Software
Houzz Logo Print
dnroach

What to do with regrowth after pruning trees

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

I'm not really sure what to do when my trees start to grow new leaves after pruning. Do I climb back up there and take them all off as they grow? How do I know the difference between desirable growth and water shoots?

Here is my sweetgum. It was pruned last year and still just looks thin and wiry. As you can see, it is sending out a lot of new leaves on the trunk and branches. I would like the tree to appear 'fuller', but don't think I need more main laterals, so I'm not sure what action (if any) to take.


Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks.

Comments (11)

  • 11 years ago

    what do you mean.. pruned.. do you mean topped????

    did you monkey up there... what exactly did you do ...??? .. any pix of that story???

    if you did it last fall.. what were you expecting at leaf out this spring???

    ken


  • 11 years ago
    No it's not topped, I just didn't get it all in the pic.

    I had moved into a house with trees that had not been maintained in 10+ years, so I cut off the dead, cut off some lower branches and climbed the trees and cleaned them up around the trunk and inner branches to help their form and thin them out a bit.

    I guess I was hoping to give it some breathing room to grow, although now I just want it to look "fuller".

    So basically I do not know if I should just let it grow, or maintain trimming off certain areas that are leafing out.

    Here are my red oaks I did too. It's thinned out too but it doesn't leaf out as much as the sweet gum. I guess I'm hoping the thin branches will become thicker now that they have some breathing room.
  • 11 years ago

    "I guess I was hoping to give it some breathing room to grow, although now I just want it to look "fuller".

    So basically I do not know if I should just let it grow, or maintain trimming off certain areas that are leafing out."

    This may be an obvious question I'm missing, but I'll ask since I don't get it. How is pruning away leafing out live sections of tree going to make it fuller? Help me understand this.

    Richard.

  • 11 years ago

    I think the OP meant the tree had a pretty open canopy and they wanted a fuller look. If it starts leafing out oddly low I might rub off the odd sprout kr two. Not sure I'd do heavy duty pruning twice in a year.

    dnroach thanked Toronado3800 Zone 6 St Louis
  • 11 years ago

    To me, it looks like it has been lion's tailed, the (improper) practice of removing all or most of the foliage until you get way out to the ends of branches. This causes less branch taper, therefor weaker branches, increases the likelihood of sunscald (as does all excessive crown thinning) and in the end is of no value, the tree simply putting energy into replacing all the foliage that had been removed, which brings us right back to your question: You've already-I think-overpruned the interior/upper crown of your tree. Why then repeat the damage? Leave the blasted thing alone! It knows where to grow and how much.

    +oM

    dnroach thanked wisconsitom
  • 11 years ago

    I was taught to remove much of the inner foliage, which now I understand probably isn't good practice, and would be considered over pruning.

    jean001a - I want my trees to grow larger, I didn't intend to restrict their size. I guess I thought if they had more room to grow, then they would grow more efficiently...but that probably isn't necessarily true. I definitely didn't want to slow down growth, although I may have done just that.

    drrich2 - I just wasn't sure if I should let everything grow, or maintain certain areas. Also, some trees will send out water shoots as new growth, which as far as I understand should be removed (I've seen mulberries do this terribly after a hard pruning), so I was curious how to handle those as well.

    toronado3800 - Yes you're right. I think I've just been too detailed with it, and should just let it grow and rub off anything obvious.

    wisconsitom - Yes, I think I just should've left what was on there and let it do it's thing. SO at this point, I'll just let it do it's thing.

  • 11 years ago

    Yup, and regarding water sprouts, yes, many of those will grow straight up through crown, possibly even rubbing up against an established branch. That's poor structure in the making. But.....there's always a but......some suckers will be more or less okay to leave remaining on the tree, if they grow outward, away from other branches, etc. Sometimes, I will even prune a sucker back to an outward-facing bud. So why all this fuss?
    Suckers are really just new branches forming. And removing branches too excessively causes the tree to just turn around and make new branches (suckers). So if there are any more well-behaved ones, I try to retain them. It's just all about trying to not send the tree into hyper drive in terms of causing new suckers.

    +oM

    dnroach thanked wisconsitom
  • 11 years ago

    Yes, and that all makes sense now, after the fact of course. I've seen mulberries around here do it terribly. They get a hard pruning, and then they send out a million suckers straight up off the branches to counteract.

  • 11 years ago

    after a trim job like that... i think you need to give it a few years .. THEN decide if more need be done ...

    you have to think in tree years .. rather than your expectation of some instant gratification ... eh???

    ken


    dnroach thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 11 years ago

    Dn, you've got the right mindset to gain a better understanding of this stuff. And if I'm right, you might enjoy looking up the terms leader training and subordination pruning. Ed Gilman of U of Florida has done as much as anyone to put together some great info on science-based tree care. There's information for more mature trees too, more suited to your situation. But just a great resource for tree and other plant info that you may enjoy checking out.

    +oM

    dnroach thanked wisconsitom