Software
Houzz Logo Print
catkin_gw

Not Centering The Dining Table Under The Light Fixture?

15 years ago

Have you ever placed it near a window in your dining room or centered it on a wall instead of the middle of the room?

If so, do you think it works well/better for you and your family (traffic flow, etc.)?

Thanks in advance.

Comments (18)

  • 15 years ago

    For us and optimal traffic flow, our table HAS to be centered in the room, which means centered under the chandelier.

  • 15 years ago

    After 5 yrs living with both the kitchen and DR chandeliers off center from the tables, I tried to get the fixtures repositioned when I replaced them in 3 months ago. Nothing doing - it would have been a big mess and very expensive. Instead I'm using a different table in the kitchen(smaller and rectangular rather than round)and I moved the china cabinet to a different wall to allow the table to be centered. I still don't like the furniture placement, but it's better than everything being off-center. THAT drove me nuts and hurt my brain!

  • 15 years ago

    Mine isn't centered under the light (which is a ceiling fan/light combo). Because the light doesn't really look centered for the true eating space--in the combo DR/LR, in a townhouse. Problem is, there's a slight bump-out (bump-in?) on the side wall, just deep enough for a buffet/cabinet, and I have a waist-high glass-top one there. So the light is centered over the entire space, but not over the true dining-use space.

    It hasn't bothered me, because the light provides plenty of coverage at night. But for some reason, last night I was looking over it from the sofa in the adjoining LR and wondered if I should reorient the table (again) 45 degrees so it doesn't look so "off"!

    I think whatever works best for traffic flow.
    I also think, tho, if your light fixture ends up quite a ways away from the table, you might want to have an electrician in to move it over (as long as you're not the type to rearrange things every few months!). Or have an electrician in to install some pot lights over near the window or a few delicate hanging lights.

  • 15 years ago

    We have a farm style DR table, and years ago I put it right next to the wall, lengthwise, and also had it next to the wall with the longer end coming out from it. I loved it both ways!

    Since there was only 4 of us, we could still sit at the table.

    I also put a small lamp on the table next to the wall and it was really nice, and the kids loved doing their homework there.

  • 15 years ago

    In my current house, the chandelier is centered on the room, but my table is not because I have a buffet on one wall so the table has to be slightly to one side. It sort of bothers me, but not enough to get an electrician to move it. I'm more bothered by the fact that it's an ugly chandelier, but I've lived with it for 10 years, so I guess that doesn't even bother me that much, LOL.

  • 15 years ago

    Our table is centered with the chandelier, but they are not centered in the room. I already had them, a sideboard and a vitrine when we were designing our home, so I made sure it would all fit. To do this, the table is not centered in the room. No one has ever noticed.

    That said, I think not having the fixture centered over the table would bother me.

  • 15 years ago

    I would change the fixture to a flush mount and do something altogether different with the lighting.
    While the swag is the easiest, I'm not remotely crazy about the look. Maybe a paneled board on the ceiling and "swag" it internally through the ceiling so it doesn't show?

    There are lots of creative ideas but having it non centered is not one I like.
    Pottery Barn Store had a display I loved: a large plank hung from the ceiling with knotted ropes on each end. The wide board was covered with candles and greenery, quite beautiful. Overall, it was about 20" wide and 5' long- at a rough guesstimate. The ropes on each end were thick and rough (for texture). The board was stained a distressed green.
    If you did something like that over the table as focal point and a flush mount light fixture somewhere else, it might work very well.

  • 15 years ago

    I really like bumblebeez idea. You could even do a seasonal arrangement that used those battery operated timer candles. Ones that automatically go on for 6-8 hours? Depending on your decor, you could use chains, ropes, cords, etc. The shelf could be metal or wood, delicate or heavy. Hmmm... sounds like it could be a really interesting focal point.

  • 15 years ago

    Great discourse, everyone--thanks so much!

    So many different issues that we all deal with LOL.

    This is a friend's home and it's a house full--my friend, her daughter and 3 active grandkids (13, 9 and 5) and pets of course!

    I was wondering how we could make it easier to navigate from the living room to the rest of the house the only pathway being through the dining room.

    With the table smack dab in the middle, it gets crowded.

    The light fixture is a fan/light combo and isn't going anywhere soon.

    oakleyok, your idea of putting of the table (end) against a wall with a lamp at that end is what I was thinking and would work beautifully! It would free up a lot of space. The table is rectangular and they could seat 5 easily. There just happens to be a window there, too which would be great for school work or just hanging out.

    I saw a few homes on Google images that were gorgeous but the dining room light wasn't centered over the dining table--funny thing was, had I not been looking for it, I probably wouldn't have noticed that!

    Thanks again, in my own kitchen I'm going to use the *swag to the center* idea when I get around to it.

    catkin

  • 15 years ago

    Catkin, you wouldn't believe the space it opens up. Our DR isn't all that large to begin with, and it's also in the center of everything.

    I remember that day vividly for some reason. lol. I got a wild hair one morning and wanted to rearrange, and I remember when my dh came home from work he said he really liked it!

    Since we remodeled we now have the chandy centered over the table, and it's just the two of us now, so I doubt I'll change it out again.

    I do remember in the evenings I'd turn the DR lamp on just to give it a nice glow in there.

  • 15 years ago

    oakley--I share your vision! I agree it'll make a huge difference! Can't wait to try it out :~) Thanks again!

  • 15 years ago

    The problem with light fixtures in dining rooms is that builders tend to just stick them smack dab in the center of the room, without taking into consideration where a buffet, china cabinet or other piece of furniture will be placed. When we built our house, I figured out where I wanted to place the furniture, and had the light installed accordingly. Unfortunately, most of us don't have the chance to do that. In my prior house I had to swag the chandelier over to make it centered on the table.

  • 15 years ago

    I had to put my table next to the wall in this apt which put the hanging lamp off center. I finally got sick of it and swagged it over. Looks better.

  • 15 years ago

    My DR chandelier is in the middle of the room, but centering my table under it would put the table in the middle of the traffic pattern between the front door and the kitchen. Side-to-side, the chandy is centered, but end-to-end, no, it isn't. I find it a little annoying, but I've lived with it for 10 years and will probably continue to do so for 10 more.

  • 9 years ago

    I am wanting to place my dinette table off-center to utilize more space behind the table. But this means it would not be centered under the chandelier. My husband has suggested that he simply raise the chandelier closer to the ceiling. This way the chandelier will still be in the center of the room's ceiling but when turned on, the ROOM itself will have more light rather than the table having the most light. He says he would just sort of drape the excess chain down and around the top area of the light. I'm not sure I like that part of the idea but am considering it. .......Just thought I'd add my two cents worth. :-)

  • 4 years ago

    I purchased a large ceiling medallion that allowed my to reposition the light and cover the old hole.

  • 3 years ago

    Years ago, I lived in an old Spanish bungalow in L.A.. The house had a small dining room with two huge french windows that opened out onto a garden. The table was placed directly beneath the windows in the corner of the room. I hung an antique iron art deco chandelier close to the ceiling in the middle of the room. I probably turned the chandelier on three times in 8 years. The lighting source was a lamp which I placed on the table. So much more beautiful to write or read or eat by a soft table lamp. I despise swagged chandeliers. Reminds me unpleasantly of my mother 70s style living room. It just looks dated and tacky to my eye, almost as bad as ceiling fans over the table. I only turn on overhead lights when I have lost something.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio