Software
Houzz Logo Print
amy_mcintosh58

Should I remove these trees?

11 years ago
I have four trees in my backyard, three are pine. Since we have a pool these seems like a lot of unnecessary additional work to skim the pool. The things I like about them are they provide shade and green. Thoughts on how to get both without these beasts in the yard?

Comments (12)

  • 11 years ago
    Last night was our first night in the house so I know the backyard needs work as does the pool!
  • 11 years ago

    don't be hasty. a tree is giving you privacy from the upper floors of your neighbors, and might be giving your house privacy as well. consider each tree separately, is it giving you shade at a particular time of day but not privacy? shade can be achieved by a pergola which doesnt drop leaves and bug crud into the water and pool deck.

    have fun, and happy skimming.

  • 11 years ago

    Trees can provide privacy, shade, sound-deadening if you have loud neighbors or live near a busy road. The thing your trees have going for them is that they are "evergreens" so you don't have one time of year where they drop all their leaves when you have to rake/skim and deal with the things you'd have to if they were deciduous trees. However, this also means you will have a fairly constant dropping of needles to be kept cleaned up. Pines being a soft-wood tree generally have a short life compared to hardwood trees (30-40 years as opposed to 100s of years). Just looking at the photographs, yours appear to be fairly senior trees which may be nearing the ends of their lives - I'd have an arborist come out and check their health. You can discuss questions such as "can the branches be thinned so that we have less needles to clean up" and "If I take this tree out can you recommend something that won't be messy or drop junk in the pool?" Since this is a new house it makes sense to spend a little on having the trees health inspected. The last thing you want is to have one of them unexpectedly fall on the house or car or someone in your yard.


  • 11 years ago
    Keep the trees!! Wonderful privacy for your pool!
  • 11 years ago

    Not a chance that I would remove all those trees. Get them professionally pruned or thinned to keep the shapes looking good but otherwise I can't imagine why removing them would be a plus.

  • 11 years ago
    We have huge trees and it keeps our pool and house so cold and dark. But... I will never cut them down!! I think they are beautiful. We installed solar panels on our roof to heat the pool and have annual tree trimmings.
  • 11 years ago

    we took out a tree the grew up too much and instead of shading the pool deck it shaded the pool. very bad, the water is only warm enough about 5 weeks of the summer as it is. the rest, i hate them. helicopter seeds, leaves, caterpillars, etc etc. there are enough trees in the world (and in the yard) the ones that mess up the pool arent welcome to me.

  • 11 years ago
    plant a tall deciduous hedge for privacy. be careful in your selection and planting so that the roots of the hedge do not create a problem.

    do you really need shade over the pool?

    I love trees until they become a problem.

    I'm surprised that the trees' roots have not caused any problems with your pool.
  • 11 years ago
    Where do you live that you can even think of removing four trees? Wouldn't that involve permits and a good reason to cut down perfectly lovely trees?
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Please consider that Kelley was discussing her maple trees, not pines. The maples have helicopter seeds and surface roots. Keep the pines, don't trim them, as that encourages new growth.

    Fun in the sun, splash!

    cascio.offsite@gmail.com


  • 11 years ago
    No "Amy" was discussing pine trees I believe.
  • 11 years ago
    I was describing the two tree trees that are near the back fence and the pool. I could not determine what kind of trees that they are from the picture.

    if they are a protected type of tree, then their removal will be a very expensive if not impossible undertaking.