Software
Houzz Logo Print
weedyacres

Help me evaluate this bid

11 years ago

I know, the best way to evaluate a bid is to have multiple bids to compare, but it has taken me 8 months of flaky contractors to get this one, so I'm evaluating in a vacuum. So I'd appreciate your thoughts. We're in a small town in the midwest, so reasonable labor costs.

Project: 12x16 room addition shell + reroof entire 940 sf house + 192 sf addition
Price: all include labor & materials except we provide windows and door)
Shell $9320 (3' crawl space, 2x6 framing, sheathing, roof tie-in)
Roof $4700 (currently gable, addition will add cross gable, metal roof)
Siding $1989 (vinyl dutch lap + soffits & gutters)

Total $16,000

If I pull out the re-roof, and include a $1000 allocation for the addition roof, then the shell costs us $12,309, or $64/sf. 6 or 7 years ago in a city 100 miles away, we added on 500 sf that was more complex construction and bricked exterior for $80/sf, so this seems reasonable. Without siding/brick, the prices are $54/sf and $70/sf respectively.

Another reference point: a few years back a buddy got a shingle re-roof of his simple gable roof for $2500 after he did the tear-off. So $3700 (main house allocation) including tear-off and metal roof seems reasonable.

All opinions and advice welcome.


Comments (7)

  • 11 years ago

    I'd verify that he has dealt with metal roofs before. And double check the gauge and type of ribbing. It sounds on the cheap side for metal. The flat sheets aren't that expensive. But all of the trim pieces are. They cost as much as the flat material when we did ours. If it's the typical older home, count on reframing Or sistering some of the rafters to get a flat enough surface for metal to work. Saggy old rafters and Swales up and down are dealt with easier by asphalt. So plan on a contingency for extra work to deal with that.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    You've told us all the specifications and pricing, but haven't told us the most important part of all, the contractor's reputation. Without that, evaluation is impossible.

  • 11 years ago

    They've done metal roofs: we watched them build an addition on the bar across the street from work for a month or so, and it had a metal roof. I will ask about the gauge and profile. What is recommended? He said they planned to put nailers on the existing roof planks (we don't have sheathing), and put "bubble wrap" between them and the metal to prevent water/condensation transfer.

    Joe, there's no central repository of "reputation" around here that I've been able to access. All we have to go on is the job we saw them do across the street, which is similar in scope to ours. We observed good quality and work ethic.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Good quality and work ethic and reasonable price sounds good.

  • 11 years ago

    OK, just talked to the contractor again and asked him the gauge on the metal roof. He's going to check, couldn't remember if it was 24 or 29 or something in between.

    I also verified that it was standing seam, and he said no. So it would have exposed fasteners. This is a no-go, correct? Our factory has exposed fasteners and it's too leak prone. He said standing seam was definitely 24 gauge, but it was probably twice as much (don't know if he was referring to labor or materials). I asked him to come back with pricing on standing seam as well as architectural shingles. We'll decide from there. If it's a big price delta, we'll probably just stick with shingles since this isn't our forever house.


  • 11 years ago

    That's kinda what I was suspecting, given the price quote. 29/28 gauge exposed fastener. Exposed fasteners can work, but I wouldn't be comfortable with it as a "lifetime" choice like standing seam. The fasteners are only as good as the installer, and most non specialists have the tendency to over torque, and dimple it, leading to water pooling around the fasteners, which degrades them faster, leading to leaks. And they'll need replacing in 15-20 years, which gives the replacer another chance to over torque. The material for standing seam isn't 2x as much, but the labor is much more difficult, because the seam has to be field crimped rather than just overlapping the edges. That's another potential gotcha for someone who doesn't do that all day long.

    Really, if you want metal, find a specialty roofing contractor and pull that out of the contract entirely. You'll get a better job, better materials, and a better price.

  • 11 years ago

    I'm not dying for a metal roof, I'd just take it with its increased longevity if the price was close to that of shingles.