Software
Houzz Logo Print
goostergw

Final order dilemma: mostly white or mostly stained

13 years ago

I'm ready to order my beaded inset cabinets, and we're down to one final dilemma:

Should we go with white cherry outer cabinets and a stained cherry island, or the inverse -- stained cherry cabinets on the exterior with a white island? We've rejected the idea of putting whites on top and cherry stained on the bottom.

The home is a 75 year old Colonial.

The pros/cons that I've been able to distill from feedback from others and the archives here:

Pros/Cons of Cherry Stained Exterior:
+ Shows wear and nicks better
+ Is different than what is in there right now
+ Showcases cabinet detail better and may contrast better with the other choices
- Appears a bit dated for the area
- May appear to be relatively dark and weighty
- Most of the existing trim is painted

Pros/Cons of White Exteriors
+ Stands the test of time for a traditional home better
+ Is popular for resale right now, especially with younger buyers
+ Is a typical historical color for the neighborhood; there is other painted inset cabinetry in the home with most of the moldings in paint
- Some people think it may look cheap, even when it is more expensive
- Some people think the Christopher Peacock style kitchen is being overdone

Some other details that have been finalized:
* Counters are Super White quartzite
* Range is on exterior wall, and is a CorneFe Albertine in all stainless; DW is paneled on the exterior. The fridge and WD are in SS.
* Cabinets are beaded inset, with a flat panel

Have I missed any pros/cons?

Comments (7)

  • 13 years ago

    Cherry island. :)

  • 13 years ago

    Especially with the SW counters.....I really think the white perimeter would look best. (I may be slightly biased).

    But when I was deciding this in the last kitchen, I just sat at my table and stared at the space. When I realized that the entire room would look so dark if I went with the stained perimeter, I knew what I was doing. We did the cherry stained island, and also a separate area of cabinets around the fridge in the stained cherry.

    It's really what looks right in your space and with your lighting. But...that SW really will look fabulous with the white!

    Bee

  • 13 years ago

    I vote for the stained, only because I think it will look beautiful with the quartzite and warm up the stainless steel appliances. Lots of people like white, but it really depends on your lighting, your preference and how it looks with the other finishes, IMHO. Best of luck with your kitchen :)

  • 13 years ago

    Wow. It is really such a personal decision, and while you can try to logically outline the pros and cons, in the end you if you are planning on living in the house for 8 years you should go with your heart.
    Here is me playing devil's advocate with your list:
    Pros of stained: You can paint stained wood, you can't stain painted wood(without massive amounts of work). Natural cherry can never appear dark. Nothing is more timeless that stained cabinetry, in a classic style.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks for all the feedback. I think we ultimately understand it is our decision, but we definitely are split on the issue.

    Thanks localeater for the additional pro. That is entirely valid. You can always paint the stained cabinets but it is more difficult to go back.

    I think I found another pro: stain I think will handle the micro settling and heaving that can occur in an older home like ours. I think paint is prone to showing the small expansion cracks as well (The humidity in our area does not swing severely, however).

    The original choice for stain is a mid tone cherry with some red highlights. I think the concern with stain is that the tones can come in and out of style over the years.

    There are two corner windows and one in the center of the space. Lighting is being refreshed. The cabinetry in the nearby rooms that are not changing are painted, but there is a family room that is being replaced with the same cabinets.

  • 13 years ago

    If I had the option of doing an island I would actually make the island different from the perimeter cabinets. I would make it look more like a piece of furniture and in that case would do it dark stained. A 75 year old colonial, for me, invokes dark stained furniture (doesn't have to but does for me) and so for me - white perimeter and dark island with legs on the corners and feet. (This is for my next kitchen) :)

    my 2c.

  • 13 years ago

    I agree that you have to go with what feels right in your home. I went with a stained perimeter and white island and banquette. My kitchen is on the north side of the house and does not feel too dark due to recessed lighting. I also chose a light countertop color and floor which will help keep it lighter feeling.