Software
Houzz Logo Print
mtnfever

Motawi 2nds! & Mural for BS? Pls help (long)

Last month I was able to go to the famed Motawi Seconds Room and snagged three more Pine Landscapes for 60% off-- MAJOR score and I was very excited to have all my star BS tiles--and thanks to circuspeanut who talked about Motawi! Then DH and I went to one of the U of M hospitals to visit one of his friends and lo, each floor had a Motawi mural in the elevator lobbies and all were different. Coincidentally (I think not!), the mural on his friend's floor was the Pine Landscape. Here are my Motawis (along with potential field tiles and laminate counter colors) and a shot of the whole mural. I apologize if the pics are big but otherwise it can be hard to see the detail if your eyes are as getting old as mine are.

I'm planning a DIY mini-facelift for my 1982 galley kitchen in all its beige and golden oak um, glory?..., which is staying because there's way too much in the entire house to even think about painting or staining. I would love your input but if you're feeling nauseous about a houseful of golden oak, I understand, and please feel free to move along to the next thread. The only thing I *might* do to reduce golden oak exposure :) is put opaque frosted glass in the few upper cabs that I have.

Thus, the only things changing in this kitchen are the backsplash, counters, and sink. The vintage sink was discussed in the thread some of you may recall http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg1012393112808.html). The backsplash will be green tile with the Motawi tiles but I'm not sure if the mural will work or not. Counters will be very plain laminate but I'm not sure what color. Here are a couple of mockups that I did:

For the backsplash, I had been planning to have plain solid green field tile (either 4x4 or 6x6 are available) surrounding the Pine Landscapes. Once I saw the mural, I immediately wondered if I could use the pattern for a backsplash. Do you think it would be too busy? Or too Arts/Craftsman for my transitional contemporary rustic home? Or possibly too copyright infringing?? Do you think the plain field tiles in green would be better? In 6x6 or 4x4 or other size suggestions? To be fair, the mural field tiles will be Talavera, not Motawi. If y'all think the mural in concept would be ok, then I'll get a few correctly sized Talavera tiles for another sample review.

For the counter, I prefer Ikea Numerar laminate Aluminum with Metal Effect Edge which provides (I think) a more contemporary cool color along with the also vintage-y metal edge look. I know I'll be able to see things on these light counters, even in December when the sun sets at 3:30pm in our narrow mountain valley. Also, the cooktop and wall oven are stainless steel cool (as in color tone, not as in Cool Dude) too. Do you think a cool color can work in this kitchen?

Or, do I need to stay in the warm color family? Possibly a warmer brown to help the golden oak blend (per Marcolo in the Keeping the Golden Oak DAT-thank you!). Formica Earthen Warp, Chocolate Warp, and Dark Chocolate MicroDot are the current brown candidates. I like the Earthen Warp since it's lighter but the Chocolate Warp does provide a nice dark contrast to the lighter cab, backsplash, and floor colors around it and also ties to the floor grout and could tie to the BS grout if I matched it. I think the warp pattern harkens back to the sink's 1948 vintage.

Please let me know, what do you think? Thanks to all to who've read this far!

Comments (12)

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I love the mural and think the Arts and Crafts theme looks great with your oak cabinets! But I'm not anti-golden oak, either :)

    The mural looks so good, I'd definitely use it behind the cooktop and at least as an accent on the rest of the backsplash. I think you have to tie in the mural (and other colors of greens and blue) on the sink wall, too.

    The stainless steel countertop looks amazing, with the backsplash. I'm not really fond of brown, with wood cabinets and the stainless steel looks so good, with the appliances and that cool vintage sink!

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Thank you, LL! One vote for the mural, yay! Hmm, and a mini-mural on the sink wall...7'' high? Here's another mockup. The Talavera tile that I can afford for the mural is too shiny for the sink wall window ledge--blinding in the sun.

    Unfortunately, the ''stainless steel countertop'' is actually the Ikea laminate brushed aluminum but I'm glad it looked good. I did try for actual SS counters but DH wouldn't go for them.

    cheers

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Oh, I know it's Ikea laminate...I was talking about the 'color' and that it looks so much better with the mural and wood...and the white dishwasher. I think it will also look better with the floor, instead of another tan or brown.

    This is going to be a fun kitchen! Best of luck with the remodel :)

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Thanks for the encouragement, LL. Good luck to you on your evolved-through-the-decades kitchen!

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Thanks! :)

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    mtnfever
    I love the tiles. I couldn't resist playing with them just to see if they could be lined up this way. Not a viable idea for your spaces, nothing I would do with them, but just couldn't resist. So, FWIW


    Sandra

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Oh I really like what Bellsmom did! That layout would look great over the cooktop!

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Oh, I love Motawi tiles!! Can't wait to see your finished BS. I used Motawi accent in our fireplace surround. The only thing to be aware of is the Motawi tiles are much thicker than regular tiles. Be sure your installer knows how to handle that.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    @Bellsmom, thanks for going to the trouble of putting together a pic! The dark green does make the picture tile stand out more.

    @kaiju, Having the tiles in a row would be pretty much the same 36" as the cooktop and exhaust hood except the 4x8 is really one tile, not two 4x4s, so the lack of symmetry would make me crazy.

    @joyce, I love these tiles! There were several more Pine Landscapes in different sizes that were very tempting. When DH told his group of friends in Ann Arbor that I had gone to ''a tile store'', one of them said that it must be Motawi and boy was DH in trouble LOL. I'll definitely have different tile thicknesses. We have a good friend who does excellent tile work that I'm hoping to work the backsplash into his schedule. A good enough friend that he'll tell me if he doesn't want to do it rather than doing a unhappy job. How did you handle the different tile thicknesses for your fireplace surround?

    thanks for your comments!

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Those are sooooo BEAUTIFUL...so serene....Lucky you! :)

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I think the mural would look great in your kitchen. I
    One of my friends kitchen is on their website - how cool!

    We are so fortunate to have 2 high end tile companies in SE Michigan, but out of my price range, so just get to see the motawi tiles at UM hospital and pewabic tiles at Mott childrens hospital. I even had a chance to make one of tiles for the new children's hospital.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Thanks, annsch and a2gemini! I'm glad you think the tiles and the mural will go ok in my kitchen.

    cheers