Software
Houzz Logo Print
comom27

Downdraft for Island

11 years ago

I've decided to get the Bosch Flex Induction cooktop and need a downdraft (thanks again for all the advice that led me to induction. That said, I now need to pick a downdraft. My sales person has suggested an unbranded Kitchen Aid downdraft. It is $1000 with an internal blower. The name brand downdrafts she'd previously quoted ran from $1750-$2000 (purchasing the downdraft plus the inline blower).

Does anyone have input/advice? Would the KA be "good enough"? What is the difference btw the internal blower and the inline blower? I cannot run venting for a remote blower and we do not want a hood over the island. All of these downdrafts rise 13"-14".

Thanks for any help you can provide.

Comments (14)

  • 11 years ago

    The unbranded should work as well as the KA. Downdrafts do not have great reputations for reliability or effectiveness. I don't think I would pile a lot of money into one.

  • 11 years ago

    You're fighting gravity. I wouldn't invest much (or at all) in what will be a losing battle. Siting the blower remotely, at or near the exit rather than in the middle of your kitchen will help reduce noise.

  • 11 years ago

    Do an overhead hood. Maybe with a glass canopy. Downdrafts aren't for foodies. They are for those who do the occasional Sunday pancakes. Just not the bacon that goes with them!


    Most people fail to dedicate enough room to island cooking, so examine your layout knowing that 70% of your time is spent doing prep, next to, or across from, a water source. A dedicated prep spot takes 36''. Actual cooking is only10% of yur kitchen time. If you want to prep looking out into the room, then you need a much larger island than just the 12'' of emergency landing space on either side that you sometimes see in island cooking.


  • 11 years ago

    We have a Whirlpool glass cooktop with a built-in downdraft system. It is nearly worthless. Not enough flow to do much. You will need a lot of vent to draw rising warm steam downward. There are so many up-draft models and styles, can you put one in by sacrificing cabinet space. In our tiny kitchen we couldn't.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Pop up downdrafts are far better than the ones built into cooktops.

  • 11 years ago

    The short answer is get the maximum airflow you can.

    I'm using a downdraft in the third kitchen I've installed where overhead venting was not possible. The first one wasn't too bad, the second was useless and I'll put the current one up against most up drafts.

    First, most people don't realize there are 2 different types of down draft. The first tries to pull straight back down to counter level and just doesn't work for an island. The second stands above the counter and pulls sideways at 10-15 inches above the counter level. This 2nd type can work well providing there is enough air flow and that the pot depth is an inch or more below the air ingress.

    We ended up installing a 40" wide collector which draws air in 10" above the 36" induction cooktop at up to 500 cfm. It sits in a 10' long islan. This is used on a daily basis for serious cooking and works just as well as the overhead unit in our second home as long as the pot depth limit is respected.

  • 11 years ago

    Like everyone is saying, do everything you can to work in a hood. Even with hoods, you see the discussions ensue around capture area and CFM ... so with downdraft you basically start off with the battle lost. Even Gaggenau realized the drawbacks and came out with their funky telescopic swivel vent arm a few years back. I assume they killed it because the mechanics and economics made it impractical to continue to market.

    BTW, for what it's worth, the current Gagg downdraft raises about 22" out of the counter (not bad) and has lights - but I suspect it's a budget buster: Gaggenau Vario 400 Series AL400790


    Good luck.

  • 11 years ago

    I had a downdraft stove, and did not liked it at all, i was very worried about that as my family is is large and we cook a lot, so we decided to check the prices for island range hoods, and we were shocked how much a nice working island mount range hood would cost. We accidently came up on Kitchenhoods.ca , this is Canadian based company , which has very good pricing and also very nice products. They ship everything from British Columbia , and they do not charge for shipping. We got one of the lower end models they had on the website, but we are very happy with it and with the suction. My opinion is that downdraft stoves or ranges are very expensive , and ineffective when it comes to suction. The model we purchased is called SV400D- I30 , and it is very beautiful and small at the same time.


  • 11 years ago

    The hoods on Kitchenhoods.ca appear to be the no name hoods that are prevalent on eBay. I am suspicious when many of the hoods don't mention the manufacturer. There are also significant spelling errors in the installation guide and no information on how to get warranty service although they claim to offer warranties. I would shop carefully on such a site.

    I agree that an overhead hood is much better than a downdraft. I think Gaggenau discontinued the cool telescoping downdraft but you can still find it on eBay.

    Since most individuals spend so little time cooking, an island cooktop is not a preference. Most people spend more time prepping and I would prefer that people are not sitting at the island and getting splattered by hot oil while I try to achieve Wok Hay!!!

    Homepro01

  • 11 years ago

    I strongly disagree with Homepro01 , as i`m a kitchenhoods.ca range hood owner , and i believe that this purchase was the best purchase i could have made. I was looking at all this brand name range hoods, yes there is spelling mistakes on the website and on some of the manuals, but this does not mean that this company is fraudulent , to be honest i do not understand people that overspend on range hoods, the brand name on this range hood is Spagna Vetro. I got referred to them by a friend. This company has superb customer service and their customer service listen to a situation the potential customer has and they suggest what they believe is the better range hood for the situation. I also do not agree that they are prevalent on Ebay. Here is the link on their about us section just so you can see the manufacturer of their range hoods

    http://www.kitchenhoods.ca/range-hoods/about.php

    I would never buy a range hood that is very expensive , it makes no sense, these appliances are not something so special just so they can cost that much money.

  • 11 years ago

    I have to say also that i disagree with Homepro01 , i`m a proud owner of model SV218D- I30 which is not a very large range hood, and it is good in suction and noise levels too, we where debating between a downdraft and independent island range hood, i can not be more happier , because i was just about to purchase the downdraft ,but i decided to contact them and get their opinion on the downdraft. I decided that i would go for independent range hood, and this was the best decision i have made. The customer service is amazing, one of my boxes got lost during transit, they shipped another one immediately as they understood that everybody is on a dead line. I would recommend them in a heartbeat.

    Here is the link for my range hood


    http://www.kitchenhoods.ca/range-hoods/range-hoods-spagna-vetro-sv218d-p-120.html



  • 11 years ago

    Disagree all you want, these hoods have been discussed on these forums for years. The quality of the blowers on a range hood are important for those who cook and want quieter hoods. Also, the ability to filter is important.

    I said nothing about the company being fraudulent. I would be cautious of any company that has huge misspellings in commercial documents shared with the public. Would you purchase food where they misspelled the ingredients?

    I am happy you like your hoods but be forthright about the information you provide others who are trying to make decisions

  • 11 years ago

    We had a downdraft stove, and the happiest day of my life was when it was finally ripped out! Now for a range hood to be installed. In the meantime we use a fan with an open window. I know it's primitive, but I don't believe in buying on credit. I way prefer that interest money be in my own pocket.


Sponsored
Trish Takacs Design
Average rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars36 Reviews
Award Winning & Highly Skilled Kitchen & Bath Designer in Columbus