Software
Houzz Logo Print
elle7381

Help choosing granite kitchen countertops

15 years ago

Need help choosing granite kitchen countertops. My husband and I have been looking at granite slabs for weeks and cannot agree on one. The cabinets are medium to dark wood with blacks veins in them. The refrigerator is stainless, double oven, cooktop and dishwasher are black. I want something subtle, medium to light colored. (medium to big kitchen 62 feet of granite needed). I don't really like the giallo venzenia or the imperial gold but my husband does. I feel they are to busy. We currently have white formica so those patterns are to big of a change for me. If you love your countertops please send me a photo or give me the name, I am desperate. I wish I could afford a decorator but can't, and I don't find the people at the yards helpful at all. Also, I realize if I don't come up with something soon, my husband will put it off. So frustrating. I need someone who has gone through it. Thank you

Comments (12)

  • 15 years ago

    I have no suggestions for you, but want to sympathize with your agony :) It has been a long, hard decision for me too. I find myself even having dreams about it, and I know I am driving my husband crazy with my lack of ability to make a decision! Good luck Elle.

  • 15 years ago

    So by "too busy" do you prefer a granite with more movement and less of a "speckled" effect? For me, most all granites are "busy". ANY granite with its inherent stone will be busy compared to formica. If you like the 1 tone of formica, perhaps getting a Ceasarstone countertop would be a nice compromise. A bit more tones than formica but not as busy as granite(depending on choice, of course, but...)

  • 15 years ago

    Also, if you can post a picture of your kitchen so we can see the actual space, that is easier to offer suggestions. The Ceasarstone I think would perhaps be a compromise would be one of the following:
    Desert Limestone
    Baja
    Buttermilk
    Champagne Limestone

  • 15 years ago

    I googled your husband's choices and although they have pattern, they are not as busy as you can get in a granite. First thing first is that you both have to agree on a color and then how busy. My first thought too after white formica was that I did not want movement! Guess what? We chose a dark giallo ornamental with movement. Look at the finished kitchen blog for inspiration. Going to a granite yard can be over whelming.

  • 15 years ago

    Hi elle..

    My sister has "Fire Bordeaux" with her med. cherry cabs and black appliances. I wish I had a close-up, but it's calm in my opinion, with a creamy greyish background and some mild coloring swirling through it. It's very different from what I chose, but I love it in her kitchen.

    Here's a link to the granite yard where she found it. Fire Bordeaux is on Page 4....

    KA:)

    Here is a link that might be useful: fire bordeaux pg. 4 of Exotic Granites

  • 15 years ago

    I'll take photos of my kitchen when I get home from work, but here is a photo of my cabinets we want to match. http://img.auctiva.com/imgdata/1/5/6/2/0/7/7/webimg/511813892_o.jpg

  • 15 years ago

    I have very dark cabinets and tropic brown granite...I prefer light granite with lots of movement, but I am really glad we ended up with tropic brown in our kitchen... it isn't "busy" IMO and it gives the room a more traditional feel. best of all it always looks clean-no staining or marks ever. Not sure if it's a color you would consider but just my 2 cents:)

  • 15 years ago

    I totally feel your pain. I have been looking at granite in at least three different states and for 6 months!!! Ok, I was just visiting those states and saw a granite yard and pulled over so it wasn't like I made a special trip but that should tell you how much it's bugging me, lol. I know what you are going through. It makes it doubly hard when you and hubby aren't on the same page. I found one that is so beautiful called Colonial Gold it didn't look like most of the Colonial Gold slabs I have seen it was very soothing the pattern was very uniform and reminded me of water flowing. Wish I had a photo of it. I also think that Bianco Romano is less frenetic and Kashmir Gold or Kashmir White were nice. Ceasarstone is just too much like the Corian I had for 14 years so I just didn't want to get that if I could avoid it, though I am sure it is a wonderful product.

  • 15 years ago

    I feel your pain! I have been wrestling with granit/tile/quartz for a month. I think we have finally decided on Persa Avorio granite for counter and BS. It is tan/gold, grays and black. Most of the different slabs I have seen in pics are pretty consistent. I think it is more subtle than a lot of the granites we saw but has nice movement. We also liked Golden Beach, but there is a lot of variation in the different slabs. There is a thread on here for Persa Avorio...not sure how to link it.....

  • 14 years ago

    I struggled for MONTHS .... so many choices and I knew I'd ever get to do it again (because of the money and finally saving up enough to have the granite in the first place!). I finally chose one called Giallo Napoli ... ended up totally in love with it. My cabinets are white and I have the black and stainless in my kitchen like you do. I didn't want too many competing colors. My granite has a tricky chocolate-amethyst that would look AWESOME with your cabinets with the black veining in them. Here is my post from when I was lurking around trying to figure out what to do ... I, like you, didn't think I would like 'busy' granite with slight/some movement ... it worked for me though, although I STILL haven't chosen a floor yet ... did you say what your floor is?
    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg0211302019266.html

    Here is a link that might be useful: GammyMommy's post & pics

  • 14 years ago

    Here is ours...absolutely luv it!
    Cashmere Gold.....
    Did you ever think of doing a solid outer (eg black) and color/movement for main part of kitchen? It does look fabulous !

    http://i1011.photobucket.com/albums/af233/flatman/Kitchen%20Oct%202011/f76b55a9.png

    http://i1011.photobucket.com/albums/af233/flatman/Kitchen%20Oct%202011/011239ae.png

  • 14 years ago

    The wood is pretty! I probably wouldn't do something with lots of waves since you do have a lot of "movement" in the cabinet itself.

    Something like mine might work. Or kitchenaddict's (I can't remember the name) if you want similar without the caramel colors.