Software
Houzz Logo Print
julie77777

What is the best Luxury Vinyl Tile (LVT) product?

13 years ago
I need about 550 SF of this for my small great room area, which includes kitchen, dining, and entryway. I like the square tiles that look similar to stone ceramic tile and will be glued down and grouted...not talking about the wood-look planks or any locking system. Locally I've looked at Mannington Adura, Armstrong Alterna, Congoleum Duraceramic, and a Shaw product. I've seen some posts about Amtico and Karndean. We live in a rural area and some of the outdoors gets drug into my house daily by husband and sons. No pets, though. I want to something reasonably priced that will last and stay looking nice with little maintenance; we will install ourselves. Any thoughts on WHICH type of LVT is best quality??

Comments (21)

  • 13 years ago
    We have amtico in our kitchen. We put it in ourselves with very little DIY knowledge about 10 years ago. 3 children and lots of skateboard and scooter riding later, it still looks like it did when we put it in. And we have never done anything except mop.
  • 13 years ago
    Thanks a lot, Karen! I found out yesterday that Amitco has been purchased by Mannington. Not sure what that might mean for the future of the Amtico product line.....
  • 13 years ago
    Mannington Vinyl tile question - Has anyone used Mannington Adura luxury vinyl tile (16 inch squares that are glued down and grouted)? I'm looking at the Athena line. Photo attached. Wondering how it holds up long term for kitchen, entryway, dining room? How easy to keep clean? Thanks for any info.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Consider Armstrong "Natural Creations". I had to lean down and touch it, it looked so good. Wears well because it is also specified for commercial installations.
  • 13 years ago
    Thanks, Scott Design. I will check that out. I previously considered Armstrong Alterna but when I did some testing in my kitchen with sample tiles, the Mannington was the winner (I had to try really hard to damage it). I will check this one out!
  • 13 years ago
    Other comments?
  • 13 years ago
    Have heard about many homeowners experiencing a lot of the problem with grout pulling away from the tile within a year or two. Not just on a couple of tiles ..... in some cases, over half of the floor! It's not a big deal to re-grout a tile or two with this product .... but I don't need problems! Having second thoughts about using Mannington Adura luxury vinyl tile.... I have been planning on using the 16x16 "stone-look" type. Looks awesome. Any comments??
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you, Distinguished! I will take a look at the Karndean.
  • 12 years ago
    I just got a great deal on some Centiva vinyl plank flooring @ our local Habitat Restore, and want to install it in a kitchen, dining room and game room. I need advice on care and maintenance. I've read that it needs a sealer / finish put on it after installation. Is this necessary for the protection and wear of the floor? I have no experience with LVT vinyl flooring.
  • 12 years ago
    I am about to have the adura Mannington LVT installed. Hoping for the best. Have looked at all of them and it seemed to be the best. Just tryng to decide whether to put it over present old vinyl floor or have it taken up. Suggestions on removing ole vinyl.
  • 11 years ago

    joieblanc...did you end up removing the sheet vinyl? if so, why and was it easy? How are you liking the Mannington?


  • 11 years ago
    To: joieblanc

    Personally I would remove the vinyl flooring since it is somewhat flexible and could still deteriorate over time if there were a moisture issue below the surface. If it is glued down purchase a good floor scraper from your favourite tool supplier and have a go at it.

    I would like to lay LVT over existing ceramic tile and wanted to know if anyone can advise me regarding surface preparation? Do I need to scuff/sand or etch the surface prior to laying the new product?
  • 11 years ago

    How old is the final flooring you're considering removing? We are going over ours as it's probably midcentury and likely held down with asbestos.

  • 10 years ago

    We came into a house with cheap white ceramic tile flooring. Took tons of hard labor-including a floor "jackhammer" to remove it! Replaced with Armstrong cushioned sheet vinyl; softer, easier on bodies especially. At 75 I can't imagine what a fall onto hard tile could break!

  • 10 years ago

    Any feedback on the Mannington Adura Tile? I am trying to decide if it is good choice for a bathroom floor. Also considering Alterna Regency Essence.

  • 10 years ago
    Joieblanc - how is your Mannington Vinyl holding up?
    I am so torn! Due to water damage, I am replacing a four month old laminate with vinyl plank. I am looking for a brand that looks authentic, durable to withstand a four year old (scooter, bike, etc.) and without all the toxins. Any suggestions? I really like the white oak look.
  • 9 years ago

    I purchased LVT and Adura Grout is separating from tile (everywhere). Had local company where purchased and installed come out and he checked moisture in house and it passed and after weeks said it was probably the house settling! Put in claim to Mannington and they say their grout was not covered under warranty and there couldn't be anything wrong with grout because it cimes in a batch and they haven't had anyone else with problems! I see on web all kind of comments about this problem. They say Im at fault because probably left too much water on floor when cleaning. They are worthless! Do not buy this product!

  • 9 years ago

    I purchased Armstrong Alterna in a Snow White, had it installed in a walk-in closet with NO grout (as they say you can butt it up against each other), but was not happy with seeing all the lines. Flooring store said it was because it was such a light color the lines are going to show, yet there were many areas of just plain gaps (tho' apparently they are acceptable - to the mfg. not me!) Now I'm ready to install this same LVT in a bathroom and decided I should have it grouted to eliminate the lines. Problem is Armstrong doesn't make a white grout to match the white tile. They said I could use an acrylic grout, but I'm getting a different answer from every flooring place/person I talk to. And there's Epoxy grout that is also non-porous like the acrylic, but some say it's hard to work with. Mapei makes one in Avalanche which is the closest to white I've seen; it's called Kerapoxy CQ.

    Anyone have any experience with these various grouts on LVT? Need to know quick as I'd already torn apart the bathroom when they told me the Armstrong grout wasn't white. Thanks in advance

  • 8 years ago

    I have recently used neobo LVT after years of having amtico. It is exactly the same in terms of quality and when fitted by my fitter I couldn't tell the difference.

  • 8 years ago

    I understand Cortech is the best for water resistance and other things. Any thoughts?

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz