Software
Houzz Logo Print
tashamh2

Quote & Layout from Amish Cabinet Maker

14 years ago

I promise this will be my last posting regarding cabinets and layout!

Master Design Cabinetry (Amish cabinetmaker) came highly recommended on this site as well as in our local magazine called "Washingtonian". We had a very pleasant phone conversation and email exchange and he sent me the quote and layout below. I want to get your thoughts before I drive 2.5 hours to his shop to see the cabinets in person. This could work with my budget if I choose some less expensive finishes, i.e. non-glass stacked cabinets, backsplash and countertops.

Thoughts?

Comments (16)

  • 14 years ago

    Hi there,

    I recommended Amos and we are using him again for our laundry and powder room. I can't see the layout very well so cannot comment on the layout.He is quite practical - reminded me I need to have a place for cookie sheets (I told him I did not bake coookies but I am glad we put in dividers which I use for other things)

    It looks like you are going with cherry (stained) I presume? If so I recommend you do go and check out his stained cherry doors and his white ash drawer boxes which is what "sold" me. His dovetails are wonderfully smooth and he puts the heartwood of the cherry on the middle of the door and his doors have very little color variation in them (there was another thread about variation in wood doors). Amos works with a small door manufacturer and I really liked how the doors ended up on the stained cherry side in my kitchen.

    I am in PA otherwise I would offer for you to come and see what he did but I think I am 2.5 hours away for you as well.

    The installation seems high to me but that maybe because of the drive, etc.That may be where you can shave some costs if your GC can install

  • 14 years ago

    Hi Fks3 - thank you for your post. I hope to make it out to his shop this Friday if possible. Amos mentioned that they prefer to handle the install since they know how to make them look nice. Do you think it matter who handles the installation? It would be less coordination on my part if the GC took care of everything - install, plumbing, electrical, flooring, etc. vs. having to coordinate with Amos' team.

  • 14 years ago

    Hi Tashamh2

    We are going out there on Friday to pick stain color for bathroom and for laundry room

    For the kitchen we did beaded inset and we felt it was important for Amos's team to install as I know that is trickier. We loved Nelson and Henry - for the crown molding Henry colored in the ends on so that no unstained wood would show through the joins.We are not as far as you so I know my installation was less and they are great guys. I was just thinking that was high as a proportion of the kitchen.

    For our bathroom that we did six years ago we went frameless with a local cabinet maker (not Amos) that did not install so we had our our GC install and he did fine. We were not as happy with how the doors on our bathroom turned out in terms of variation and we had paid for select doors which is why we were both pickier this time around with the stain on the kitchen doors.

    Bottom line - how fastidious is your GC - I know Amos's guys are super careful - the granite people were impressed that they did not have to do anything to level the bar counter in any direction b/c Nelson had been so careful

  • 14 years ago

    Badgergirl,

    I posted on your thread on how much I love your kitchen, especially your gorgeous island. Looks like there are great prices in the Mid-West in terms of labor costs when I look at the price of delivery and installation. WOW - lucky you

    I am curious about the rev-a shelf price. While not apples to apples since I got the double trash in link below - the price you got seems like a bargain.

    http://www.rev-a-shelf.com/p-324-double-soft-close-w-tandem-heavy-duty-slides-waste-containers.aspx

    Depending on where folks are (relative to you) and if they are OK with not having a phone conversation- it may make sense to get a quote from your mid-West cabinet maker and pay for their travel etc since the prices are lower. The con is that it may be tough to visit the "shop" - just a thought.

  • 14 years ago

    Fks3 - my appt is at 1pm for this Friday. Maybe I'll see you there.

    Badgergirl - what a gorgeous kitchen! my goodness, love the island and hutch!

    Here's a better copy of the layout:

  • 14 years ago

    fks3- I guess I did get a bargain. I thought $145 was a lot of money until I had looked it up on the reva shelf website and saw that it was priced at $344. It is the one with the gas spring assist soft open and close. I think he gave it to me at his cost. I'm not sure if he made my peg in drawer insert or got it from reva shelf but he only charged me $50 for the same one that is $ 107 on the website.
    Tashamh- maybe you can try to bargain a little when you meet them in person.

    I had some snacks and pizza for the installers to eat instead of their own bag lunches and they wanted to deduct the price of the food from the bill. They also used a couple of our power tools and wanted to reimburse me for that. Of course I told them neither was necessary.

  • 14 years ago

    don't rule out swapping the cab to the left of frig for a counter ledge with a stool underneath.Reason is that you have a hallway/tunnel effect leading in/out of kitchen now. When doing laundry/kitchen activity you may like a "sit down with cup o tea" spot. The dining room now seems more removed, and so much more a part of the "front" room.

  • 14 years ago

    tashamh - just a quick plug for allowing the cabinetmakers to do the install themselves -- so much of the success of a kitchen depends on the little details, some of which are ironed out on the spot during install. I'd personally pick the actual cabinet carpenters over the GC's guys -- they have more invested in making it look good, and will be more perfectionist about it.

  • 14 years ago

    Tashamh, if it were mine, I might want to do away with the cabinets that form a U at the bottom, sink, corner. That'd make that corner good work space so there'd be very little storage lost. Then I'd move the DW into that corner, dedicating it to cleanup, and the area to the right of the sink for cooking.

    I'd mentioned finding potential additional space in the depth of usable walls, and the inches available in that bottom wall siding to the powder room could be used to build in a shallow but large cabinet on that wall--such as for spices, vinegar, soy sauce, other frequently used food items. Or perhaps for flat storage of baking trays, etc.

  • 14 years ago

    I'll second Circuspeanut's post. I've always heard that the install was trickier than building them.

  • 14 years ago

    Not to pile on, but I would also endorse having your cabinet maker do the install. In some cases, my guy used shims or did little adjustments to doors to get them to shut just right as he put them in. He also had them pefectly even for our granite guys...

  • 10 years ago

    badgergal, I am also in the midwest. Would you share the name of your amish cabinet maker? thanks!

  • 10 years ago

    @lbm3 check badgergal's reveal thread for the info and just to appreciate her kitchen details!

    The cabinet maker is a few posts down but I believe is located out of WI

    http://ths.gardenweb.com/discussions/2405967/re-reveal-curvy-natural-cherry-kitchen-tons-of-pics

  • 10 years ago

    before the shop makes the cabinets, be sure your range is selected and that the dw door will clear the face of the range. a 2 1/2" filler may not be enough.

  • 8 years ago

    Did you end up using Master Design? I’m in Northern VA and am exploring Amish kitchen cabinets. Would love to hear who you decided to use

Sponsored
Daniel Home
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars20 Reviews
Premier Interior Design Team Transforming Spaces in Franklin Co, Ohio