Software
Houzz Logo Print
emma823_gw

Egads! Not completely satisfied with kitchen floorplan. Help plz

16 years ago

Hi,

I am at wits end as we have gone back and forth with architect and city planning 2 times already (additional $3k in wasted architect fees). Here's the current ground floor plans and we can't seem to figure out a way to have the kitchen and family room be one large open space without sacrificing the functionality of the family room. I've been an avid long time reader of those much more experienced than I in GW and hope someone can help. Our current plans have the kitchen and dining room sharing the open space which is acceptable since we plan to have good amount of family/friends over for meals. However, we prefer to open up the kitchen to the family room instead, and lead out to the backyard. The issue that we can't get around is that the family room is somewhat narrow (22'x13') and if we open up the wall between kitchen, then it would be difficult to have the family enjoy watching TV in that room with seating. Any ideas? Here is a link to the floorplan for first floor.

http://picasaweb.google.com/106506743807018684470/Desktop#5492862285364379634

Comments (24)

  • 16 years ago

    Here's the floorplan (check the READ ME for instructions on how to post images inline).

    I find the shapes of the rooms a bit difficult too, so I'm not surprised that you're having trouble. The front room is good sized, if I'm reading correctly, so can stand on its own pretty well. Do you want/need a formal dining room? Because when I look at the plan, I want to open up the whole thing past the front room, except for the hall wall by the powder room. I'd leave that.

    Then I'd put the kitchen area where the current dining room is, and move the dining table to the back windows if there's a pleasant view or garden prospect. That would leave the space in between for family room stuff, and that hall wall, for an entertainment system. It's a great interior flat wall, and gives room for people to pass without walking through. The issue then is working around the slider, which I'd be tempted to turn into a window, or make into a single door on the up page side.

    But I might be entirely wrong. Maybe the beauty view is out the lefthand slider and the table really belongs there.

  • 16 years ago

    then you've been had by those architects...

    how much changing do you wanna do? I'd redo a lot of it.
    do you have kids? is the stairway going up or down?

    is the glass door by the dining table used much? will it be?
    if that doorway isn't used so much I'd put the stove on the wall shared with the LR, put the fridge over to the left of where you have the stove, move the sink some to the left of where it is (don't see a dw there either?) and make the window bigger.

    you could move the kitchen a foot or so 'south' giving that extra foot or so to the FR. is the very, very skinny 'block' in the FR behind the stove the tv?

    put an island turned opposite of what you show now - don't know if seating will fit. then I'd totally do away with the wall on the far right of the kitchen and put the table and chairs there.

    i'd move the stairway 'north' to where you have the PR toilet and your shower. move your bath partially into the area of the pr and the part opening into kitchen would be pantry (or w/d).

    i'd have the entry door from the garage go straight in at the top of the steps and the area to the far right in the mudroom (don't know what you have there) the PR.

    what are the squares in the mudroom? w/d? i'd put that on the north wall of the mudroom (or off the kitchen and pantry in mudroom).

    the kitchen would then be open to the FR from the right of the fridge on over...

    btw, if the glass doors on the left in the kitchen area can be deleted you could put a big window there and run cabs all along that wall and around on the wall shared with the LR.

    it's hard to know how things will fit w/o measurements.

  • 16 years ago

    A few things immediately...

    First, I would leave the FR/Kitchen/DR order b/c I like having a view & windows in the FR...they're not as important in a DR, to me. We spend much more time in the FR than the DR. When in the DR, it's to eat a meal, not enjoy the view. But, that's me and my family...maybe yours is different. If you have a view in the DR, that's great! But, if you have to choose b/w the DR & FR having a "view", I would choose the FR. Plus, the extra windows will bring in more natural light to the FR.

    Desk...do you really need/want a desk in the kitchen? Most people take desks out when remodeling b/c they find they're nothing more than clutter magnets. Even if you keep it, there isn't enough room for the chair...the aisle is too narrow.

    It would be a lot easier if we had all the measurements, window/wall/doorway widths and the distances b/w those windows/walls/doorways...unless they're all movable/changeable. If that's the case, then it makes it easier to find a solution for you. Give me some time to work on something for you!

    Next, the Mudroom/Laundry Room. It's really too small to function as both and I see a Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde thing going on...not knowing what it really is!

    I would separate the Mudroom & Laundry Room into two rooms. Think about it, do you really want people coming into your house and seeing your dirty laundry...even close friends (or your children's friends)? Even clean laundry? You need room to sort dirty clothing, whether you use piles on the floor or bins (freestanding or inside cabinets) as well as room to fold/sort clean laundry for the family.

    In the Mudroom, you need room to hang jackets, backpacks, etc. as well as a place for muddy shoes/cleats/boots, sandals, hats, gloves. You may even want a closet to hang all the family coats, jackets, etc. so a closet by the front door can be reserved for guests. Oh, and a bench to sit at while removing shoes/boots/cleats as well as a place for purses, keys, & mail/packages would also be very useful.

    Can the exterior walls be changed? I'm thinking you might want to move the garage out some to accommodate either the Laundry Room or Mudroom b/w the current front hall and the current garage wall. Then the other room (Laundry Room or Mudroom) can go where the current one is.

    I'm thinking 5 or 6 feet...then those 5 or 6 feet could be incorporated into the Kitchen & FR or FR & Bathroom (behind the PR) & BR closet or break up the extra 6' and distribute to various rooms.


    Let us know just how flexible you are...and then we can "go to town" with it!

  • 16 years ago

    I'd put a half wall where the stove is, so you can see into the family room. A downdraft vent might be a good idea. Replace the family room slider with a single glass door on the left. Put the TV/entertainment space on the wall to the right (bedroom 4). This will allow you to see your guests and still let them watch TV :)

  • 16 years ago

    Using a downdraft even as I type this...don't do it!

    (Dacor telescoping downdraft)

  • 16 years ago

    I wonder if you could just flip the kitchen upside down? You could also flank the cooktop with windows on the exterior wall and put the sink in the peninsula.

    One thing that stood out right away was the direct sightline into the master bedroom. Can you build a little foyer for it?

  • 16 years ago

    thanks so much everyone! I will take all this feedback back and talk things over with family. I'll also provide more detailed drawings with dimensions and answer questions.

  • 16 years ago

    What about something like this? I put two options for the frig and the master bedroom entry. This also has two full size couches rather than a love seat.

    Also, in your original plan, the window behind the couch will always cause a glare on the TV. In this plan, it's on the wall to the left of the chair. People at the island can swivel around to see it as well.

    Oops, I see the island is a little to long to allow for proper clearance on that right side.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi, first of all, full disclosure, I know nothing about layouts, planning, that is why I am here, for help with my own dilemna....

    That being said, what is the hallway behind your kitchen where the powder room is? Could you move the PR door over by the entry/stairway and make the kitchen extend that far over? Then the opening to the FR would be an extra three feet or so, however wide that hall is.

    And, by personal experience, I STRONGLY advise against a desk of any kind in the kitchen! I have a very nice one, and can NOT wait to get it out of my kitchen layout. I don't use the computer there, it's on my counter if needed for a recipe. It's not in the way, but visible, and it seems to gather all the clutter and in turn, makes my kithen look like it, but then, I'm OCD and a neat freak.

    Good luck, you will get your answers here, I'm sure!

  • 16 years ago

    Hi,

    Thanks for all the help everyone! I should probably mention that we are trying not to alter any outside walls as we already went to planning department and gotten neighborhood approval. I think it's ok to move a few windows/doors, but not move exterior walls. Not sure if this matters or not, but the downstairs master bedroom/bath are for in-laws as we have another master br/ba upstairs along with 3 other bedrooms and an additional bath.

    Windows sizes:
    2 - 4'x 3'6"
    3 - 6'x 4'
    4 - 6'x 4'
    5 - 6'x 4'

    Room Dimensions (for the ones that aren't noted already)
    Laundry/Mudroom - 10' x 5' without the w/d nook
    Hallway between kitchen and half bath - 3'

    Here are the larger plans and dimensions that hopefully help.

    Top half of first floor

    Bottom half of first floor

    Here are some of the questions and our stances:

    1. Do you want/need a formal dining room? We live in a more traditional area where formal dining rooms are the norm for larger homes. We were originally ok with an open kitchen/dining space as we eat as a family (one 2 yr old daughter and grandparents) every dinner.

    2. Thanks for all the suggestions, but we would like the keep the kitchen in the current location (with some flexibility on shifting it down towards existing formal dining room by a 1 ft.

    3. Formal dining room slider - since the front door was just a single door, we thought it would be nice to offer another wide entry/exit from other than in the back of the home. There's not going to be a view per se as it's about a 6' clearance to fence.

    4. how much changing do you wanna do? We'd prefer to limit the changes to DR, kitchen , and family room (perhaps wall between Master Bedroom and FR). Moving the stairway would be too dramatic for all the discussions / changes that we've already gone through . Sorry!

    5. is the very, very skinny 'block' in the FR behind the stove the tv? Yes, that is what was originally planned.

    6. Removing right wall of current kitchen - we didn't like how there was a clear view to closet and bathroom/powder room doors, so we'd like to keep some divider there.

    7 what are the squares in the mudroom? w/d? Yes, the nook is for the washer and dryer. Perhaps this will only be a laundry room and not a mudroom if we cannot fit the seating for true mudroom.

    8. I would leave the FR/Kitchen/DR order b/c I like having a view & windows in the FR...they're not as important in a DR, to me. Agree!

    9. Desk...do you really need/want a desk in the kitchen? No, it is definitely optional.

    1. One thing that stood out right away was the direct sightline into the master bedroom. Can you build a little foyer for it? We are locked into the exterior walls and since this is the "in-law" master br, I think we'd prefer to save the floor space for other common areas.

    2. Houseful - thanks a lot for the visual and we like where you are going with the Kitchen/LR!!! Any reason...

  • 16 years ago

    forgot to add.. yes, currently the dishwasher is between the sink and fridge, and we're planning to put a wine fridge below the island somewhere.

  • 16 years ago

    I also really like what Houseful has done...it makes much more sense than what your architect came up with! Not only do you preserve the "formal" DR that is prevalent/expected in your region by adding the middle wall, but with the two doors it also opens it up some.

    Instead of the desk, though, I would consider a pantry...

    As to refrigerator location, I like the one on the right wall. This would keep the Prep & Cooking Zones completely separated from the Cleanup Zone (ideal) as well as provide plenty of wall space on the left wall for dishes, etc. That also means dish storage will be close to both the DR for setting the table and the Cleanup Zone/sink/DW for putting dishes away (also ideal).

    Using Houseful's as a starting point...how about something like this?

    • It has a Message Center centrally located to the commonly most used rooms for the family...b/w the Kitchen & FR but near the family entrance (garage). Here you can have a calendar, a place to hang keys, a temporary place for mail/packages/purse, locate your landline/answering machine, and, in the base cabinet, directories/phone book, notepads, pens/pencils/tape/stapler/etc.

    There is also a Beverage Center on the periphery of the Kitchen near the FR. People can use the Beverage Center w/o interfering with those working in the kitchen. At the same time, it's near a water source for the Tea/Coffee machine (assuming you drink tea or coffee) as well near storage for glasses for wine & other beverages.
    It also has a 12" utility pullout for your broom, dustpan, etc. More centrally located than the Laundry Room/Mudroom.

    The utility cabinet also acts as the "filler" necessary b/w the wall and refrigerator to ensure the refrigerator doors will open fully.
    The pantry is a "drywalled" pantry that's 54" wide w/15" deep shelves. I show sliding doors, but you could use french doors or bi-fold as well. The sliding doors take up the least amount of aisle width, that's why I put them in. However, it's up to you what you want to do (assuming you keep it, of course!)

    Note that drywalled pantries not only cost less than pantry cabinets, they also hold much more since you can utilize the entire space...floor-to-ceiling and wall-to-wall. Additionally, the majority of us here agree that 15" is about the maximum depth that's truly useful...everything fits, including small appliances (all my small appliances fit on 12" deep shelves except the toaster oven), and the shelves aren't too deep...so things are easy to see/find/reach and do not get lost.

    On the top shelf, you could store rolls of paper towels...light-weight and relatively easy to get to. You will probably want a small stool/step ladder to access that shelf and that stool/ladder will also be useful for accessing the top shelves of your upper cabinets.
    The trash & recycle pullout is located so it's easily accessed from all three of the primary work zones...Prep, Cooking, and Cleanup. It's also...

  • 16 years ago

    Wow! Layout #2 looks wonderful (I like the snack center) and everyone needs a utility/broom closet.

    This may already have been mentioned, but why not take down the wall between the LR and DR and have one big airy space? This would be about the same size as the kitchen/family room and you'd have two large, open areas to entertain.

  • 16 years ago

    Houseful, thanks again for kicking off this vision. buehl, can't thank you enough for putting in the time to suggest the detailed kitchen layout. Please let us know if either of you are in Bay Area. We are checking with structural engineer now on opening up the wall and already gave the architect the heads up that we want to change the layout to match your suggestions. We feel sooo much better with everything if our floor plan can be updated this way. We'll keep everyone posted on outcome and pictures once we finish! I'm sure we'lll have more questions on cabinetry (white insets are planned), and appliances/fixtures. THANKS EVERYONE!

  • 16 years ago

    I'm glad you like it! Most of it came from Houseful who, btw, helped me with my kitchen as well when I was a newbie! She and several others also completely re-vamped my kitchen and finally convinced me an island would just not work in my kitchen.

  • 16 years ago

    Oh, there was one change I meant to make to Layout 2...change the aisle b/w the range & island to 42". This is particularly important b/c there is a high probability of two or more people working in that aisle (prepping & cooking) and a 42" aisle is really the bare minimum you need for two people. 48" would be better, but then there's not enough room b/w the island and the FR wall.

    You might consider taking 3" from the DR just in case the walls don't go up exactly as planned...those 3" would be "wiggle room" for the cabinetry.

    (If you notice, there's a bit of room b/w the walls & cabinets...if you have frameless or framed/full overlay that bit of filler will be needed to ensure the drawers all open w/o scraping the walls. If you put doors in the base cabinets instead, then you will probably need even more filler to allow the doors to open fully...unless the walls are not as deep as the cabinets.)

  • 16 years ago

    Just saw this. Thanks again buehl!!!! If anyone has master bathroom planning experience, I put up another stumper

  • 16 years ago

    So glad it's coming together for you. Please post pics of your progress.

    Beuhl - I have my general kitchen plan finished, but when it's time to order cabinets, I am going to need lots of help from you! ;D

  • 16 years ago

    I will keep folks updated. Once my bathroom plan gets figured out , i'll post the final plans and will start with before, during and after pics after I finally get approvals.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks to you guys, we had the confidence to go against our architects plans and go with your kitchen/family combination. CanÂt express how grateful we are. SoÂ..hereÂs the layout Âthis took forever since not really familiar with softwareÂ

    1. Any initial thoughts on layout? Any glaring issues that may have been missed?

    2. WhatÂs a good width for spice pullout by cooktop (currently is 9.5")

    3. Software defaults Upper depth to 12". Is this enough? I recall some GWebbers having issues with inset cabinets and plates not fitting.

    4. WhatÂs a good width for the drawers underneath the wall oven? Baking pans will be going underneath.

    5. Where do people store their cutting boards? Prep work will be hopefully done in Island sink.

    6. Are people happy with their prep sink size? If so, whatÂs a good size. We have 18", but not sure if weÂll regret not getting bigger one.

    7. How many pots and pans are people able to fit into their drawers? Trying to figure out how many pans/pots can fit into each drawer given that the drawer widths are ranging b/w 20 Â 24.

    8. Any thoughts on where the bookshelf is currently (Kitchen 3 picture)? WeÂre not completely sure thatÂs the best place (we feel like weÂre wasting 12 inches of counter space since itÂs to the right of sink and not really wide enough to do anything and we like the idea of having the sink at the end of the island).




  • 16 years ago

    I would get a larger prep sink if possible. As a rule of thumb, the bowl is at least two inches smaller than the sink size. You want to be able to fit the largest pot or colander you use on at least weekly basis and the bowl to fit a large load of fluid. Sometimes, you might want to wash out a pot.

    For the drawer heights, the average baking pan isn't very tall until you get to a larger casserole. Looking at where the ovens fall in your 3d pics, I'd probably go for two equal height drawers. I wouldn't worry about the width unless you own restaurant sheet pans. Normally, I'd say cookie sheets and roasters on edge over the oven, but I don't know if you can with the double stacked cabinets - the cabinet needs to be at least 16" tall on the inside.

    Inset uppers are often 13-14" depth BUT you still need to check that your plates or whatever else will indeed fit.

    I put tray racks under the prep sink and that's where the cutting boards live.

    I would really encourage you to see if you couldn't have 30" pot drawers. Because you're using inset cabinets you lose over 4" in usable width for the frame and the drawer sides so 20" drawers are really 16" drawers. The problem with using them for pots is the damn pots have handles! Those Handles Take Space.

    As far as things that may become an issue...

    --- am not liking that undercounter ref placement - particularly hating the door swing. It seems pretty awkward with the other ref a step or two from the prep sink.

    --- Isn't the ref door going to hit the header? And the cabinet over the ref and same thing with both vertical sets of uppers on the right of the sink wall.

    --- Where's the trash? Do you need more than one?

    --- Is there a micro?

    Decorative - the proportions of the cleanup sink window look odd to my eyes - either needs to taller or narrower? Or maybe about 6 inches narrower and about a foot taller so the glass area reaches the first cabinet division in height and the cabinets aren't squished into the window trim.

    I wouldn't turn the corner with cabinets to the left of the window, I'd probably continue the uppers on the cooktop wall into the corner. Alas, I'd also probably start working on dh for a slightly larger window with its budget changes.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Bmorepanic for your feedback! See below for replies to your helpful comments....will try to work on a new rendering and repost.

    "I would get a larger prep sink if possible. "

    ThatÂs exactly what I was thinking tooÂlarger is probably better. Guess we need to sacrifice some drawer space or forgo the bookshelf.

    "For the drawer heights, the average baking pan isn't very tall until you get to a larger casserole. Looking at where the ovens fall in your 3d pics, I'd probably go for two equal height drawers. I wouldn't worry about the width unless you own restaurant sheet pans. Normally, I'd say cookie sheets and roasters on edge over the oven, but I don't know if you can with the double stacked cabinets - the cabinet needs to be at least 16" tall on the inside."

    ThatÂs a great idea! There may be room  the double oven is meant to be a micro/oven combo..but havenÂt settled one yet so this was just a placeholderÂ.was thinking we should bring it down some since donÂt really need a tall drawer for baking pansÂ.

    "I put tray racks under the prep sink and that's where the cutting boards live."

    We were planning to do a pull out trash thing underneath the sinks.

    "I would really encourage you to see if you couldn't have 30" pot drawers. Because you're using inset cabinets you lose over 4" in usable width for the frame and the drawer sides so 20" drawers are really 16" drawers. The problem with using them for pots is the damn pots have handles! Those Handles Take Space."

    "As far as things that may become an issue...
    --- am not liking that undercounter ref placement - particularly hating the door swing. It seems pretty awkward with the other ref a step or two from the prep sink."

    Sorry  thatÂs meant to be a wine fridgeÂsoftware limitationsÂ.

    "--- Isn't the ref door going to hit the header? And the cabinet over the ref and same thing with both vertical sets of uppers on the right of the sink wall."

    ThatÂs a load bearing wall/headerÂwe probably need to check w/ structural engineer on the thickness

    "Decorative - the proportions of the cleanup sink window look odd to my eyes - either needs to taller or narrower? Or maybe about 6 inches narrower and about a foot taller so the glass area reaches the first cabinet division in height and the cabinets aren't squished into the window trim."

    Excellent pointÂweÂll need to fix thatÂ

    "I wouldn't turn the corner with cabinets to the left of the window, I'd probably continue the uppers on the cooktop wall into the corner. Alas, I'd also probably start working on dh for a slightly larger window with its budget changes."

    Yah  I know itÂs kinda squishedÂ.I just like the look of the upper corner cabÂsoftens the edges up a bit..

  • 16 years ago

    Also, we aren't totally sure about not centering the cooktop/range with the island. Is this a faux pas?

  • 16 years ago

    The wine ref might be happier by the ref-ref and one of those drawers can move into the island? Unless you use that much wine during meal prep? If you do, I'd like an invitation.

    I don't know if this will be true for you, but we generate the most trash at the prep station. That's where boxes, bags and other packaging end their journey as well as other minor debris. Sink cabinets usually have a door that would need to be opened to be able to get to the trash can.

    Which way would the door open? Will you open the door and then a pullout or what? Where will your pipes be? Will you have a garbage disposal in the same cabinet? Realistically, how big of a can will fit.

    At prep, we have two 50 qt cans, one for trash and one for recycling. Both are in the same top-mount pullout that's attached to the door. I put on a foot pedal for the pullout and its working great.

    This is not meant to talk you out of it, just what I think about when you said the trash thing.

    I'm still futzing around with the cleanup sink - looking for a way to do another trash over there. There turned out to be problems with under the sink - with a farm sink, the door is very low and I'm likely to want to be using the sink and use the trash at the same time. And not trip over the open door to the cabinet. I don't have a lot of room left over between the pipes and the hoses for the pull out faucet and the dishwasher.

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations