Software
Houzz Logo Print
kittyfam

Broccoli brown bead; how to prevent this? zone 5

11 years ago

Two years in a row I've had broccoli brown bead, or at least that's what it looks like to me after reading about disorders. The years before that I've had no trouble.

I have put on some dolomite lime in the fall, and 10-10-10 granular in the spring most of the time. Otherwise I've thrown out some coffee grounds as well.

For watering, we have sprinklers set on them in the late morning so foliage have time to dry out again. We stay on top of watering, give extra if plants go limp on hot days. The last two summers the temperatures have been decent, not as hot as some years, and I've had hotter weather with better broccoli harvest.

I use captain jacks spinosad for worms.

Would you say it's a nitrogen problem, maybe add some extra right by the broccoli? It just doesn't seem like it's stress due to weather and watering. Or could it be viral / bacterial? How can I know?

Is there anything you would suggest to do to try to avoid it for this season?

Comments (6)

  • 11 years ago

    I have found brown bead to be largely a function of variety. That probably also equates to water as brown bead is much more rare on high dome heading varieties versus those which are more flat. I depend on rainfall, but have more brown bead in rainy seasons with varieties like Packman.

    Else thanked farmerdill
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you very much! I just delivered a soil sample for nutrient testing, but that's good to know about nitrogen as I was reading that lack of nitrogen could be the problem.

    We have already decided not to use the sprinklers for the tomato plants since it encourages early blight, but it's been so convenient! We're going to put in a drip system for them, so I suppose we'll just do that for other plants as well if we need to. I'll take your advice and not use sprinklers for the broccoli.

    As far as variety, I've been purchasing whatever is available at our plant centers, whatever that might be. I'm not sure. I'll try to look into that and find out if a flat variety is available. Thanks so much!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Interesting! I encountered brown bead for the first time this year. I had it on 2 of the 8 Early Dividend broccoli that headed up in the last week. I have grown ED in the spring and fall for the last 5 seasons with no problems. ED is a comparatively flatter headed variety rather than domed.

    I water with soaker hoses as needed...usually 1-2 times per week for 1.5 hours if no rain. Fertilized with about 1 Tbsp. urea per plant 3 times during their 7 week growth and treat weekly with liquid BTK. Temperatures while heading were in the upper 80s and low 90s which I have read can be a contributing factor and we did have a couple heavy rains when the heads were just starting to form. I don't recall ever having these high temps before while heads were forming in the fall. The brown bead started in the middle of the heads and then spread outward. By the time I cut them at least half of the head was infected and they had to be tossed in the compost.

    I have 6 Bay Meadows in the same bed that are heading up now with 3-5" heads and no sign of brown bead on any of those so far.

    My questions...Does the brown bead affect side shoots production as well as the main head? Can it spread to adjacent plants? Would it be a good idea to pull the plants that had it? Am I worrying too much?

  • 10 years ago

    Brown bead is a physiological disorder. No it cannot spread as one normally uses the term.The condition is actually early abortion of the flower buds. Lots of speculation as to causes but nothing definitive. I have less problem with full domed varieties than with flat varieties. https://nevegetable.org/crops/physiological-disorders https://growingsmallfarms.ces.ncsu.edu/growingsmallfarms-broccoliproblem06/

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for the links farmerdill! Funny thing is I read both of them just this morning.

    A couple things I found interesting from the NC state blog was

    Research has shown that fast-developing broccoli plants tend to be less susceptible to brown bead. A study showed that broccoli under higher nitrogen application rates had less incidence of the disorder than plants under lower N rates.

    I believe Early Dividend at 45 DTM is about the fastest developing broccoli available. Mine was right on schedule...set out on August 6 and harvested September 21-24. This research also seems to contradict some of what Dave posted in response to the OP.

    Since this was my first encounter with BB, I guess I will chalk it up to the unusually hot weather and just keep doing what I have been doing. I do enjoy growing broccoli and trialing new varieties. I think I have tried 11 types now IIRC. I am also trying Arcadia for the first time this fall.

    A few heads from my spring crop. I believe these were Bay Meadows.

    Garden pictures · More Info