Software
Houzz Logo Print
lkbum_gw

Vague Question on Cabinets

15 years ago

I am building a fairly upscale lake house, Large open kitchen, Hardwood floors, Granite counters. Craftsman style for the most part. My builder suggested I look at "pre-built" cabinets. I've looked at custom scratch builts and the "pre-builts" appear to have more options and finish choices. I went to Lowes and spoke with their Kitchen Designer, he suggested Shenandoah, Schuler and Karftmade. I am only looking at all plywood, cuchisoned closers etc. Any opinions on Shenandoah or Schuler or pre builts in general? Thanks.

Comments (9)

  • 15 years ago

    Many of the semi-custom name brands, do not offer plywood cabinets standard. Make sure that you request an upgrade to plywood or you will receive particle board or "engineered wood" cabinet boxes

    Here is a link that might be useful: Kitchen Cabinet Kings Door Style Selection

  • 15 years ago

    Try typing into Google (or Bing or whatever) Shenandoah cabinets site:gardenweb.com and it will bring up all the old threads about those cabinets - there's a lot! Then replace Shenandoah with Schuler, etc.

    One thing you'll hear over and over is to check out Lowes and HD, but then check your local cabinet makers. Many people have found the local prices to be at least as good if not better and, of course, you get exactly what you want in the size you need.

    P.S. Ignore anything the CabinetKing people have to say; they're just promoting their own products, which is against the policy of this site, but they don't seem to care.

  • 15 years ago

    How can custom have fewer options and finishes than prebuilt? I wonder if you've found the right "custom" shop. Many of us have found that we get better value with custom, as suzanne points out. My custom guy is mixing a custom stain for me to approximate my Stickley bookcases. And he'd never been asked for a paper towel cubby before, but he's doing one for me. I would think that any true custom guy or gal could do anything you wanted. Nothing against the "prebuilts," but it's worth it to compare apples to apples and check the prices.

  • 15 years ago

    My semi-custom cabinetmaker has standard:
    hardwood drawer boxes,
    plywood sides/tops/backs/floors
    full-extension, soft-close drawer glides

    [Note: I'm not a cabinet salesperson and I'm not linking to my own business' site...just a very, very satisfied customer!]

    Have you considered other options than "big box" stores?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Omega Construction Details

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the follow ups. I have searched this board and in general on the various types of cabinets and have read a lot of older threads. Seemed like a lot of mixed reviews, some not so current. I am surprised that the moderators allow the posts with links to their sites at the end of the posts. The comment on prebuilt options vs custom made is valid, imo. Take a look at the Kraft or Shenandoa brochures. Lot's and lots of glass choices, mulling choices, varied drawers etc. Custom built guys can clearly do these, but they will cost more. I'm not talking finishes, but different drawer configurations, glass etc. Shenandoa has a corner unit with drawers that have a "corner" shaped face (looked like a lot of wasted space, but very cool), their catologue for base cabinets has about 20 pages of various slide outs, drawers etc. My fear on using a cabinet like these comes from some of the threads where delivery problems, damaged goods etc are disussed. And frankly ordering from either HD or Lowes is not something I would look forward to. Any input is appreciated, thanks.

  • 15 years ago

    lkbum our custom built cabinets with glass and mirrors and every drawer and drawer insert designed exactly the way I want it are costing tens of thousands of dollars less than semi-custom. So, I do not think it is necessarily, or even usually, true that custom built guys will only do those things if it costs more. The general consensus seems to be that it will cost less to get those things if you go custom, depending on where you live of course.

    Ginny20, not to hijack, but if you check back - is your cab maker doing the paper towel w/ the PVC pipe? I'm going to be eager to hear how that works out for you!

  • 15 years ago

    beaglesdoitbetter,
    thanks, I'm in north Georgia (Lake Lanier, north of Atlanta by about 30 miles), any references would be greatly appreciated.

  • 15 years ago

    There are a bunch of threads on recommendations for Atlanta custom cabinet makers:
    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg0121371629111.html
    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg0715391728149.html

    Here are just two of them. I would go to Google and search "Atlanta custom cabinet maker site:ths.gardenweb.com" and you should be able to find all the threads.

    I'd love to recommend my amazing cabinet maker but he's in PA. :)

  • 15 years ago

    We have custom in our kitchen, and Shuller for our bathroom vanities. The Shuller ones are fine, but some of the doors are a little wonky (some faces are a little off and the hinges don't all slide perfectly). I like the way my kitchen ones that were custom feel much better than the Schuller ones. Manufactured cabs, in my experience, tend to have a heavier finish on them, which feels a little plastic-like to me. My kitchen cabs feel like wood, which I like.

Sponsored
Trish Takacs Design
Average rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars36 Reviews
Award Winning & Highly Skilled Kitchen & Bath Designer in Columbus