Software
Houzz Logo Print
dirtymartini_gw

pls help with backsplash/countertop/peninsula wall coordination

15 years ago

Tried to word the title so it is understandable, not sure I succeeded. LOL

I don't want my kitchen to be boring...but I am also worried about it being too "busy," especially coordinating the backsplash, island countertop and also the wall under the counter on the peninsula. (Does that wall have a name? You know...where people sit, where they kick and scuff up the wall?) The wall will face our family room (open floor plan) so we were thinking of doing something decorative and putting undermount lights under the countertop to showcase whatever we do and add to the ambiance. Or is that just getting ridiculous?

Little info here...medium tone wood floors, dove white shaker cabs with drawer cup pulls (almost like ORB color, but more black with a rust finish). Butcher Block (waterloxed) perimeter counters, SS appliances. Gas cook top on the island. SS double wall oven. I *think* SS farmhouse sink and SS hood vent over island (we were thinking about copper for both of those but again, worried about mixing too many finishes.) Island is not white, but stained a dark walnut color.

1) Ok, so...for the island with cooktop, I wanted something different than perimeter counters, also would really like it to be a "landing spot" for hot items coming out of the oven or off the cooktop. I do not want granite. I really like tile for the island countertop. Before you scoff, hear me out...

My husband can DIY

it is inexpensive

if we hate it in a few years we can do something else at that time

I am trying to keep with the "1970s faux spanish ranch house" theme.

We are talking about large tiles,very small grout joints. I would love some suggestions on tiles and/or colors.

2) backsplash...as much as I want to be daring and add some color, I am thinking something white or off white and pearlescent with some shimmer. I love the look of rustic against "blingy". I also love the idea of antiqued mirrors (VERY antiqued, so as not to see too much reflection) as a backsplash.

3) under peninsula countertop...don't think it should match the backsplash or the island countertop...it will look like we got free tile and were dying to use it, lol. It will be a focal point from the family room as well as the entrance of our home.

I am willing to listen to any ideas (should brick be in the equation somewhere? Maybe SS countertop on island?) I am so worried about the kitchen ending up a hot mess...but I always gravitate towards plain and boring because I am unwilling to commit, and then end up regretting it.

Thanks!

Comments (4)

  • 15 years ago

    Have you taken the Sweeby test yet? You have a lot of wonderful ideas but definitely need to arrive first at your blurry unfocused final picture, then add in all the elements that belong there, where they belong, and pass regretfully on others that don't work in that picture. Maybe like coloring in outline drawings of your kitchen with pearly tile and copper and stainless, or stainless, with or without brick, hmmm, or let's see what it looks like with this....

    "1970s faux spanish ranch house theme"
    "love the look of rustic against "blingy"
    ?

    BTW, I love the idea of tile on your island, and likely your backsplash. How about a handcrafted tile, perhaps a fusion of old rancho with pearlescent?

    Regarding having the underside of the eating counter a "focal point" from the FRM and entry, my reaction is a knee-jerk noooooo. With stools/chairs in front, that's an area the eye should skip right on past--to settle on something genuinely handsome. Even with no stools, that area should only bea contributing portion of the entire view, with focus moving right on past to something important. Wouldn't dark walnut with a scrubbable finish be great for hiding shoe smudges? It would be for allowing focus to keep moving to...what will your focal point be?

    Regarding lighting up your counters, I sure don't think it's "too much" if done right. But, since this would create a rather dramatic effect of a horizontal band of light each evening, is a horizontal band what your room needs? Does it echo a horizontal effect elsewhere? Will your counters describe a very pleasing continuous shape, length of band in proper proportion to the rest of the area? Is focusing attention on that portion of the kitchen the best option or is there something else that might be lit up to better effect? Lighting is a major design tool and feature, but it does need to fulfill a design purpose.

  • 15 years ago

    You are awesome, thank you for helping me brainstorm.

    You know, sometimes just typing ideas onto a post helps a person think. The more I think about it, the more I think you are correct, that under the peninsula counter there should NOT be a focal point. It seems so clear to me now I almost feel silly for ever considering it.

    Thanks to your post, I looked up the Sweeby Test. I am still fuzzy as to what I want exactly, but I did zero in on antiqued mirror tiles as a backsplash. I am concerned, tho, about lack of color. Maybe I will introduce color with the tile counter on the island?

    Thanks again for giving me a well thought out and helpful answer.

  • 15 years ago

    There are so many beautiful Mexican and Spanish tiles that will lend themselves to the "1970s faux spanish ranch house" theme and go with antiqued mirrors.

  • 15 years ago

    yes...you mean for the island? And do you mean a pattern? I am scared of pattern on the island countertop...not sure why. Hmmm...will have to look for some images to get some ideas. Thank you.