Software
Houzz Logo Print
debqhix

Washing Machine Hell. Does it really matter what I choose?!

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

Our 10 yo Kenmore Elite washing machine needs repair and I've have been offered the chance to replace it at a discount by the home warranty company, rather than repair it. Looking at replacement is mind boggling!

IF I were going to replace it, I have some things to consider. I've read every thread on Houzz concerning preferences and it's so mixed I feel no better informed. My first issue is my second floor laundry room. It has a tile floor with a drain in the middle. The drain is right in front of the washing machine which means the floor slopes and the washer does not sit on level floor. When the machine is running it is so loud downstairs! I don't know that the noise is solely the machine and not the way the house is plumbed, but I would like to get a quieter machine if I'm going to replace this one. I also don't want to buy one that will make worse noise because of the slope in the floor. It seems newer models can have an issue with walking that will be worse with the slope.

The front loaders seem to have so many flaws that I'm leaning toward a top loader. (I'm short and don't like having to reach over my head to fill the detergent dispenser on a top loader.) The flip side is that I see so many conflicting reviews about the HE top loading machines I can't decide if an "HE" is something to avoid.

Then there is brand..... Is it just a crap shoot as to if I get a decent model of either type? If you have a washer you love or hate please comment and tell me what type, brand and at least general model name. If you have any knowledge about how the sloped floor will affect any washer I'd appreciate the info.

Thanks in advance!!

Comments (19)

  • PRO
    11 years ago
    I've had a Fisher Paykel since 2002 and I love it. It's a top loader. I had to fix a part on it at year 2 for about 60. Since then it's been going strong.
    debqhix thanked Drawer Essentials
  • 11 years ago
    @hayleydaniels - I guess that is a problem most people don't run into. Sounds like you found a reasonable work around! Whirlpool is one of the brands in the replacement program I'm considering so I'm glad to hear your experience.
    @Drawer Essentials- I've heard lots of good about Fisher Paykel and very few complaints. Sounds like getting the brand repaired isn't a drawback either, like others report with some brands (Samsung & LG seem to have expensive parts). Good to know.
    Thank you both for your help.
  • 11 years ago
    I have the same washer as haleydaniels. Mines has a he on it. Lots of setting. I am happy with it.
    debqhix thanked goldensister
  • 11 years ago
    I have a LG front loader and am very happy with it. My laundry room is on the main floor so I ensured I purchased one that has low vibration. All front loaders need to be level, so if you have a slope in your floor a top loader might be your best best. Look at consumer reports to get com parables.
    debqhix thanked Tina
  • 11 years ago

    Don't the feet adjust on your washer? You could set the back feet low and the front feet higher to level your machine even if the floor slopes a little. Or, even set the front feet on shims or casters or something.

    I have a new LG front loader in my second floor laundry room, and love it to death.


    debqhix thanked Sally Pascale
  • 11 years ago

    I have a Bosch front loader and I'm very happy with it..we've had it for 8 years and no problems so far.
    My mom has LG, front loader, and she's really happy with it


    debqhix thanked printesa
  • 11 years ago
    We just bought new LG washer and dryer, which are in our master bath. Clean well, and they are quiet!
    debqhix thanked User
  • 11 years ago
    I had a Bosch in Denmark, it was ok, but not great.
    I now have Maytag front-loaders, which I LOVE.
    One of my friends has the Fisher Paykel, and I have only heard good things about their quality.
    debqhix thanked User
  • 11 years ago
    We have an LG front loader in our 2nd floor laundry room that has similar issues as yours. When it goes into spin cycle, the entire house shakes :( I'm in the same predicament as you are. Bookmarking this post to see if anyone has any suggestions!
    debqhix thanked Jacquelyn Freshour
  • 11 years ago
    I have an LG top loader and I absolutely hate it. Well, I guess it's the HE features that I hate and not specifically the LG. We left our 10 year old Fisher & Paykel when we sold our last home (not one repair in 10 years!) and I wish I'd bought another instead of the LG but the LG was larger and more easily available in our new area.

    The HE is the real problem, I think. Cycles take forever unless I use the quick wash, which I don't think cleans as well.

    The Fisher & Paykel seemed to balance loads better and spin clothes (esp towels) drier.
    debqhix thanked crowley48
  • 11 years ago

    Top rated high-efficiency washers by Consumer Reports are LG, Samsung, Kenmore Elite, and Maytag for front loaders, and LG, Samsung, and Kenmore Elite for for top loaders. Noise ratings are the same for all these brands. You should be able to level the washer by adjusting the feet, and if necessary, using rubberized floor protectors under individual feet. You can also get floor pans to place under the washer and dryer.

    debqhix thanked derk5
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks everyone for the comments they were helpful. I think I narrowed it down to a Whirlpool Cabrio or Maytag Bravos which are both made by Whirlpool and mostly the same machine with varying features. However, the discount program my home warranty company is offering has so many extra fees that even with the discount and money back offer, the final price ends up being about what I'd pay just going to Home Depot, Lowes, or wherever. So, I might just get the Kenmore repaired and hold off on a new one.

    The one thing I did find in all this research, jacquelynnmarie, is that they make anti-vibration pads for washing machines. Lowes & Amazon sell them for less than $30. I think I'll try these no matter what brand machine I use. The shaking with the 2nd floor laundry room can get a bit jarring-- even with the balancing feet firmly leveled to limit walking.

    http://www.lowes.com/pd_273886-67588-13131_0_

  • 11 years ago
    crowley48 do you also have a smell issue?? We also have a top load HE LG washer and I noticed a stinky smell gradually build up.
    It didn't get the clothes clean and left my hand towels and wash cloths with a sour smell. I've been reading everything I can on how to deal with this and apparently you have to run a clean cycle every month to get the tub clean as the holes plug up and stuff builds up behind the tub. I leave the lid open. I'm hoping this helps or I am ready to get rid of it and find an old fashioned one!
  • 11 years ago

    Smell Issue? I have a front loader, I leave the door wide open and the soap dispenser drawer open between loads (both open ALL the time) to avoid a mouldy smell. Remove the soap dispenser drawer and clean it as needed, you'll be surprised how much water sits in the bottom of it. The backside of the rubber gasket at the door needs to be checked and cleaned as needed.

    Run a hot water cycle periodically to help remove residue from the machine that warm or cold water may not remove.


  • 11 years ago

    Help!!! My clothes washer has to go in an unheated garage I would like to avoid building an enclosure any ideas? This is a slab ranch in natick mass thank you so much

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    @debqhix - you may have bought your washer by now. We have a Maytag Bravo top loader and really like it and it's the largest size so my number of loads have decreased substantially. We also purchased a floor model that saved us a couple of hundred dollars - hope that helps. @mjmiller - I believe all HE's have build up and newer models have a reminder after so many loads. It's recommeneded to use a special cleaner or bleach and there is a specific wash cycle on new machines. I do about 5-7 loads on a weekly basis and it's about a month when I get a reminder. Also leave the lid open when not in use if you don't have children's safety issues. @bettie - is there any issue with pipes freezing?

    debqhix thanked Maureen
  • 11 years ago

    We will drain the pipes for the winter I am concerned about the motor. Does anyone have the same situation?

  • 5 years ago

    I believe the odor issue with HE machines can be attributed to three things: the plastic outer tub, and the removal of PHOSPHATES in laundry detergent and not using a HOT wash for whites. 15 to 20 years ago, no one had to clean their washing machines or dishwasher. Now both machines have a dedicated cycle to clean the machines. The issue with phosphate is due to fertilizer runoff from farming, not the tiny amounts in household detergents.