Software
Houzz Logo Print
compumom_gw

Show me your staircase please!!

15 years ago

I'm torn and need good input from decorative minds. We're in the midst of a huge remodel and our wood balustrades are dated-- but I do like the look of having wood. Our home is very traditional, lots of moulding and wainscoating, but the contractor/designer now wants to use a wrought iron railing system. He says that all of the upscale homes have them now. I like clean lines, so we're only talking about bars with one or two knuckles of some kind--No scrolls.

On the upside, they've suggested brown iron finish- which would compliment two of the light fixtures I'm leaning towards in the living and dining rooms. But I'm having a hard time visualizing it with the black sample that they've given me.

However the only other iron around is a simple railing leading up my front steps into the house and the outdoor light fixtures.

The inside staircase is such that on the flight up from the entry hall you see only a handrail. The posts are on the upper flight of stairs and across the landing at the top. Nothing but the handrail is really visible from the entry.

SUGGESTIONS and/or PHOTOS PLEASE!!

Comments (44)

  • 15 years ago

    Personally I'm not a fan of the wrought iron, but that is just me.

    You need to look at the photos on Houzz

    Here is a link that might be useful: [Staircases on Houzz[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/staircase-ideas-phbr0-bp~t_745)

  • 15 years ago

    My parents used wrought iron with wooden handrail in their home, built in 1985. The wrought iron was painted a tan color, and has never had to be touched up.

  • 15 years ago

    How funny, I just found Houzz. It's very useful and yes, I'm consistently liking the wood better than the iron. Painting the balustrades isn't that big of a deal, but other than the birdcage iron effect, I'm not sure I like the look. That said, it's just a lot more work. We have an issue with the moulding going up the stairs-- we have a sawtooth below and then they made it meet in a V at the place where the first flight meets the second. It's ugly and clunky. I want it off and suspect that the contractor wants the iron railing to make all of this go away. We also have a problem with the crown return at the opening of the staircase and I think that the decorative piece as shown in the photo attached would solve that problem as well.
    Our staircase is posts going up to the second level and not walled in as this one is.

    Here is a link that might be useful: [Crown moulding and staircase[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/thriftydecorchick-contemporary-staircase-indianapolis-phvw-vp~28368)

  • 15 years ago

    I don't think wood staircases ever go out of style. I do think that in a few years the wrought iron would certainly be dated. I have a 230 year old house: nothing but wood for me!!!

  • 15 years ago

    Wrought iron is great outdoors, but I don't care for it inside. They started adding it to new home construction here about 15 years ago.

  • 15 years ago

    Both iron and wood rail and baluster systems are classic looks - but the style of the house should dictate which is used. Which is appropriate for your home?

    The fact that your contractor said "that all of the upscale homes have them now" would be enough to send me running in the other direction. If everyone is doing it, I won't.

  • 15 years ago

    Ditto Deb! Very good point.

  • 15 years ago

    If you prefer the wood than stick to that.

    We had a wooden staircase in our townhome that was light oak with white spindles and it was pretty beat up from the previous owners. I wanted to to change it to something that would match better with our decor and home. I felt that the light wood and white spindles was clashing with the rest of the house and it really looked out of place (we have darker woods, dark finishes). Normally I prefer all wood but I felt that look didn't match with the style of our home. So even though I normally prefer something else I went with the iron because I felt it would go better with the feel of our home. We did black iron with the birdcage as every third spindle and a dark (like a rosewood) stain on the rails. I am very pleased with it.

    I say go with your gut and with what you think will look best in your home. Don't do something because everyone else is or isn't doing it.

    I feel that the change I made to the staircase is an improvement. If I want to sell this house one day and it's out of style - oh well. If I would have left what was there it would still be out of style. At least now I can enjoy it :)

    I am sure whatever you decide will look great. But I say go with what you want not what the contractor says.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm with you; I just don't care for wrought iron on indoor staircases in our home. I think they can be beautiful in some homes, but I'm just not a fan for us. Here is our wooden staircase:

  • 15 years ago

    Fabulous input, keep it coming...please!

    I see that some ballestrades have a rail above and below. The iron sample that was dropped off has it too. I'm not a big fan, but I'm not sure what to do. What wood is everyone's handrail made from? I dropped into a large moulding store today and the selection was either red oak or poplar. There were 3 in maple, but they weren't very grand.

  • 15 years ago

    Our rail is oak, the balusters are painted poplar. They're square with a very simple routing detail to dress them up a bit. No picture of that close up but I can get one if you're interested.

  • 15 years ago

    I have iron - very simple - because it went with my current home better than wood.


    Previous house had wood. We had two staircases.

  • 15 years ago

    We replace our railings, along with refinishing and staining the wood floors, a year ago. We had white ornate rickety spindles before. I had them stain the newels much darker than the floor and went with a simpler hammered wrought iron spindle. The upper hallway can be seen from our great room. It works a lot better with my decor style.
    {{!gwi}}

  • 15 years ago

    When we first purchased our home, the builder had installed natural wood ballusters, railings and posts. To me it obstructed the view so we painted the ballusters, leaving the rail and posts natural. We've been pleased since.

    No photo of the original but here is how is appears today.

    {{!gwi}}

  • 15 years ago

    doonie - You've got a few different styles going on with that staircase, but it works and is absolutely gorgeous!

  • 15 years ago

    You all have been so helpful! Most of you have more of a focal point going on with beautiful stairs. Unfortunately most of the posts etc are not visible from the first floor. It's kind of a waste. Love the two tone effect too!

    There are so many great designs!

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks Newhomebuilder! (I am still working on art for the wall in the foyer!)

  • 15 years ago

    I have had both iron and wood in previous homes but in this house, I chose wood which suites imo this home better.

    {{!gwi}}

  • 15 years ago

    The house before this one had wrought iron rails and supports. I hated it. It was cold looking. Looked very commercial. Our contractor tried to talk me into just adding a wooden rail to the top of it to warm it up. I still didn't like it. I had the wrought iron completely removed and we did wood.
    It changed the look of the whole stair case. One of the best things we ever did in that house.

  • 15 years ago

    The contractor was here this morning. I told him NO to wrought iron. It just isn't in keeping with the style of our home. So we have to come up with an alternative-- we don't have much width to do a tread & riser and frankly, our budget has been hammered. He's calling a staircase company to come out and give a bid-- Our problem is the way that the balusters come right down to the treads. There's little room for the carpeting and the moulding along the sides. When we first moved in, DH mickey-moused the edge detail with some moulding which has now been removed.
    One option is now to replace the posts and rails with one which has a wood rail at the bottom which runs diagonally up the stairs with the balusters fitting in between the handrail and this wood piece (can't think of the name).

    My problem is how to end the carpet and how to finish off the moulding. The sawtooth with a decorative cap seems to be my best option. Not crazy about it going up the wall, but do I have a choice? They've already added the sawtooth, but stopped short with the trim piece until we make a more final decision.
    DH posted these 5 photos to help with suggestions.

    Thanks all!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Our existing stairway

  • 15 years ago

    That's dated? I think it's beautiful!

  • 15 years ago

    I'm with natal - I see nothing dated about it. In fact, I would refer to it as classic. But, the only thing that matters is that you're happy with the final product.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks, now please give me your suggestions on how to make the carpeting and trim detail work. I don't want to wrap the stairs with carpeting, if at all possible. It's a clunky look to wrap around the balusters-- BTDT. I'm all ears...

  • 15 years ago

    It's a lot of work and labor cost but your treads can be changed - the stair company can probably advise if it's a good option for you. Your risers might be able to stay and simply be painted. Then you can do a runner instead of full carpet. However...... I've seen people here and on other sites with the same situation you have and they just paint what they have and do a runner.

    Our stairs have the bottom rail for the balusters like you were talking about - and a runner.

  • 15 years ago

    doonie, that's FABulous!

  • 15 years ago

    I can't get a good photo of my stairs right now as the sun is shining thru from every direction and all you can see is a bright white light. But we have a stair case with oak treads to match our hardwood floor. Later in the day I can take a good picture.

    OT- DLM2000 I have been looking for a runner like yours. Could you please tell me what kind of rug it is - durability etc? We have a yellow lab that likes to sit on the stairs during the day so I need something durable, but also pretty and we have a similar color on our walls so I think yours will look great!
    Thx

  • 15 years ago

    gillylily (cute name!) I'm not going to be much help - someone else asked for info a while back and I couldn't find the paperwork - we've had that runner for 7 years or more.

    What I can tell you is that I went to a local small carpet store and told them what I wanted - low pile, durable, would take to being bent over stairs well, dog (and kids!) running up and down - they limited my search from that and I picked the 'look' I was after. It's a rug, cut and bound for a runner, wears like iron, shows almost no dirt (we've never had it cleaned, only done a bit of spot work if something spills), vacuums beautifully and honestly looks just like it did the day they put it in. There's a very high quality pad on each tread but even so, that may wear out before the carpet. If I ever track down the paperwork I'll let you know specifics.

  • 15 years ago

    Some wrought iron can look down right ugly, as well as wood spindles. I like both as long as they are beautifully done. I've seen some gorgeous examples of iron I wish I could do. The only downside would be in dusting them.

  • 15 years ago

    Doonie and Newhomebuilder, yours are simple yet very nice. We don't have stairs but we have a sunken living room that uses this ghastly uninteresting wrought iron to separate the rooms. I'd like to rip it out but I don't know what I'd replace it with.

    On the other hand, we have a deck that needs to be updated as it's not up to code. I'd like to replace it with decorative wrought iron. It would open up our view.

  • 15 years ago

    Our treads and risers are crummy plywood. Changing them wouldn't be cost effective...sadly.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh my goodness, you all have such pretty homes. You can be so proud!

  • 15 years ago

    TODAY! We ended up changing out our wood staircase for another wood staircase, but one that looks more like Newhomebuilder's 3rd photo- white wood straight balusters, slightly chamfered with squared newel posts. It became a sticking point and we called in a stair specialist who rebuilt and more importantly firmly anchored this new staircase. The other one was a bit loose with all of the construction and now we have a bottom curb for the baluster's to end and that solves the carpeting problem!
    A bit poorer, but much happier. The kicker of the day is 85 yr old mother approved, saying that she never liked my old staircase! LOL

  • 15 years ago

    Here is a picture of the staircase in my house, from the homebuilder's website. Good luck with your selections!

  • 15 years ago

    Take a look at this webpage for lots of before and after.

    www.staircrafter.com

  • 15 years ago

    Congrats, Compumom! Post a pic of them for us to "ooooh and aaaah" over when you have a chance!

  • 15 years ago

    I will, but it's not painted or stained yet. We're planning on painting the balusters and staining the newels and handrails. I cannot wait!!

    Today was a big day too. I guess everyone is happy for our warmer and drier weather and ready to get back to work. The plumber showed and put in all of the faucets in the 2 bathrooms, switched the MB toilet to another bathroom, installed a new one for us (with a better flush we hope) and around and removed the powder room toilet for us to move upstairs hopefully next week. I wanted to make sure I was happy with all of the other arrangements before that installation.
    Tomorrow the contractor will be back at 7AM. We are moving!

  • 15 years ago

    Finally, I have photos of the unfinished rebuild! The handrail and newel posts will be stained a walnut color and the balusters will be white. Sorry it took us so long to get photos up here! Many thanks to all for their wisdom and input.

    More work today and again all week. I'm almost at a decision point on the paint colors. Gotta get more hardware and Baldwin is taking forever to send our door handles for downstairs. At least the weather has cleared and no one has an excuse for why the rain is keeping them away!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rebuilt, but unfinished staircase

  • 15 years ago

    TTT

  • 15 years ago

    It looks really good! What paint colors are you considering?

  • 15 years ago

    It's beautiful! I can't wait to see the stained wood!

  • 15 years ago

    I've always loved the traditional wood, either stained, painted, or a combination of both, but decided on natural wrought iron(very dark charcoal)with dark stained posts/handrails/stair edging beyond carpeting. I think of it as traditional with a twist. ;o)

    Here is a link that might be useful: wrought iron railings

  • 15 years ago

    I really like the basketweave iron. If I had chosen one, it would have been that one!

    Color-- our floors downstairs will be walnut (medium dark) so we'll probably stain the banister and newels to match or at least continue the theme. I guess that the balusters will be swiss coffee to match the rest of the wood work. The hallway above the chair rail will be a tan color. I've got samples on the walls and am leaning towards an ICI color called Vanilla Tan. It doesn't have pink or yellow over tones.

  • 15 years ago

    Doesn't anyone here know about the Gallery thread on staircases? It has hundreds of stairs photos. Here's a link for you:

    Here is a link that might be useful: Staircase Eye Candy Blowout!