Software
Houzz Logo Print
35ftcabo

Help needed - Final BS decision is due

14 years ago

Help. We need to get this BS finished and I am stuck on whether I like what we are currently thinking. We are planning on the rough marble random strips under all cabinets. The water cut marble will go behind the range with a skinny strip marble border. I am not sure I like the rough marble with the water cut marble. We had originally wanted to do Carrera random strips (last pic) under all cabs, but does that make too much marble? Too much grey?

Help. Any advice is appreciated.

Here is what we are currently thinking. The granite is River White, the cabinets are black.

Here is a larger picture of the tile that will go behind the range

Here is what we were going to do originally as the BS.

Comments (14)

  • 14 years ago

    I like smooth better. Both for looks and for cleanability...if you cook in your kitchen, I can't imagine trying to keep the rough cut marble clean.

  • 14 years ago

    I prefer the rough marble with the RW. The colors seem to complement one another better than the random strips of carara.

    I also love the watercut marble however on my monitor it appears a more blue/gray in comparison to your counters.

    Could just be my monitor. How do they look to you? Maybe the skinny strip board will provide a nice transition from the rough to the smooth and also in terms of color.

    I'm no expert tho'. Interested to hear what feedback others have.

    I hate these final hour decisions! Good luck! :)

  • 14 years ago

    I think the smooth marble tiles better looks better. It will be easier to clean too. The rough tiles look like they have a touch of gold/ brown in them. I don't see any of that color in the water cut marble. The water cut marble is beautiful.

  • 14 years ago

    I prefer the smooth, but I'm all about easy cleaning. I also wonder about the blue undertones in the watercut. If you don't see it in real life, it's not a problem. The water cut is a gorgeous pattern. Very graceful.

  • 14 years ago

    Just wanted to say I really like your water cut til., Any chance of just using that only?

  • 14 years ago

    i think there is a lot going on here ...maybe too much. can you take a clearer pic of the counters? mixing marble with a patterned granite is very risky, imo. also, the marble you are considering is very busy, just by the cuts.

  • 14 years ago

    I like the look of the rough marble because the "waves" in the marble mimic the movement in your stone. And there isn't much color variation in it which is a positive in my book. But I'd hate to try and keep that clean in a kitchen.

    The rough marble has, well, a rough feel and then the water cut has an exceedingly refined feel. I'm not sure they work together. I think the water cut with a plain subway would work.

    As for the Carrara, again, not sure it works with your granite. Tend to agree with kate on this... too much going on with that BS.

    As for too much gray? There can never be too much gray - says someone who loves gray. =)

  • 14 years ago

    So, you have some nice choices. I'm not sure any of them is in sync with your granite, which is bold in movement, but subtle in color. Would you consider glass tile? You could use a solid color mosaic, like this one, with gloss and frosted glass to highlight one individual color in the stone (the cream below, grey or white) without too much texture or color that can clash with your counter top.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Glass

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks everyone - I feel like I've spent more time and angst on BS decision than the whole kitchen.

    The watercut is a straight Carrera with white mica strips. It's not blue at all and really looks good with the counter. I think that may be the problem - the Carrera blends so well with the counter that if we did the random strips in the Carrera everywhere, it's almost too much of a good thing? I am hoping that if we do go with the rough, it won't pose too much of a cleaning problem as it won't be behind the range.

    We did look at glass tile, I just never found one I liked. There is not one warm thing in my kitchen, and the glass mosaics I found really tended toward creams instead of whites, and there is no cream here. I found some with stainless tiles that caught my eye, but it just seemed too busy with the counter.

    And Jjazzy - the only hope of using the water cut everywhere is if I die and my hubby uses the insurance proceeds. I'm getting a discount at $90 sq ft, which is why it's strictly limited to behind range. But if I win the lottery in the next week....

  • 14 years ago

    wow...the water cut is SO elegant......I think there is too much contrast between it and the rough cut but that is personal opinion. Rough cut seems like it will be a bear to clean even if it's not behind the range.

    My thoughts are that there is too much going on with the three types of stone but I don't like to mix stones much at all. Your granite has alot of movement and conflicting movement from counter to BS is chaotic to me. I see a neutral tile in grey or even white...glass or ceramic, for the majority of the BS...and the lovely watercut for behind the range.

    Sorry I can't be of much help....I can sympathize with you though...our BS was by FAR the most difficult decision!

  • 14 years ago

    It sounds like you are set on the watercut so I'd work from there. I'd either go with a white shimmery glass tile that works with the mica or maybe a gray glass, else ceramic subway in white or gray.

    There are white (not cream or green) glass tiles out there.

    Here's one, described as the whitest white (even though it looks a bit gray which might actually be fine) and comes in various sizes because you wouldn't want this mosaic...

    And another - the Salt is beautiful but the Andesine would probably be awesome too.

    Again, it sounds like you have your heart set on the watercut so go with that and figure out the rest of your BS given the watercut and granite. Good luck with your decision.

  • 14 years ago

    Ooh, beeps, those are gorgeous. I will bring them to the tile person. What has been bothering me is what a couple people have said - the difference in the rough marble and the refined watercut. And the cleaning can't be ignored. What I personally am seeing when I look at the rough is thinking it should be on the outside of a house.

    And slonewby - I just saw your BS - it came out so beautifully. So classic. And I do see your point about mixing. I am really driving myself crazy with this. In our last reno in old house, we never did anything and I had white plaster for 10 years. Much less stress!

  • 14 years ago

    I think you are answering your own question about the rough. In your first post you say you aren't sure it works with the watercut (and several people, including me, have agreed with that thought), and now you say you think it belongs on the outside of a house. So... umm... unless this is an outdoor kitchen and you didn't tell us it sounds like it is time to stop thinking about it for your BS? :)

    Seems like you have decided and it is time to move on and figure out the last element. Just to warn you, the Salt and Andesine run about $45/sq ft. Sigh. Less than your watercut, however! I'm in love with them and may suck it up even though I have a long run of BS. I'm still thinking and won't be doing anything about it until December. House won't be done until then. Maybe I'll win the lottery before then. Oh, but you have to play to win, right? Sigh. It's always somethin'. ;o)

  • 14 years ago

    At least there is no *real* rush in getting a BS done. You can function in a kitchen without a BS just fine until you find that perfect one. Don't settle and don't be afraid to revisit ideas you thought about and discarded. I was looking at ALL sorts of things and, to this day, our builder laughs and says, "honestly, does EVERYTHING need to make your heart sing?" My answer to him is a resounding YES.

    Yet, after searching high and low (location AND price), I went back to my original, plain cream subway but slapped a bevel to the edge and it made all the difference in the world for me AND my hubby.

    I think, because we spend SO much time and effort putting a new remodel together, we sometimes feel that EACH and EVERY decision must be *special*...but sometimes, those *special* selections just fight with each other too much to work even though we love them individually (revisit my thread about the green crackle glass!)...so, in the end, I guess we need to pick something wonderfully spectacular and then have the rest of the elements work to enhance that one lovely.

    Always go with your gut. If the rough cut makes you think it belongs outside, it will always make you think it belongs outside.....You'll find the right choice and you'll know it when you do~