Need two 8x7 garage doors. I've narrowed it down to Amarr or Haas. The Haas door is called Wood Collection has an R value of 13. Estimate it in cherry w/ windows for $1200 per door.

Now the Amarr door is the oak summit w/ windows R value of 6. And I got an estimate of $1100 per door.

What I like about the Haas door is it comes in a smooth finish which looks a lot better I think than textured. Also has a pretty good color match to my front door.

The Amarr has only a textured finish n the colors don't match my front door, either too dark or too light.

I'm a little surprised the Amarr is cheaper because Amarr is typically a more expensive door I'm told.

I'm leaning more towards Haas because of color match n R value is better but never heard of Haas.

How would you scale this two brands 1-10?