Software
Houzz Logo Print
gary_cotterill

Entirely replacing potting mix

How often should old potting mix be washed entirely from a plant's roots and new potting mix added?

Comments (10)

  • 11 years ago

    It depends on the type of mix used, but for me, every time. I haven't used any peat based mixes in years now, only gritty mix. The gritty mix I use never breaks down, so it is completely recyclable, meaning I don't need to be too worried about removal of the old stuff when I repot. However, if using a mix that breaks down, like commercial potting mix, you'll want to remove all of the old stuff. As the soil breaks down, it changes properties, particularly its water retention, including its ability to drain. If you don't remove it, and simply add soil, you are creating seperate soil properties within the same container, which will give you grief with watering. With peat mix, you'll find that the water will just drain through the new, looser soil, leaving the old clump around the roots dry. If you soak the whole thing, the old stuff will soak up water, but not drain well, and lead to root rot. These problems go away with a gritty type mix, which is why I use them exclusively now for anything other than annuals.


    Joe

  • 11 years ago

    My question wasn't too clear so I'll rephrase it.

    Should the old potting mix be entirely replaced every 6 months, every year, every 5 years....?

  • 11 years ago

    The answer isn't that cut and dried, because it depends on what you're using for potting mix. As noted above, with a decomposable mix, every time you repot. When you repot depends on the plant, the pot size, growing condition, etc.. Giving a specific time frame isn't good advice, as I and others do not know the conditions of your plants. What are you using for a potting mix?


    Joe

  • 11 years ago

    The only thing I use bagged, peat based soils for is annuals in my wife's planters, which gets disposed of each season. In Wisconsin, our growing season is short enough to not have too many of the problems associated with peat moss mixes breaking down and turning into a very fine, silty like substance. However, I grow plenty of trees in pots, jades, tropicals, etc.. For those, as noted above, I use only a variation of the gritty mix, because the peat moss mixes break down rather quickly, causing drainage problems. For the most success, I recommend searching these forums and reading up on the "gritty mix". It would be wrong of me to advise much on the use of bagged peat moss mix, because I don't use them, and when I did, there were many problems and frustrations associated with them when used with anything that requires repotting. Those problems and frustrations are all but gone since switching to gritty mix, so I'd highly recommend looking into it.


    Joe

  • 11 years ago

    Unfortunately, Miracle Gro potting mixes have a terrible reputation for being excessively moisture retentive and too fine a particle size so therefore offering pretty poor drainage. I wouldn't expect the mix to hold up longer than about 6 months or so at the outside. So I'd repot frequently if that was the potting mix being used.

    OTOH, if you were to use a more textural and durable potting mix, like Al's 5-1-1 or gritty mix, you may only need to replace the mix when you repot the plant to root prune or upsize.


  • 11 years ago

    If I were to use it, which is unlikely, Iwould only plant annuals in the pictured potting soil and then dispose of it every season.

  • 11 years ago

    Can I buy bags of Al's 5-1-1 or gritty mix at Lowes or Home Depot? (I don't mean the individual components).

    Is Promix HP the same as or similar to Al's 5-1-1 or gritty mix?

  • 11 years ago

    I think some persons with more experience or container water interests have moved on to 5-1-1 or other potting mixes. For others, store-bought or even MG potting mix will suffice. Whether it's the best or not for a container, perhaps the person isn't at that level of gardening just yet.

    To give another answer to OP's question, but yet include what some of these other responses have mentioned, you can use the store-bought mixes for probably 1 growing season. That could be 6 or 9 months, or even 12 months, if you repot in the early spring of next year.

    After that, you may want to replace it.

    As for repotting, I think you don't exactly need to wash roots, if I'm envisioning your statement correctly, but that will depend on how robust those roots are also. It's usually OK if you get the root ball, shake a bit of the excess dirt off, and transplant it. Sometimes you can even do the root ball without disturbing the roots too much. However, a general rule of thumb is that you do want to encourage new root growth, and that may include trimming some roots off or otherwise doing something to the root ball so that it will grow outwards in its new media or new container home.


  • 11 years ago

    I haven't converted to the gritty mix (yet) for houseplants and I watch the plant's growth and health to get a sense of when it's time to replace the mix. When I don't see growth during the growing season it's time to change. I use store-bought mixes amended with perlite for a 3:1 soil:perlite ratio. For small and medium houseplants this usually lasts 2-3 years. I agree with the above poster that unamended soil will probably only last a year, but in that case I'd probably only do a complete replacement every two years and just replace the outer inch or two in between. The reason is that complete soil replacement puts a lot of stress on the plant and it can take a long time to recover.