Software
Houzz Logo Print
tomatotomata

Cabinet estimates - is this impossible?

18 years ago

How can I find out which cabinet lines are high, medium, low cost/quality/service? It seems to be impossible to go from one cabinet maker to another without a specific plan, so they are comparing "apples to apples". I don't want to go to a KD, choose a cabinet I like, and pay for a design, just to find out I'm buying hugely expensive stuff, when I could have bought cheaper, but adequate, cabinets. Any suggestions? I have googled my fingers off, but since no one quotes prices, I can't get that information.

Comments (9)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I would pick a standard-sized cabinet, for example a 30" cabinet with drawers, and get a price for it in each line. The cost for a kitchen-full of cabinets will not be exactly proportional, but it should give you a good idea of price points. Also, it will enable you to see how much each line charges for the extras like full-extension drawers and soft-close.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This thread may be helpful to you:

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cabinet Brand Pricing Comparisons

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Go to HD, Lowes and a few local indep. shops with your measurements and see what they have to offer and then research the company's - most stock company's, you will find really good and bad experiences so you'll have to make a tuff decision (we picked by door style - Kraftmaid and had a great experience). We got ours from Just Cabinets which is a chain doing what you are talking about for the same reason why. No hassle, standard pricing, walk in, bought, walked out. No problem (well, minor, but no biggie).

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I very much like the idea of comparing a single cab-- a 30" 3 drawer with self/soft close, for instance, or any cab that your own preliminary work indicates you might need several of.

    But after I checked those out, I'd check the same cab from Ikea: I've been assembling my Ikea cabs today and I'm just amazed at how tight and solid they are.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I don't know if things are different in your area, but I just got a bunch of quotes on cabinets, with general designs, and didn't pay for any of them.

    Yes, I paid for an independent kitchen designer to come to my house, measure and make me a general design.

    But based on that vague, 2-dimensional floor plan, I asked them each for essentially the same lineup of cabinets, so I WOULD have apples-to-apples comparisons for prices.

    Prices were, as many others have said, all over the place. A full custom line came in less than a semi-custom line.

    I then talked to them enough so I could see how creative they could get with the layout, how they worked, and how much those changes would affect the price.

    I ended up choosing a local cabinet maker who, on the spot, sketched out a shelf unit and a layout that blew my doors off and is going to use every millimeter of space, and his own guys will install in my nothing-is-level- house, and said, of course you want to paint it yourself, soapstone counters and all the other quirky things the cabinet stores tried to talk me out of. Because that's what his clients have. It's, uh, not going to be cheaper. But it's not as expensive as I thought it could be. I have this board to thank for even considering it.

    I'd take Erikanh's advice and acquaint yourself with the lines and their vaguely general priciness.

    Your choices may be immediately narrowed by some design aesthetic or design choice, like inset, or, in my case, the lines that would allow me to order them unpainted. Or it might be the ones you can get with a certain cabinet feature like a special pull-out, so if that's what you really want, tell them up front.

    But to pay just to get a quote? No. That shouldn't happen. Just tell them that's what you're after. You can go to a full design afterward if you like what they've done, feel you've been treated well and the price is right.

    (If what you're looking at are design-build places that really want you commit to soup-to-nuts when you walk in the door, you can at least get a quote on the same cabinet line from a regular cabinet shop to see what you're REALLY paying for before you sign a contract. As long as you're up front and don't monopolize their time at their busiest hours, I think it's OK. I have done this and definitely thrown business toward shops that were willing to help a confused consumer out.)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There are NO "standard" 30" cabinets. My Kraftmaid spec book probably has 5 pages of cabinets that can come in 30" width, and KM isn't even all that semi custom. There are just so many options based on idividual design choices and cabinet location within that design. Thermofoil or cherry? Raised panel or shaker recessed panel? Glazed finish or completely unfinished for you to custom paint? Are you talking basic construction or "upgraded"? Without pulls or with the $5 pulls or the $15 pulls? No finished sides for a cabinet in the middle of a run, or plywood flush sides or door paneled sides and back for an island situation? No molding or a 5 piece stacked molding plus light rail? Is that "regular" 30" cabinet a butt cabinet (with or without a dust strip) or does it have a stile in the middle? 1 drawer or 2 top drawers? Full depth adjustible shelf below or half depth unadjustible one? All of these are potential options that have to be considered and optioned out correctly in each particular cabinet line in order to compare "apples to apples". And even then, it's not really going to be easy to do, even if you spec everything you can imagine out for your "basic" 30" cabinet. You're leaving out install for one, industry reptuation, lead time, customer service response time, and, most importantly, the relationship between you and the KD who reps any of these lines.

    In most cabinet lines, it's not the "basic" cabinets that are the majority of the cost of the kitchen. It's all the little "upgrades" that add together that make that "basic" $400 cabinet all of a sudden cost $1400 in the actual kitchen design as finalized by you. There are some lines that are pretty inexpensive for the boxes, but their moldings are out of sight. Or the charge for glazing is 30% rather than 15%. Or the full extension drawer glides are $100 per glide extra. Or they don't offer that itty bitty angled corner cabinet for your wine that you had your heart set on. Or, they are difficult for installers to work with, and so cost more to install than some lines.

    There are a whole host of factors that go into "pricing" of a "basic" 30" cabinet, and you won't take any of those into account by asking for either a "basic" design from your measurements or just the price of a 30" cabinet.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Live wire oak, the problem is, you make it seem impossible to start anywhere. It is a daunting process, but what would you suggest to help the OP? I don't know the OP's buget, but not everyone wants or can afford to just go out and hire a KD and give them a budget and let them take care of it.

    Do you have any idea of what you want yet? If you want to do more of it yourself, I would consider doing a basic layout. Maybe using your current cabinets if you don't plan on doing any major changes in layout, and getting "starter" prices using that. Measure the walls along your current cabinets and note the layout in a basic drawing of the floor plan with the wall measurements, like L shaped, U shaped, galley, etc. Photos of your current kitchen can help them a lot. Make sure you make notes at the outset of anything you know you want to change, like replacing a lower cabinet with pot drawers or adding one or more lighted cabinets, if you want plywood sides or it doesn't matter, if you want plywood shelves or it doesn't matter, etc. That will allow them to do a fairly quick price estimate that WILL go up from there. At the very least, this will allow you to eliminate the ones obviously not suited to your situation. For instance if you have a 30,000.00 budget and new appliances are mandatory, a cabinet quote of more than 20,000.00 probably wouldn't work by the time you added cabinet add ons and organizers, fixtures, facuets, appliances and floor, not to mention unexpected surprises. You also will need to decide where you want to spend your money. I decided to use less expensive cabinets but put in a hardwood floor and get a more expensive countertop. Others go for high end appliances but cut costs elsewhere, some go for custom or semi custom cabinets but use a more affordable granite or laminate countertop or vinyl floor. And then there is Igloochic. :) If you plan on spending 100,00.00 or more on a kitchen you are beyond my stratosphere I my only suggestion would be to look at magazines and the FKB and print or save kitchens you love and start interviewing KD's and calling custom cabinet makers, and check out Omega and Plain and Fancy cabinets. Then post another question asking how to go about managing a ???,000.00 kitchen budget, and let those with real experience in that area answer. :) So, my suggestion is to determine a basic overall budget, list of priorities and room measurements and layout, and then get a few estimates. If anyone has suggestions you love, find out what it would cost in the lines you have already gotten estimates in, and incorporate it into future estimates so you continue to compare "apples to apples". Make of note of when "standard features" include upgrades that are not important to you. If you don't care about plywood sides or shelves and a line only offers that, you might get the upgrade without paying more or you may decide that is why they are more expensive and you would rather go with another line that doesn't use them unless you pay for them, but is less expensive because you are not paying for what you don't want. It is going to take some time.

    Sue

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    we made a kitchen layout and labeled all the cabinets (ie B24, W3030, etc...these naming conventions seem pretty standard in the industry). Specifcally noted that add-ons like molding, cab inserts, knobs were NOT to be included, except full ext blum slides or equivalent. Specified exact cabinet style (ie all wood, light cherry, shaker inset). Faxed plans to about 8 or 9 places recieved quotes in about a week from all but one place. worked like a charm, but we knew exactly what we wanted. good luck.