Software
Houzz Logo Print
david90531

Buddha's temple crumbling down...

11 years ago

I'm sad to report that my C. "Buddha's Temple" is not doing well... Since few weeks ago I've noticed these brown spots on the plant, didn't think much of it, and it started to spread, and now lots of the leaves are shriveling and doesn't look like it's gonna make it...:(




It is in fairly "gritty" mix, so I've been watering it every 5-7 days because the soil dries out very quickly. Does it look like it's rot problems? Pests? Any help would be appreciated... this was one of my favourites and really hope there's a way to preserve it.

This is how it looked back in winter:




Comments (39)

  • 11 years ago

    It looks like sunburn to me, but I could be wrong. Don't you have your plants on a spinner? Or am I thinking of someone else?

  • 11 years ago

    This happened to my C. capitella thyrsiflora. I plucked out all the dead leaves, cut the top off so I had about an inch of bare stem and stuck it in a pot of pumice. It only took a month (summer) to root (or I didn't notice it until a month later and by that time, it had rooted.)


    The good news is that the main method of propagation for this crassula is by rooted stem cuttings so I bet it will work!

    Pagan

  • 11 years ago

    I've been wanting one of these but can't help you with the care or what's wrong with it. Could it be too dry if the leaves are shriveling?

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks everyone for chipping in.

    @ctnesbit81 @fakechuchi(7) @camellia1_gw I think that's what I'm going to do, cut off the top part and hopefully start it new, although the top part is starting to look bad with the brown spots too... It's a confusing situation because I definitely don't water it any more than my other crassula, maybe a bit heavier watering since again it's in much grittier mix than the others, and few lower leaves shriveled prior to this major problem so I thought it wasn't getting enough water. Rootcup looks very interesting, thanks for the share!

    @_sbgibbons_ I thought about that too but I really can't come to that conclusion because my windowsill is north-west facing, so especially during winter it gets no direct sun at all, although it's mostly quite bright. I placed it under grow lights for extensive amount everyday though for quite awhile since I wanted it to grow more compact, could it be burned by grow lights??

  • 11 years ago

    I thought I read somewhere that Buddha's Temple could be challenging to grow but I can't remember where I saw it. Someone else on the forum had a bought one a few weeks, ago; maybe he can chime in.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, I think it's not the one of the easiest cultivars, I may or may not try again just because I love it so much, but if it still doesn't do well then I might have to move on to something else :(

  • 11 years ago

    Sorry to hear this plant isn't doing too well. How long have you had this plant, David? It is possible that the plant might have been damaged prior to you receiving it and it took a bit of time to respond? Just a thought.

    I hope you are able to salvage the top. I too would want to know what the roots look like. I would tip it out and inspect prior to any scissor action.

    Tracy

  • 11 years ago

    @tracy I've had it since last October, it was one of the last plants I acquired. It was shipped from Europe so it stayed in the dark for quite some time, which is usually no problem for most succulents I've got. Not sure if it was having trouble prior but it did start to show sign of unhealthiness around a month in, and again I kept it quite dry over winter and it's in very porous soil, the water almost immediately comes out from the drainage hole as I pour it in.

    I will inspect the roots tomorrow and Monday and post some pictures here before I proceed to the next step.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Reactions to root loss will be the same whether it's over watered or under. I think the pot may have been too big for the root mass. The mix perhaps remained wet longer around the smaller mass of the roots as the mix retains moisture longer in the unused space if pot is too large.
    Hopefully you'll be able to recover it from the cutting.

  • 11 years ago

    Hello david,

    Crassula's dont like burning sun - only light.

    Maybe that's why

    greets Harry

  • 11 years ago

    I'm so sorry to read about this David. It sounds like you've received some solid advise. I hope you can save it!!!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    @aztcqn(10) Thanks! I think that might be it. This is the smallest pot I could find though 3" plastic pot, perhaps I need terracotta pot that's 2-3".

    @Harry Thanks. As I was saying earlier, my window has 0 to very little direct sun, that's why I have to use grow lights. During spring/summer I get maximum 1-2 hours of sunset that's about it, otherwise I only have bright indirect light for my plants.


    @deva thank you :)

    I've taken it out just now and snapped a photo of the roots. The bottom part of the soil was still a bit moist when I took it out. I truly have no clue how to inspect root health, so any ideas would be appreciated. Should I go ahead and cut the top part off and wait for it to hopefully root and plant it?

  • 11 years ago

    David, it looks like your mix is mostly turface? It could have been holding water longer than you expected (just guessing here...)
    Rina


    DavidL.ca thanked rina_Ontario,Canada 5a
  • 11 years ago

    If it were mine I would definitely cut the top off. At least that way you have 2 plants that might make it, doubling your chances. And being that it was still wet do you think you might have rot?

    I remember you posting when you acquired this beauty. Hope you get it back to health.

    DavidL.ca thanked deva33 Z8 Atlanta
  • 11 years ago

    @rina yes, it is equal amount of turface and chicken grit with some soil and perlite. I think I underestimated Turface's ability to hold water. Although most of my other plants seems to be doing okay with the same amount of watering..

    @deva I agree, I think I will do the surgery tomorrow, fingers crossed :S

  • 11 years ago

    I think if the main stem at the base is still solid, (hard no soft sponginess) it may only be lost roots and that section may put out new ones.


  • 11 years ago

    @aztcqn so what would you do in this case? Still cut off the top and hopefully have two plants both going, or just leave it be?

  • 11 years ago

    David
    while I think your mix is pretty good (and other plants are doing well), another possibility may be that this is one of the plants much more sensitive to wetness; and during winter when it's colder and darker, it takes longer for everything to dry. Again, I am just speculating here...
    The roots should look fleshy-plump and usually whitish color. I am sure you know how unhealthy ones look - soft, mushy, dark/blackish color or totally dry.
    I would cut the top off and hope it roots, and plant the original with the roots too - you may end up with 2 plants. You have nothing to loose...Rina


  • 11 years ago

    I think that was way too much water for an indoor crassula in winter. I've let outdoor crassula go without any water whatsoever for six months or more during the winter. This was outdoors in the SF Bay Area. With the minimal amount of light yours is getting indoors it's not going to be growing anyway so water needs are close to zero.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks guys, I will definitely be adjusting my watering according to the experience. During the winter I was watering every 14-20 days, with the exceptions of my Haworthias, but with that schedule this plant seemed to be drying out with leaves shriveling and that's why I decided to gave it a bit more water once the weather was a bit warmer..

  • 11 years ago

    Usually the plant will let you know when to increase watering. A bit in winter to prevent shriveling. Considering the size of the pot to the plant root mass your schedule may not have worked well in this case.
    You could try what Rina suggests and try for 2 plants. As Spring and warm weather is starting it's time for new growth on most succulents so could very likely work. I would check how that base is (mushy or hard) and decide from there.


  • 11 years ago

    Thanks. so the smaller the root mass is, the less water it should be given, considering the size of the pot is quite bigger than it is, even though it's only a 3" pot?


    I've done the chopping yesterday and here's what they look like. I don't know if these could grow from leaf cuttings so I saved some healthier-looking leaves. Right now they're just laying flat on one of my windowsills shaded by the other pots, do they need more light? Should I stick all of them in perlite or wait for roots to come out?


  • 11 years ago

    Hate to say it David but this is what happened to the one I tried several years ago. It just shrivelled away to nothing. Haven't tried it since...

    DavidL.ca thanked breton2
  • 11 years ago

    @breton I see, yes I suspected that it would be a hard one to cultivate indoor, but it was always on my bucket list so I wanted to see how it goes. I'll see where this go and update here.

  • 11 years ago

    I can only tell you from my experience outdoors. I have a slatted tray in which I threw all the succulent odds and ends last summer. Left them there for months. All the echeverias and crassulas produced roots from the pieces (tops, stems laying on their sides and leaves). The tray was slightly elevated from the ground, so they had moisture from my watering other potted plants. but never sat in it. They were also covered in leaf litter from the tree above which I suppose helped retain moisture without being wet and drew out roots from the bits.

    What I deduce is the bits needs moisture, not wet and air movement to prevent bacteria from attaching and spreading on the plant. I've never tried to reproduce this in a window environment. I'm thinking air movement is the big difference from both environments.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Root size is important. Watering is a balance of giving it the moisture it needs without letting the mix retain it longer than plant uses up despite pot size. I wish I could be more precise. I lost a dwarf mammillaria to just this. The mix had a high amount of sand the pot was too deep and it was retaining moisture so long the rots rotted and my plant began to decline. They need air spaces around the roots and the mix was too dense.
    Perhaps New Zealand sphagnum moss (I've never tried for succulents) because of it's fluffyness and openess to air while retaining moisture as a rooting medium? Maybe, someone has already tried this???

    DavidL.ca thanked aztcqn
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you for the detailed responses again. I have propagated sedum, echeveria, and also crassula successfully at the same windowsill, so I'm hoping I will have some luck with this guy as well.

  • 11 years ago

    David

    I had same problem with C. rupestris (gone) and C. moonglow is not far behind while I read that it is easy to grow. For some reason these 'stacked' crassulas are not growing for me.

    This is what I found on Dave's Garden:

    Crassula Buddha's Temple is a hybrid of Crassula perforata var minor and Crassula pyramidalis......it quickly gets leggy, falls over and then tends to rot if not cut back and replanted. It has really wimpy roots and seems to like being watered regularly or it dies.

    about stacked crassulas

    You probably already read all about.

    Rina

  • 11 years ago

    David, sorry to hear about your plant. I hope your new cuttings can take root.

    I've tried propagating some plants using ctnesbit81 suggested rootcup concept.

    I bought a bunch of small 1 inch opening tubes, wrap around the tubes with thick paper to cover light to encourage root growth, and filled the tubes with water, just enough that the callous part of the stem isn't touching it.

    I had one crassulas cutting growing roots in a few weeks. Maybe this might help.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I hardly ever water mine, and then only sparsely. I also have it growing outdoors in full sun, and it does not sunburn. It receives full sun all day:


    I think it would do better if you put it outdoors. It does grow rather slowly, however.

    Lars

  • 11 years ago

    Very pretty blooms Lars!

  • 11 years ago

    @Rina Thanks for the info, I haven't read some of that actually! Interesting that it says it likes to be watered regularly though. I'll see what happens! I might try again if this one doesn't root successfully.

    @bernardyjh thanks for the suggestion, I just found out that they ship to Canada and free shipping when $30 or up, so I might take a look at this for sure!

    @Lars Thank you for the advice, if only I could move my plants outside... I live in apartment that is 12th floor, and no balcony :(. May I ask you what kind of soil you grow them in?

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I am growing mine in a cactus/palm mix that is somewhat sandy and has very good drainage.

    I did not realize you were in Canada - at first I thought the "ca" after your name meant California, which is where I live. I have a problem with Oxalis when we get a lot of rain, but that hasn't happened lately. You can see dead Oxalis in my pot - it will die from lack of water, and that is one reason I water sparsely. Sometimes in the winter, I have to pull the Oxalis out.

    Lars

  • 11 years ago

    I see, mine was in more of gritty mix and as mentioned, they are indoor.

    Haha, yeah a lot of people got that confused... Sometimes I do crave for the California weather, definitely perfect for growing my favourite plants succulents and Tillandsias. I will see if I can find a good balance to raise this plant, all my other crassula are doing fairly well at the windowsill

  • 11 years ago

    http://www.cactusjungle.com/plant_pages/crassula_buddhas_temple.htm

    Care tips says this plant require low water.. :/

  • 11 years ago

    Haha yeah... I think it really depends where you grow them, I think for me less watering is probably safer

  • 10 years ago

    David, what ever happened with you plant? I just got some of these from Italy, and I think the bottom leaves are doing what you did, shriveling, already!

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Hi guys, just noticed my buddha was also falling down. At first I was worried about heat and overwatering but then I moved the plant a bit to the side and spotted a bug inside, it has being eating it from the inside. I then cut the top to send out the new "neighbour", hope the plant will get better by time.