Software
Houzz Logo Print
artemis78

Calling Hafele Magic Corner or LeMans pullout owners!

16 years ago

We're trying to decide whether to use the Magic Corner I or the LeMans pullout in our kitchen, and would love to get some feedback from anyone who has one of these and has been using it for a bit (especially LeMans since there are some older threads with Magic Corner people). We had originally picked the LeMans because it was cheaper, but it turns out our cabinetmaker has some extra Magic Corner trays we can have if we get that, which makes the cost essentially the same for either. We will have a drawer over it so that limits the clearance a bit. We have a 42" cabinet with an 18" door, so we can't use the Magic Corner II, just the one where the door attaches to the pullout, so my husband is a bit concerned about that it might get rickety over the years. We will be storing infrequently used small appliances and pots on it.

Any thoughts or pros/cons on yours? Would you make the same choice again?

Thanks!

Comments (10)

  • 16 years ago

    I have the LeMans (or as I call it, the "peanut thingy"). We got it because it was what our cabinet maker recommended; he said he used to put in lazy susans, but had complaints, so started with these and apparently clients have been happier. I haven't used mine for very long (still moving back into the kitchen), but I can tell you it is MUCH better than what I had before, which was a gaping black hole from which storage lids, sippy cups, and measuring spoons never returned....

  • 16 years ago

    honeychurch...interesting. My KD had the exact opposite experience. She said she discourages her clients from using blind corner pullouts b/c she's had so many complaints about them. They don't hold up well over time and when something falls off you have to literally crawl inside the cabinet to retrieve the fallen item b/f you can close the cabinet.

    Lazy/super susans, OTOH, rarely have issues, especially if your cabinetmaker can make one that has the back/side walls closely follow the contour of the round shelves. That's what we had in our old kitchen. Our lazy susan was the only cabinet in our 13-year old kitchen that worked as well at demolition as it did when we moved in...flawlessly! Nothing ever fell off b/c there was no room to fall off and the mechanism worked smoothly...and we stored relatively heavy items in our lazy susan...all our pots & pans, etc. We also had the one w/the door attached to the shelves so it rotated inside the susan which meant no doors banging against adjacent cabinetry.

    As with anything else, of course, the quality of your cabinetmaker's hardware will make a big difference...whether it's a lazy/super susan or a blind corner pullout. Hafele, from what I've heard, makes good hardware, so I suspect either one will work well enough.

  • 16 years ago

    Dear artemis78: We don't have either pull-out right now. But we are considering the Magic Corner I for our new kitchen. The Magic Corner looks more functional than the Le Mans for the things I'd want to store. And I like the efficient "one action" required for the Magic Corner I, with the hardware opening when one swings open the door better than the Magic Corner II. For what it is worth, I am considering the Magic Corner without a drawer over it.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm no help at this point, but look forward to additional responses to your question. I will be putting in a 'peanut thingy' in the remodel. I currently have a *&%$! lazy susan with the door attached to the turntables that's waaaay too easy to pinch fingers. A supersusan with a different style door would solve that problem, however I don't have room in the new layout for that type of corner unit. The KD recommended the LeMans and after looking at it and the MC, I opted to go with her rec. Time will tell.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks all!

    We are (thankfully!) so far down this road that lazy susans aren't an option at all, but in our particular case that didn't make a lot of sense anyway---we have 21" on one side of the corner and 30" on the other, so putting in a l azy susan of decent size would have meant giving up our wide pot drawers....the lazy susan never had a chance!

    @puppeez, one of our misgivings about the LeMans is that we haven't seen one in real life. Did it seem relatively sturdy when you looked at it? I also have heard good things about Hafele, and our cabinetmaker has installed a few Magic Corners and has glowing things to say about them but he hasn't used the LeMans before and we didn't encounter it in our cabinet hunting, either. The pictures do show pots and pans on it and it's rated for decent weight, but who knows....

  • 16 years ago

    My kitchen isn't installed yet, but we've ordered the LeMans system. Anything will be better than digging around in that blind corner! LOL When I tried it out it seemed to be very smooth in operation and our cabinet company said that there is very little repair complaints to them. I really like the idea that you can pull out the top or bottom independently and that they are installed in the cabinet and not on the door so there is no stress on the door at all.

  • 16 years ago

    Artemis, from my experience it moves very smoothly and seems very sturdy. It says it can hold 30 kg (66 lbs) per shelf, though I will most likely put heavier things on the bottom shelf until I am confident of its capability. I was also planning on putting shorter heavier items along the perimeter railing, with taller lighter items in the middle--this way I think things might be less likely to fall off...

  • 10 years ago

    Hi Chef Shalleck I am about to install two Le Mans units in my kitchen. My kitchen fitter recommends them but you have had a bad experience with them. I understand there are various qualities - look on ebay and see how they can range in price from £55 to over £200 each. Maybe that makes a difference. Unfortunately I am unable to install drawers (as you have done) because mine are both deep corner cupboards. Let me know your thoughts . thank you

  • 8 years ago

    Chef David SHalleck you said:

    LMans has same space as drawer in the *open part* and ignoring the corner space. I hven't done the actual comparison but seems likely that the LeMans is really a gimmick. Can you please add details for the square footage. BTW wouldnt the Magic corner be even better?

Sponsored
Haus Studio
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars28 Reviews
Franklin County's Preferred Custom Cabinetry & Design Studio