Software
Houzz Logo Print
d_kope60

Spruce in clay going "yellow"

11 years ago

Last year we planted spruce in our clayish-loam soil. They have good drainage as they are on the side of a hill, but I believe they are having trouble adjusting because originally they were grown in a more sandy-loam environment (in addition we had an uncommon amount of rain last year). They are doing ok and putting on new growth this year, but they are looking 'anemic' (light green to yellowish). My question is; should I try to amend with an organic acidifier (such as cottonseed meal) or just let them be to adjust? (I could also try a foliar such as Miracid, but don't really think that is a good idea.) Thanks,

Comments (4)

  • 11 years ago

    how did you rule out a bad winter ... meaning.. where are you .. can you offer a pic ... etc ..

    i NEVER fert conifers ... ever ...

    have you had a soil test done.. to show what the status of such is ...?? .. when i do fert.. i dont guess at the issue ...

    how do you know where they were previously grown ... and if you dug them up ... how did you get them home.. and how much stress was involved in the digging.. transporting.. and transplanting??

    all you give is a description of off color.. and if you want a good discussion.. we need a lot more facts.. and that pic... if possible...

    with all the stresses of a recent transplant.. that means within the first three years... the last problem that comes to mind.. in a loam soil.. is a nutrient deficiency ....

    what kind of spruce might also matter????

    ken


  • 11 years ago

    I have given the particulars that are germain. Had they been damaged in the transplant process, I would have said so. Had there been questions as to the composition of the soil, ditto. And no, the "kind" or variety of spruce does not apply here or again (,,,). You may keep your discussions to yourself. Thanks for demonstrating that this forum is just another venue for snarky, aggressive spout offs.

  • 11 years ago

    Hey D, Ken does a lot of good work here trying to help folks. He's got his own manner of communicating-we all do-but I seriously doubt he's spending his time here just to aggravate folks.

    That said, do you happen to know your soil's pH in that area? Adjusting soil pH is an often-frustrating process, with especially clay-based soils having so much buffering capacity that the reading often likes to simply return back to what it was a short time after the "adjustment" has been made. Then too, these adjustments are not in and of themselves difficult. Your cottonseed meal, or my soil sulfur, can simply be broadcast over the top, so even if that pH sneaks back when you're not looking, it's a relatively simple matter to reapply. So again, do we know where that pH is at?

    Finally, spruce are mostly not living on a knife's-edge of pH requirements. Heck, I too live in a clay zone and pathogen issues aside, spruce seem to do just fine here, across a range of species. We're circumneutral in our soil pH readings around here. So an extremely acidic situation is not usually warranted.


    +oM

  • 11 years ago

    I didn't see one bit of snark in his reply,,those were all valid questions

    when were they planted,,spring,summer,fall,,?,,,,did winter sun do a number on them ?

    ball,burlap,,potted ?,,,,how tall ?,,,,,what kind of spruce? ,,,constricted roots ?

    did you rely on rain ? did you water these stupid trees ?

    regards , snark


Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County