Software
Houzz Logo Print
bikemanswife

Can we replace counter if backsplash rests on it?

16 years ago

We are interested in swapping out our old, tired, almond-colored laminate countertop without also redoing the backsplash, but there's a problem: The counter appears to have been installed first, then the backsplash put up so the tiles actually sit right on the back edge of the counter. Is it possible to replace the counter without having to remove the tiles? If we had to remove the tiles, ... um ... can that even be done without breaking them? We don't have enough extra (left by the previous owner) to put new ones up. I should mention, the backsplash is along the entire length of the counter, not just behind one area. In case that helps.

Thank you for any advice you can give!

Alice

Comments (7)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Installing the counter first is the correct way to do it. What type of tile is the backsplash, and what size? You could try to carefully remove the first row or two and then re-install them. Or you could do something different where you remove them, something that accents the existing tile. Many people do an accent row. Do you have a picture?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, I don't have a very good picture, but here's what I've got. The tiles are 6" x 11.75". They are shiny and look like, oh, how to describe, butcherblock travertine. You can see in the picture where the backsplash ends -- it's fairly thick (1/4").

    If we did an accent it would be a really BIG accent. Can't really envision what that'd look like. I'm not in love with the backsplash we have, but I really am not ready to take on that project!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    could you put a 4" high BS of the material you are using for new counter top and then a 2" accent tile across separating the BS now and the new BS (counter top type)?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I suppose that's an idea we could consider, though I think if we're going to get into any tiling at all, I have a feeling DH will just want to replace all of it because he's not wild about it. Truth be told, I'm not either but I didn't want the project to mushroom like so many do!

    So the answer is: No, we can't remove/replace it without removing at least one row of tile. Yes? Ugh.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You say the tiles are directly on top of the counter? Normally there will be an expansion joint filled with caulk between the two - it may only be 1/8" though, but it should be there.

    Then you can carefully cut out the caulk (it should not be grout, but it might be). After removing anything mounted to the counter top, I'd get out my circular saw, set the depth to just cut through the laminate, and cut it off close to the backspash and remove the bulk of it. Then you should be able to carefully loosen and pry the portion remaining and remove it with no damage to the tiles. But you are going to want to go very slow and work back and forth the entire length so you don't put pressure on the edge of the tiles. If your counter is not glued on, you may find this will slip right out from under the tiles. How the laminate is attached to the cabinets will determine how hard this will be more than anything.

    The main problem you have at this point - your new counter has to be the same width as what you took out so it will slide in place. And you may find with the layout of your counter, the new one can't be installed by sliding it under the backspash. It's no fun to take the time to carefully remove something and then discover it has to ALL come off to get the new stuff installed anyway.

    This is the type of demo I won't let my DH handle. He gets impatient with the small back and forth working to loosen something and will get some leverage and pull or pry, and who knows what is going to pop loose then. He can hand fit a board along a uneven wall, but he has no patience for demo work.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks, MacyBaby. That's good info and I'll share it with DH. I was already worrying about the thickness of the new countertop (what if we switch to granite, or concrete, or quartz, or ...??) and what that would mean. I suspect we're going to end up doing the whole kit and kaboodle. Which means we'll also think about restaining our oak cabinets. And probably switching out the hinges. And replacing the stove. And ... Sorry, gotta go grab my checkbook!

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!