Software
Houzz Logo Print
acmully

Interior Designer Fail?

11 years ago
I recently hired an interior designer to help with a living room space in our new home. We really don't need the extra room as we also have a den off our kitchen plus another family room with tv in our finished basement, but we needed to fill the space. So, I went with the interior decorator's suggestion for a large ottoman, settee and two chairs. All of the pieces have just been delivered and I am now thinking this was a bad idea! What do you guys think? Does anyone really feel that these pieces go together or could be pulled together with additional accessories? Aside from the fabric selections, I also feel that the scale of the chairs and ottoman are too large for the settee? The third photo is of the other half of the room - our dining room. Thanks!

Comments (27)

  • 11 years ago
    I think accessories are needed. An area rug, something on the window, something for the wall..... I try to envision as a finished room
  • 11 years ago
    Hi there. I'm certainly no interior designer, just a decorating enthusiast who wants to help.

    The settee IS too small and out of scale alongside the chairs and ottoman. Is it still possible to return the settee or maybe exchange it for a larger/longer piece? In my opinion you should replace it with a regular size sofa, usually 6'-8' long depending on the length of the wall.

    What color scheme do you have in mind? Are you going traditional or modern? Pull in some accents like pillows and lamps. An area rug would anchor the space, now the furniture kind of looks like it's "floating". Add some artwork. Floor length stationary drapes would also look nice and add softness to the room.
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi, beautiful home! But I do agree, the settee seems a little small scale wise next to the other pieces, especially in the first pic you posted above. I do like how it fits well between the 2 windows so I think with the right finishing touches, it can work.

    However if it's not too late to exchange or return, perhaps do so then get 2 more of the chairs you have to create a seating group similar to the 2nd picture below. The one thing I would be concerned about with this option though is matching dye lots....even if you order the same fabric for the new chairs.....that's if the fabric was custom ordered for the current ones.

    Versatile Library/Living Room · More Info

    Living Room Dining Room with modern / traditional styling · More Info

  • 11 years ago
    The pieces are just right. You need accessories and better lighting.
  • 11 years ago
    Hello, I like to ask if I can use a small sofa and table and a mirror on the wall.
  • 11 years ago
    How disappointing. The ottoman is like a big pouff! It's nice to be able to place a tray on an ottoman in that configuration because it acts as a coffee table too! I'd replace it with something that isn't mounded. As suggested get a larger sofa. Then perhaps a rug to ground space. Then you can start thinking about accessories.
  • 11 years ago

    HI -- The settee is too small and doesn't look comfortable . You need a 3 seat sofa instead . I love the chairs . Once you add the other things in the room that settee is just going to look even smaller . Find a sofa that has nicer arms , one with a wider arm but soft contours. A sofa that you sit into . The settee looks like you just sit on it . I like the ottoman and it could have been a tufted style also . With the 3 seat sofa , an oval ottoman would be better .

  • 11 years ago
    I think two armless chairs will make the settee feel larger and balanced in scale. A large single drape on the outside of each window will help, plus add an area rug. Two floor lamps and a decorative chest on the large wall with art or a mirror and a lamp will complete it. Good luck
  • 11 years ago

    Maybe 2 tall plants at window sides.

  • 11 years ago

    I think once everything is put together, it will be fine. Have you tried putting the settee in the corner? Or on the blank wall?

  • 11 years ago
    The settee looks small, BUT.....
    After you get a rug to anchor the space, tables w/ lamps on either end of the settee, a tray of some sort on top of the ottoman, window treatments, and a console table or credenza on blank wall with large art above it....THEN decide if settee is still too small. Right now the room is barely half finished so that's why it doesn't look right to you.
  • 11 years ago

    The settee only looks small because there are no end tables or drapes or anything. Furniture always looks off when it's just sitting in an empty room.

  • 11 years ago
    what the.....? the settee should go to the right. ground the area w an area rug. Bench in front of window. art work over settee. inspiration below
  • 11 years ago
    Love your chairs.
  • 11 years ago

    Louella Martina, you need to put your dilemma on your own design dilemma thread -- it doesn't work to pick up on someone else's problem when you are dealing with the original poster's issue. Good luck.

    Acmully, this is just to illustrate some of the comments above that completing the room -- the context of the furniture -- will go a long way to addressing any proportion problems you have. In particular, I've put side tables on each side of the sofa because they give the impression of extending it and making it look larger, so that it balances better with those beautiful chairs.

    As gorgeous as the ottoman is, I do agree that the rounded top makes it a bit impractical as a double for a coffee table.

    The painting on the right is a from a work on https://www.pinterest.com/danishteak/.


  • 11 years ago
    I am so glad you posted this. I have a similar 'unused, formal living room' space that I need to decorate. A few people have suggested the same furniture configuration that you have. Now I can see and modify it for my area.

    I agree with some of the above posts about putting end tables next to the settee. I think it will elongate and balance out the space. Or, you could place a floor lamp on one side and a good sized plant on the other in a beautiful pot to compliment your decorating scheme.

    I would also consider moving the chairs so that the back is not facing you from the other room. It doesn't look inviting. Perhaps flanking them on either side of the settee?
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree with other commenters that perhaps the settee is too small - on the picture it looks like a 1.5 seater rather than a 2 seater. But I also believe that with a rug, side tables, and accessories it will look good and won't crowd out the room (which is the mistake many people make).

    Think of it as the clothes that need the accessories to finish it off.

  • 11 years ago
    I don't think the settee looks right at all where it is. I would spin that whole room 90 degrees and lose the pouf.
  • 11 years ago
    Even better...return the settee and pouf, spin the chairs to be near the windows, install a shallow bookshelf against the blank wall, painting the trim color.
    A pretty table between the chairs, a good lamp, and a couple of plants, and you have a pleasant entry spot there near the stairs, which can double as a reading nook and a less intimate area to receive people.
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    The windows are large and beautiful, and they grab your attention more than the settee. I think a piece of art between them would balance that out, and would raise your eye. Don't make the mistake many make and raise the artwork too high over the settee, though. Too close to the settee is better than floating a foot over it. If it is too high, it would create a visual separation between the settee and the artwork, and magnify the tiny settee problem.

    Also, call the designer! Texting her a few photos and asking her opinion is a good decision. You don't have to follow her advice, or hire her for more work. Her comment could be something like, "once the such and such we ordered arrives," or "when we paint like we discussed," it will all come together. Don't worry. Design is all about the details. You don't have those, yet.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    The process of putting a room together can be challenging for clients when they aren't seeing the full reveal. First of all, don't return the furniture. It was probably custom ordered and if so, likely that the vendor will not take it back anyway. Your room isn't finished and desperately needs the side tables, lighting, area rug, window treatments and artwork to allow the seating to make sense in an otherwise empty room.

    Since your living room will be used primarily when you are entertaining and using your dining room, here are a few ideas that I would suggest:

    - shift the seating around to open up the passage from the foyer to the dining room. If the settee was angled and floating in the corner by the windows then the chairs would be placed on either side of the ottoman, meaning that someone sitting there would now have a view into your dining room, instead of having their back to it.

    - the now angled settee is small enough to allow for a console table to be placed behind it, which would provide a wonderful ledge for great family photos and a table lamp. The lighting would create coziness for the seating and visually brighten and widen the room.

    - the ottoman is designed to have a large tray sitting on it, with perhaps some small books, a vase with fresh flowers or a group of interesting collectibles for every day. When entertaining, the tray will provide a space to sit drinks or appetizers on, although if you have a dog having food that low might not be a good idea :-).

    Your interior designer hasn't failed, you just haven't given them the chance to finish the room. And if you're having trouble seeing the finished room perhaps they can create a rendering to help you visualize and feel more comfortable with the process.


  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Very nice, Mark. That rendering looks great.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I think Mark did a good job with the rendering but regardless those pieces will still look like they are floating in the room. The sofa is too small so I wonder if you can't return it could you perhaps use it in your bedroom at the end of your bed instead of a bench ? If you got two morw of the chairs you could set them around the ottoman to form a little circle, then if you add the things Mark suggested I think it will work. I feel very bad that you had a bad experience with the decorator, they certainly didn't think through their design plan for you.I have enclosed a photo of a similar layout to give you an idea what it might look like.


  • 11 years ago
    That settee partially blocks the window in a really awkward way. I agree the room is better off without it.
    I still think with the location by the door and the stairs, you don't want to fill it up too much.
  • 11 years ago
    Thank you all so much for the much needed input!!! The response is even more than I anticipated! I'll provide an update on the finished room. Thanks again!
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I think some art and a nice rug would really help complete the space!


Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz