Software
Houzz Logo Print
deva33atlanta

Any experience with black spots in jade when pruning?

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

Anyone seen this?

Fresh cut... Some said on another thread that they thought it was just a reaction from steel. But after someone investigation I found these black dots go through the stem. I cut a chunk and disected.

After cinnamon sitting on it a few hours.

And now today. Several days later.

Ps. These are two different branches on the same plant.

Comments (31)

  • 11 years ago

    The images are too blurry for me to see what's going on....

    Josh

  • 11 years ago


    Sorry for the blurry photos. It's difficult to get my camera to focus on the area I want it to. Hopefully these are a little better. And thank you for your time and input!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I wish I had helpful information for you. But I have never seen rot like this before. The black....roots? worms? or whatever it is almost seem independent of the jade itself. To see it even dry up differently than the rest of the jade is interesting.


    edit: So I looked all over and this http://forums.gardenweb.com/discussions/1805895/leaves-falling-off-of-jade post seems helpful. Apparently, your black spots could just be the rot trying to spread through the plant to other areas through the jades vascular bundle? Sorry that was all I could find that seemed likely. I hope your jade makes it.

  • 11 years ago

    Not sure, but what Dephora said makes sense, based on the photos. If that is the case I would remove the rest of the stem. Hope the rest of your plant is OK. Never had a problem like this.

    Christopher


  • 11 years ago

    Thank you both for your input. It is so weird I know. I've never seen anything like this. I rescued this jade from campus so I've been dealing with trying to make it healthy since then. Her is a pic of the whole plant....



    As you can see from the photo I've already done some pretty heavy pruning and I'm seeing new growth. In the first photo you can see both cuts pretty good. The big one is all the way to the left, and the little one is just right and below that. If this is some kind of disease I don't want it to spread. But I also wonder if it will bounce back now that it is in good conditions. It went from a shady spot inside an office, with terrible compacted soil and it was randomly watered to what you see here. If I cut it back any further I'm cutting the smaller one completely off the main plant, and the big one... Well. I would cut it all the way back to the trunk and hope that it stops there. I really have no idea how far back this goes and where I could stop cutting. With it still being unknown if this is rot or something else, what would you do if this was your plant? The trunk is firm, and so are all the branches. And when I cut there was no funky smell. This plant did have a previous soft brown scale infestation. Any chance it's from that?

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Wooh, I just searched all over the internet because it was bothering me I have never seen this before and while I can't find any information about what this is on succulents.
    http://www.nzwine.com/assets/sm/upload/l1/zb/q2/zo/NZTD_100_Trunk_Diseases_Petri.pdf
    http://www.sites.ext.vt.edu/newsletter-archive/viticulture/06septemberoctober/06septemberoctober.html
    I did find numerous articles about a fungi based disease called "petri disease/blackgoo" it rots anywhere it spreads and the spores travel in the plant through the Xylem part of the vascular system, turning them black.

    I can't find any information that it goes on succulents or any plants other than grapevines, but the symptoms are so similar I think we can conclude your jade is infected with some type of Fungi that is trying to spread to other parts of the plant through the xylem. It is possible that somehow the scale that was on the plant had these fungi spores on them. Plus the stress of living the way it had before you saved it.

    The only real treatment after infection is to cut away all infection but that would mean totally scrapping the small trunk. :/

  • 11 years ago

    Sorry about your troubles with this plant Deva! I remember how excited you were to save it when you found it at your school.

    I think the research dephora found is really interesting. I would hope this is not the case for your jade, as you could lose a lot of it. How are the other cuttings doing that you were going to repot?

    Please keep us updated and how this all turns out.

    Good luck!

    -Erica

  • 11 years ago

    Just want to say if you do cut it more, sterilize your blade between cuts (to use a new blade) to avoid accidentally spreading it to uninfected tissue.

  • 11 years ago

    wow, dephora - thank you so much for all that research!!! I looked for information online for jade plants but never would've found that information. I can only imagine the time it took to find that. Thank you so much!

    It sounds like I'll be doing some cutting tonight. Its unfortunate but I will see what I can save. From what I read I could leave it and the plant may do okay, but itll spread this fungi to my other plants, and I just can have that. I am fine with getting rid of that smaller trunk... I really just hope that I dont loose the biggest trunk too! If so I imagine the top part of it will be healthy and I can root that. Guess my rescue came too late :-(

    I will take pictures and update everyone. Of course I would have this weird uncommon issue that no one on here has experienced before!!! At least we all get to learn from it!

  • 11 years ago

    No problem :D
    You have me completely hooked on what will happen with this jade.
    I look forward to your next images.


    deva33 Z8 Atlanta thanked dephora
  • 11 years ago

    Keep a close eye on it, and I know eventually you will get all of the affected tissue. Then I am sure the plant will bounce back, and respond with lots of new growth for you.

    Christopher


    deva33 Z8 Atlanta thanked kaktuskris
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Christopher for your words of encouragement. I was so excited when I found this jade - though it poor conditions I was sure I could nurse it back to health. It is very disappointing to learn that it has this stupid fungus! yes - I called it stupid! lol

    I actually can't cut tonight now. I came out to my car after work to find a flat tire and had to deal with that. Now I have to get going on some terrible homework for correlation and regression! At least 3 hours worth. If its not too late after that I will cut, but I'm not expecting anything.

    What are y'alls thoughts on cutting just the infected part? Like - if only one side of the trunk has the black spots I just cut until I get all that out and dust with cinnamon. This is in case the largest trunk is infected. I also find it interesting that the cinnamon literally pulled this gunk out. So, if it is still in there after I cut but I can't see it I am hoping the cinnamon will pull it out and I will know I need to cut some more. What do y'all think?


  • 11 years ago

    Honestly if it were mine, I just might go ahead and completely remove the rest of that infected stem, and monitor the rest of the plant from there. Just my opinion.

    Christopher


  • 11 years ago

    Christopher - there are two stems that are infected. The one smaller one I am going to completely remove from the plant. No problem with that. The second one, however, is on the largest trunk. If you look at my last two pictures you can see what I am talking about, especially in the first. The largest branch, all the way to the left of the picture, then the little on is just below and to the right. I only have one node to go until I hit the main trunk. I am really worried that the infection is in there. Fingers crossed its not. If it is.... I don't know what I will do. Trash it I guess :-( or at least take it back to the school.

  • 11 years ago

    ps... I am just taking a break from stats!


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Does it feel soft at all? (around that cut end).
    How about shriwelled part - is it dry or does it feel soft?

    I would cut it all the way close to main trunk anyway, I think that may look better - JMHO. That may, hopefully, remove all sick-looking part.

    Rina

  • 11 years ago

    Oh oh, I guess you might have to cut back to the main trunk to find out. You have nothing to lose. So when you have time away from your studies, cut away, and get to the bottom of it. Hope in the end you are left with at least some healthy tissue. But if it turns out the whole plant is affected, I would discard it and the soil as well, and disinfect the pot afterwards.

    With all the Jades I have, I have never come across anything remotely like this. Truly a mystery.

    Christopher


  • 11 years ago

    What do I think about quick fixes that seem to be used over and over that dont seem to solve the problem ? Or cinnamon ?






    I think cinnomin has better uses for me in the kitchen than it does on a slightly wonded jade as seen in the pic a slightly wonded VIa a single clean cut prunning jade.




    What efforts are you willing to take ? For how long ? Only to read this. No gurantees you may even have to trash it.




  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks again for your positive and encouraging words - most of you :-)

    Rina - it doesn't feel soft at all, which is another thing I think is weird. The area that is callousing and dying back to the next node is a little soft now, but below that it is firm. I have decided to go ahead and cut back to be safe.

    nomen - I don't quite understand what you are trying to say. I understand that for healthy, clean cuts, you don't have to use cinnamon. In this situation this jade is clearly not healthy and I am asking for constructive words on how I might get it back to being healthy. Do you suggest using something other than cinnamon that is more beneficial? I understand that I may not be successful, but I am not going to just trash a nice, large jade that I might be able to save with a little cutting. If it is possible why not try?

    And on that note - goodnight everyone! Stats homework is incomplete and will just have to be submitted late. Seriously - I think I have the worst professor ever!!! As an intelligent PhD student this stuff shouldn't be this hard! Now to read some for social psych and get to bed!

    here are my happy, healthy jades that have outgrown their shared pot! Repot soon and giving a few away to friends. I'll just think about these for now.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nomen
    I don't understand your post either.
    What do I think about quick fixes that seem to be used over and over that dont seem to solve the problem ? Or cinnamon ?

    Who is suggesting quick fixes? What are you referring to as quick fix?

    I use cinnamon as a fungicide (and found that it works great) on large cuts, usually branches thicker than a thumb. I always recommend light dusting. But it is not mandatory either! It is not a quick fix, just some extra assurance against possible fungus. I don't bother on smaller branches, they callus much faster.

    No cinnamon dusting on these cuts...:


    Sorry, but this sentence I think cinnomin has better uses for me in the kitchen than it does on
    a slightly
    wonded jade as seen in the pic a slightly wonded VIa a
    single clean cut prunning jade.
    doesn't make sense to me - pls. could you be clear what you mean?

    Rina

  • 11 years ago

    Didn't say cinnomin doesn't work nor wont work just said I'd rather not use it to heal bigger or smaller tree branch cuts ( prunnning) including jades.


    I don't understand what someone else doesn't understand.

    Why is it when they say " It works for me " cant understand we all had to count some losses


  • 11 years ago

    Ok.... Supportive GW friends. Bad news. Started the cut this morning...

    This is the large branch cut to the stem. Not looking good.

    So I thought I'd cut the small stem and find out if is all the way to the base.

    And it was. I also found that the roots were withering away. And I had signs of rot.


    This is when the disappointment really set in. I knew this plant was unhealthy when I brought it home. But I thought for sure I could nurse it back to health.

    But it just wasn't so.

    This is what I'm left with. 4 nice cuttings. I dipped them in root growth hormone so now I just wait and see if they root for me.



  • 11 years ago

    Here are pics of the individual cuttings. I think I will end up with some nice specimens here.



    This one might be my favorite. I can just imagine what I'll look like when it grows up.


    And I think is one might give me a cool bonsai looking guy. One can only hope.

    Does any one have tips for rooting larger cuttings like this?

    I also want to share, I first found GW when I had a large jade from my mother that was doing poorly. I learned it was rot and tried to save it. That picture earlier of my healthy jades are all I have left of that plant. I think I could've saved more had I been more agressive then as I am being now. I really hope this pays off!!! I have learned so much from this forum and really appreciate everyones kind and supportive words. As Erica mentioned I was really excited when I found this jade and brought it home. I have been waiting for a large jade for some time. But it looks like I will continue to wait. Thats okay though. It will be more fun to watch it grow!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    deva
    |I don't use rooting hormone for rooting jades.
    Here is a jade I just 'chopped' (March 30); from soil line to top it is 17.5" tall:


    The left branch is chopped off, it is pretty thick & 16" tall/long:
    (I just measured it, circumference is 3 1/4")


    I'll pot it up in about a week or two; there will be more pruning on main plant & the new plant...and yes, I dusted with cinnamon....
    I don't spritz trunk or leaves either.
    (I apologize for photos, taken with not-so-good-anymore phone camera)
    Rina

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Rina. I've rooted smaller cuttings without any problems but I know it gets increasingly difficult as the cuttings get larger. While none of them are that long/tall, the diameter of some of these is at least an inch of not more. I just really hope they root!!!

    So you just dust with a little cinnamon and place in a gritty mix? Or perlite/soil mix? I know not to water until I see growth. But I'm debating on what kind of mix to put them in.

  • 11 years ago

    deva
    do you mean an inch more in diameter than one I posted (that is just over 3" diameter)?
    Regardless the size, I do the same - except sometimes they may stay out of any mix for longer time. Not necessarily because I think they have to, just because sometimes I forget to plant them. None of them have died yet because of that.

    After cutting, I let them callus for a while (with or without cinnamon). After a while - weak, two or so - I pot them up. I use mixture of perlite, chicken grit and turface. Nothing measured exactly, just approx. 1-1-1. I may decrease turface portion sometimes slightly. Experimentally, I recently potted some cuttings of Tricolor in mix of only gravel & turface. That was in middle of November - so far all of them are growing, have roots and I don't see any difference in growth comparing with cuttings potted at the same time in mix of gravel+turface+perlite. They are in same location, same amount of light & watered at same time.

    Rina


    deva33 Z8 Atlanta thanked rina_Ontario,Canada 5a
  • 11 years ago

    Glad to see you were able to salvage some decent sized cuttings, in any case. I am sure you will be able to root them, and they will grow well in your care.

    Christopher


    deva33 Z8 Atlanta thanked kaktuskris
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks everyone. And thanks for the tips Rina. I think I will use the gritty mix I have on hand (1:1:1 chicken grit:turface:reptibark). I have them set in that bowl as you see in the picture and they are by a north facing window. So they will get some sun but not much. Anyone think that should have a little more light than that? I am planning on buying some basic clay pots this weekend for them. Then setting them in that window and forgetting about them for at least a month. Hopefully they have enough stored energy to put out some healthy roots!

  • 11 years ago

    Oh and I just meant that my cuttings are an inch or more in diameter. Your cutting looked much bigger!!

  • 11 years ago

    So sorry deva. :(

    But I'm sure these cuttings will root. Just look at all the positive, spring is FINALLY poking her head here in the North. They'll have good sun for a good start before our next doom and gloom winter. And atleast you could save some pieces of the Jade, so youll have quite few big ones eventually. If its any consulation, I dont have any big ones either, but hopefully (now that I know how to care for them properly) mine will grow into big ones too. (Unfortunatley, I would kill them usually within 6 months because back then I didnt even know what a succulent was! Lol

    Take care and the best of luck with them! :)

    deva33 Z8 Atlanta thanked LilBit7765