Software
Houzz Logo Print
raenjapan

New build kitchen--layout reality check

12 years ago

Hi everyone, we're beginning the building of a new house, and I wanted to run the layout by you guys to make sure I'm not missing something huge.

We are a very informal family, and the downstairs floor plan is very open, so these dimensions aren't necessarily set in stone. Total width is about 14', and 18' from top to bottom. There will be a large window (4'x6') over the sink.

The cabinets are pulled away from the wall a few inches to allow for extra deep counters.

There will be uppers on the wall with the microwave, but probably nowhere else (maybe open shelving around the stove.)

Any thoughts?

Thanks!

Comments (25)

  • 12 years ago

    Here is the whole layout of the downstairs, for reference.

  • 12 years ago

    Most of it seems fine to me. I have only two notes:

    1) How wide is the walkway down the middle of the kitchen? That distance isn't clearly marked. It's clear from your plan that you intend to accommodate multiple cooks, and for that you'd need the walkway to be at least 4' -- preferably 5'.

    2) I would lose the island seating. It always looks odd to me to have seating in the kitchen when the dining table is right there, and in this case, I also think the unusual shape of the island designed to accommodate that seating is odd.

  • 12 years ago

    Thanks, Jillius. The kitchen isle is 4'. I've experimented with different spacing in other homes, and 4' works best for me. 5' makes me not want to use the island for prep.

    Generally, I'm the only cook. It's just my husband and me in the house, no kids unless we are entertaining. I'd like to have the island sink for the times I'm prepping food while we have guests. We're very much a kitchen-y family, every time we have people over everyone ends up around the island, and we eat at the island daily.

    I'd sooner loose the dining area (which has gone almost completely unused in other homes) than the island seating. :-)

    The shape of the island, however, is negotiable. I'm thinking of maybe a live edge walnut slab there that would be irregularly-shaped. The round was just a computer short-hand for that. Or we may expand seating to the end.

  • 12 years ago

    1) 4' is fine. I just wanted to make sure it wasn't less than that. It's definitely a personal preference thing between 4' and 5', so you should go with what you like.

    2) Given what you said about the island, I'd definitely expand the seating to the end and make sure that seating area is very roomy. How wide is the walkway on that side of the island, between the island and the pantry/stairs?

  • 12 years ago

    You plan is very similar to mine, and I find mine works very well. For me, a bit less than 4' is optimum for the aisle in the work area. DH often loads the DW after meals, and I have no trouble getting through.

    I suggested a couple changes below.

    I would put the trash beside the prep sink. I often move drippy vegetable peelings and the like from sink to trash. Nice to drip over the least possible space.

    I would definitely put the door into the pantry into the middle of the wall so that you can make use of the right wall for storage. Much more efficient like this. And I like narrow 4" or so shelves on the back of the pantry door. Great place for spices!

    Will you have wall cabinets? If you do, I suggest that you consider 15" deep cabs. I did this and the additional 3" of storage space is WONDERFUL. Not a great idea if you will do a lot of prep on that wall, but probably you will prep on the island. I would also strongly recommend susans in the corner wall cabs as well as in the base cabs. Astonishing amount of storage right at your fingertips that way.

    I love the idea of the live edge wood countertop to accommodate seating on the island. I personally would definitely keep the seating. I like the way the seating expands the island into the open spaces below. But be sure that if you use wood on the entire island, you use a finish that will hold up to the heavy, messy prep you will probably be doing there.

    Finally, if you can do so, I would consider making the island even longer--maybe 2' longer, so that it ends even with the perimeter cabinet run. You will use and enjoy the extra prep space--and drawer space.

  • 12 years ago

    I would also move the trash. Where it goes depends on how you work (I tend to like them next to a sink). Next to the prep sink is a good location -- I just wouldn't want it right behind the main sink. That's a butt bumper waiting to happen. Off to the side and behind would be okay for pivot and dump from either sink. Better not to be blocking hte DW though -- it might take a little adjusting.

  • 12 years ago

    Thanks for the input, guys. I agree the trash needs to be moved, and the door to the pantry. Also definitely need a bigger island! ;-) Really, I love that idea. Done.

    We had wood counters in our last kitchen, and I honestly didn't love them as a work surface. They were ikea oak finished with waterlox, and I found that I'm just too messy of a cook to keep them looking good. I think we will do a combo of something more rugged in the prep area along with the soft wood dining edge. Anyway, those are details I can work out later. I mostly wanted to make sure we shouldn't be moving any walls or plumbing at this stage.

    Thanks again.

  • 12 years ago

    Which way is "up" on that staircase? Here's what I'm getting at: Could you expand the pantry to under the stairs and get some extra storage space . . . kind of for free?

    I don't like the sink off to the side. I see that you're putting it in that location so you can have a window, but I think it feels "off" in that spot. I think in this case I'd rather have the main sink centrally located on the island (and do away with the prep sink).

    I agree that 4' or even a little less is ideal for the aisle. My current galley kitchen is a little wider than 5', and it is irritating. It's just one good step too wide.

  • 12 years ago

    The staircase has basement stairs underneath, so no storage there.

    Sorry, but I'm not a fan of having the main sink on the island. We use the island for too much, I paint and sew, and having a big, uninterrupted surface available is part of the draw of the island. I have also frequently wished we had two sinks in the kitchen, so I want to keep the prep.

  • 12 years ago

    A few tweaks (some that others have pointed out as well), but overall the same general design you already have - it's pretty good!

    1. I moved the Trash pullout (18" with 2 bins) to next to the prep sink but across from the Cleanup and Cooking Zones - so the pullout is accessible from all 3 primary work zones (Prep (#1), Cooking, Cleanup). Note that you will use it more while working in the Prep and Cooking Zones than you will in the Cleanup Zone.

    I extended the island for more work space as well as another seat. You will most likely need legs (or other supports) for the island b/c of its size and lack of counters underneath the circular. BTW...I think the shape gives it character and it doesn't cause traffic or other issues - so why not have it? :-)
    I moved the DW to the other side of the cleanup sink so it's not in the way of someone working at the island when the DW is open (and won't be venting steam out on that person if it's running!) It also removes it from the other "primary" prep zone (b/w the sink and range) - allowing two people to prep and another to cleanup.

    In fact, this kitchen will work very well as a multi-worker kitchen. You could actually have someone cleaning up, 3 people prepping and one person cooking (or 4 prepping + 1 cooking).
    I suggest dish storage in the cabinet next to the DW and the end cabinet across from the DW in the island. This makes it easy to unload the DW without moving :-) as well as locates the dishes, glasses, etc. near the Dining Room for easy table setting (and for keeping the person setting the table from getting underfoot of those who are prepping/cooking!)
    I liked your MW and Refrigerator placement, so I left them as-is.

    The refrigerator is out of the way so it's not a looming presence in the middle of that open space, but accessible from inside and outside the kitchen, and located so it's just as easy to go around the outside of the island as it is to go through the working part of the kitchen for someone who's not working in the Kitchen. Hopefully, outsiders will take the outside when others are working in the kitchen!

    The MW is placed so that a snacker can use it while others are working - and they don't get in each other's way. You can also have someone cooking part of a meal at the MW while others are using the range or prepping. Water is easily available at the prep sink.
    Drawers for most of the base cabinets!



    Zones:


    [Edited for typos]

    This post was edited by buehl on Sat, Sep 13, 14 at 11:36

  • 12 years ago

    I don't really have much to add, but I really like having a prep sink on the island. I changed it from my main sink on the island and I'm REALLY glad that I did.

    Buehl is amazing (as are other GWers), but buehl's help was integral for my kitchen. I really like the DW moved to the left of the main sink. Great idea.

  • 12 years ago

    Thank you FamCook! I'm glad I was so helpful to you! Others were very helpful to me when I was doing my kitchen as well.

    As to Raenjapan's kitchen, I hope this helps her/him - s/he was already made a good start.

  • 12 years ago

    I like Buehl's layout with a few tweaks. Personally, I would want more clear counter space on the north end of the island, as it's most convenient to both range and prep sink and most likely where you will prep. Right now, there is only 24". So, I would move the prep sink (and trash) down - maybe center it on the island. Then, I would move the cleanup sink and DW all the way down to the very end of the run so that it is not directly across from the prep sink (bumping butts syndrome). You may then wish to get a paneled DW, if it would bother you to see the appliance at the end of the run.

  • 12 years ago

    Sorry I'm just getting back to this. Thanks so much, Buehl! You're great!

    I'm linking to the kitchen in our last house because the layout was similar and I really liked it despite it being quite a bit smaller and a tiny bit cramped, especially the isle behind the island. Won't be an issue in this kitchen.

    Here is why I bring it up: I'm not completely convinced that I will use the island for prep. I cook a whole lot, and I'm a bit set in my ways. I tend to prep and cook at the same time, doing my prep in the space in between the sink and the stove, so my attention can be divided between chopping things and stirring. I rarely used the island for prep in our last kitchen. But, it didn't have a sink.

    So, any thoughts on this? If in reality I'm going to continue to do 95% of my prep in between the main sink and the stove, I'd rather have the extra counter space afforded by having the DW to the right of the sink. In our last house, the isle was about 40" between the island and perimeter, and we stored all the dishes in the 36" drawers in the island. I was able to unload the dishwasher with the drawers open, it worked great, so I should be able to do that with a 48" isle no problem, even with the DW on the right.

    I realize the "best" solution to this is to put the prep sink on the perimeter and main sink in the island, but I really don't like that for several reasons (there's no pleasing the woman!)

    Also, we will be using ikea boxes again in this kitchen, so sizes need to be standard. And I'd really like to get back to a 36" sink, I had one in a previous house and much preferred it.

    Thoughts?

    Here is a link that might be useful: old kitchen

    This post was edited by raenjapan on Tue, Sep 16, 14 at 9:49

  • 12 years ago

    Ok, I've messed around a bit. I think I can keep the DW on the right side, allowing me more prep space, and store dishes in the three cabs at the bottom of the island and sink. I think the only thing I really lose by doing that is that it would make it a little worse for multiple cooks, but since that happens about once a year, I believe I'm OK with that. And there is still the island prep to fall back on in that case.

  • 12 years ago

    What is the reason you would prefer the DW to be on the right rather than on the left? Is it handedness? I am severely, severely right hand dominant, and I have zero issues loading my mom's left-side dishwasher.

    Seems as if it would be nice to get the dishwasher out of the way down at the end instead of opening right into the middle of things.

  • 12 years ago

    The reason is it gives me 24" more prep room in between the sink and the stove, and that's my favorite place to prep. I want a 36" sink, and I want more than 36" between the sink and stove. I know the island is supposed to be the main prep area, but I'm not sure that's going to happen with my cooking style.

    I understand the advantage of the DW on the left, I'm just not sure it outweighs my desire to have that extra prep space. No one is cleaning while I'm cooking, but while I'm cooking I like to have room to spread out.

    Still thinking about it. I appreciate all the replies. :)

  • 12 years ago

    I agree that it is best not to put the cleanup sink on the island. You do not want to pile dirty dishes there.

    Glad you centered the pantry door. I would put 18" or so deep shelves on the back for storing small appliances and big roasters and such. 8" or 10" deep on the sides for cans and jars and such.

    Are you going to have wall cabinets?

    Can you play with rounding the bottom of the island almost to a circle (except on the left side)? I really like the way the rounder seating radius in Buehl's plan improves conversation.

  • 12 years ago

    So swap the DW with the 24" cabinet. You'll need an end panel to support the countertop, but the DW can be at the end of the run.

  • 12 years ago

    If you can center the sink in the window and want the dishwasher on the right...I can see that would give you access to that upper cabinet for glasses, etc.

    It would also be easier to load pans, directly from the range. And...if you want access to silverware, etc. from that end cabinet, that might be more convenient for 'helpers' than access to the dishwasher.

    I like your plan :)

  • 12 years ago

    Why would you lose any prep space at all if the dishwasher were on the left? Isn't the dishwasher 24"? You have 24" on the left of the sink now. Put the dishwasher there and have that 24" cabinet on the right of the sink. The counterspace dimensions would remain identical.

  • 12 years ago

    Oh, sorry Jillius, I thought you were talking about Buehl's plan where I have 4' on the left of the DW and about 3' (with the required 36" sink) on the right. I hadn't thought about just having the DW by itself on the end. It's weird how you look at something so long you get tunnel vision. :)

    In THAT case...yeah. I'm liking that. The only disadvantage I see (and this is just one of the results of a big kitchen) is that it's a long walk to the uppers on the fridge wall. I really don't know what I'll be storing in those...this kitchen will have about double the storage I'm used to. Spices and sauces and stuff, probably....ooooh, that's going to be great!!

    Yay, new big kitchen!

  • 12 years ago

    Haha, I have been there with that tunnel vision. Now that we've installed our kitchen, I have thought of a million alternate layouts. At the time, what we did was the only thing I could think of that worked. I'm still happy with everything, but it is just astonishing how much easier it is to think broadly and creatively now that I'm out of the process!

  • 12 years ago

    Okay, this has nothing to do with the kitchen (sorry) but I am wondering if you really want to access that bedroom via the utility hall? Seems like a noisy/busy area for a bedroom door. Unless there are mechanicals in the way, I would rather create a short hallway by the front door to that bedroom, then move the closet so you don't lose closet space. Just a thought.

  • 12 years ago

    Well, the front door is on the south side of the house. This house has a kind of unusual floor plan because it's just my husband and me and we have some different preferences.We plan to stay here long term, but we did want 3 bedrooms just in case we have to sell for some reason.

    That room will be my art studio, and I like having the door there because it allows good access to the kitchen and bathroom (water sources, and the island in the kitchen. I have tried to avoid hallways as much as possible in this plan.

    If we moved the closet , it would need to go to the exterior wall on the back, and then we'd lose a big window. Trade-offs everywhere. :) But thank you for the suggestion, I'm always open to them!