Software
Houzz Logo Print
dandk40

Help with crooked willow oak

11 years ago

Tree is crooked and driving me nuts. Any suggestions to straighten or should I ask for a new one?


Comments (13)

  • 11 years ago

    Dandk, is that a recent transplant? Who planted it? My phone & houzz are being stupid, is that a mound of mulch I see?

    It looks like quite the large transplant.

  • 11 years ago

    It was put in last August. I had a landscaper plant it and yes that is a mound of mulch. Landscaper claims it is planted straight. 3inch caliper 10ft willow oak.

  • 11 years ago

    That was probably a bit of an investment. I believe I am seeing it is on a bit of a slope. Who made the mulch volcano? I say clear the mulch from around the tree and see what you have so far as determining if the root flare is at a reasonable grade (post a pic of it maybe) and maybe be able to tell if it is in burlap and wire still. Then replace the mulch to to correct level and use the rest elsewhere.

    What kind of warranty did it come with? Is settling and tilting covered? Was the tree staked? Much as I don't like stakes unless absolutely necessary, that was really a LARGE transplant. Evertime the wind blows the foliage up high catches it and the root ball is a pivot point so the landscaper may be telling the truth.

  • 11 years ago

    It will be fine in a couple growing seasons. The lean is very slight and given how massive they get you won't know the difference in 10 years

  • 11 years ago

    It isn't still in the burlap and wire. It was not staked and is on a slope. The landscaper did the mulch and actually does our maintenance throughout the year. He finally asked if I want it replaced yesterday, but I haven't responded yet. There was a bradford pear there prior to it breaking in a storm and I wanted a larger replacement as the landscape is mature.

  • 11 years ago

    Sorry for the 10 degree. The mulch volcano is wrong and tells me to question everything he does. Like if a car mechanic knowingly pours wiper fluid in my radiator. It probably won't kill my car bit it should not be done intentionally.

  • 11 years ago

    That mulch volcano will kill your tree! You should be able to see the "flare" where the tree trunk joins the roots. The flare shouldn't be below ground or covered with mulch.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the advice and info on mulch, I appreciate it. I will correct and let him know. What do we think about tree, leave it or go for a new straight one?

  • 11 years ago

    Another angle.

  • 11 years ago

    First of all I am not a professional. I planted a Willow Oak in my front yard in my front yard in 2001 ($19.97 Lowes). It has done fantastic. I would not remove it if it was mine. You might want to stake it for a year to straighten it up. I think it is pulling away from the larger trees in you neighbors yard. Just pull the mulch back and wait a bit. They will sit a while and grow roots, then take off. I will try to get a picture. Mine was about 6 or 8 foot tall in 2001 and must be at least 20 or 30 foot now.

  • 11 years ago

    I can't leave well enough alone sometimes. I'd pull back the mulch and see if something is goingnonnwith the rootball where it is moving in relation to the surrounding soil. With my smaller transplants I can drive in a couple metal stakes and use an old pair of nylons as needed to guide the tree.

    If the rootball was pivoting or shifting I'd probably mess with straightening it. If it isnjust growing away from the shade I might prune it. I'd probably leave the tree be though if it seems healthy and ask those here with more experience how to use a staking method to secure it if needed.

  • 11 years ago

    I agree with the poster above who commented that this lean is not really all that significant, given the forces at work to make the tree grow "straight", which are : Gravity and phototropism. Together, these natural forces-always there and always at work-will cause the new growth to completely hide this small degree of sweep, in time. And not that much time either!

    +oM

  • 6 years ago

    Pull the mulch away from the bark. That is only a slight lean. These trees get massive and you won’t notice this lean in a few years. Good luck. Willow oaks are great southern oaks!