink.

    you'll lose the cab/counter running to the side of the sink but will gain a straight stretch of it.

    sink will be opened into the rest of kitchen and dw door will not be a problem w/ the garage door.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for all the great suggestions, sorry for the delay in responding. We hadnÂt considered swapping the cooktop with the refrigerator & oven, but that makes sense. Also we hadnÂt thought of the problem of having the DW next to the garage door, the good news is the door opens out. That door can be removed as we have a second access door from the garage. We also have considered removing both the LR and garage doors, and getting rid of the pantry and entry closet to get a rectangular space. Then we could move the appliances down toward the sink and make a tighter triangle. However, it makes everything farther from the dining area, and the space at the right side would have to be filled in with more $cabinets, or what else? WeÂll check the Ikea site, unfortunately nothingÂs cheap in CA so its 9.5% sales tax on the cabinets. Do the custom cabinet makers charge sales tax too?

  • 17 years ago

    Smmc, removing the door to the living room would change the feel and dynamics of both rooms, plus all the other spaces around. You should benefit, or at least not lose, from all the changes.

    Regarding how to put in more linear feet of cabinets without blowing the budget--how about losing some of the uppers?! Your storage wall across the way would hold stuff close by. Especially in a compact area like yours, leaving at least some open wall space would open the whole room up and gives it a wonderful spacious feel. My Danish daughter-in-law, who's lived in France as well as Denmark, says my kitchen feels "European." I've never been in a private Continental kitchen, and my house is 2 years old, not 200, so I suspect its main distinction is that it just doesn't feel like a standard American builders kitchen, something I attribute entirely to not installing uppers over my work counter. It's very standard and inexpensive otherwise. I also saved a lot of money that way.

  • 17 years ago

    We originally went to Home Depot too. Then a neighbor told us about the custom cabinet maker they used. Our cabinet maker does not advertise or even have his name on the door, so the only way to find him is word of mouth. But he does work for high end restaurants like Capital Grill, high-end homes, clients like Tony Dungy and Dick Vitalle. Needless to say, we were very surprised when his quote came back LESS than Home Depot! After going through all the design with HD just to get a quote, the cabinet maker came in, spent about 3 hours with us, took measurements, asked a lot of questions and bounced around ideas. Then a couple days later he gave us a fixed price quote...before doing any design! The design came after we committed to using him, but pretty much anything goes. Like you, HD added money for distressing, more money for glazing, more money for lazy susan and verticle pull-outs, more for crown molding, more for encased bottoms (for flush mount lights). All this type of thing was no added cost with our custom cabinet maker. Plus, he had tons of experience working with designers and had fantastic ideas. I'd suggest you ask at a local high-end restaurant, neighbors, local "Parade of Homes" open house, etc. to find a local cabinet maker.

    Regarding you layout, folks here asked me to provide a view of the larger living area. It's hard to say without understand your traffic flow. I'm tempted to suggest placing the cooktop where one of the sinks is located, and to make the area with your cooktop an island with no upper cabinets to open things up. In fact, maybe swap the cooktop and one of the sinks.

  • 17 years ago

    Do you have a "flat"/2-D view? It's easier to see what's what and you have a better scale view.

    I wouldn't close off the LR...the garage maybe, if you can still bring in groceries easily from the garage to the kitchen. The "biggest bang" would be the garage door closure...that would be a great expanse of counter & added base cabinetry. I would still put the range where the refrigerator is now as it will be even more protected w/o garage traffic.

    If you eliminate upper cabinets, I would definitely keep the pantry as I think you'll need that storage space. It's not a bad idea to eliminate some with your kitchen (narrow space at sink end). What you could do if you don't need the closet, is make the pantry flush w/the sink run...

    Never mind, this view is distorted...it looked like you would have a large space for the pantry, but you would only have a 24" depth....although, is that what you planned anyway? That closet + pantry looks to be only 5' deep... Do you need the closet? Could you make the whole area the pantry?


    Have you thought about something completely different? Something like these....

    Note: There's a 6" broom closet pullout in both...see IkeaFans links in the linked thread for how to make it DIY. It's 4" on IkeaFans, but you may need 6" for your refrigerator to open fully. If you need 12", then you could either just get a 12" pullout utility cabinet or build a 12" broom closet.

    OR

    Here is a link that might be useful: Thread: 4'' Broom Closet from Ikeafans

  • 17 years ago

    Again thanks for the great comments, and especially buel for the designs! rosie, I like your comments, do you have a picture of your kitchen? flhomes, very interesting that you got a custom quote before the design, and it makes sense regarding pricing. It seems like only half our cabinet cost at HD is for base cabinets, the rest is extras and nonstandard items. We will get started looking into some custom makers.

    buel, thanks for the comments and designs, we like them. Sorry no 2D layout, will try to get one tomorrow. The existing pantry is 19" deep, your idea to move the door is nice. We could live without the closet but prefer not to, since its at the front door. By eliminating that door to the garage, it would also seem to allow the appliances to move down nearer the sink to reduce the triangle and eliminate the prep sink. But given the long expanse of cabinets & prep area that are on the right side, guess its still desirable. If we remove the door to the LR (we have another LR entry about 10Â to the right of the kitchen), maybe we could keep the appliances on the same side as now. The cost to move all the electrical and plumbing is a concern, but we should get some idea of that tomorrow when we get HDs installation bid.

    Thanks!