Software
Houzz Logo Print
lmridgeway

HELP! Color scheme with pickled cabinets

11 years ago

Recently had my kitchen walls painted with BM Covington Blue, the trim in White Dove, and oak floors refinished with a medium brown stain and I have black and white accents. Cabinets are shaker style with a pickled finish. I am putting in granite counters and a backsplash but cannot pick them out until I decide if I should keep my cabinets as is, or paint them to match the White Dove trim. I know general consensus is "pickled anything" dates a house. That said, my cabinets were fine for me until I put up the white trim/blue walls. As is they do not compliment each other. But I think it could work if I install granite that has both the trim and cabinet colors, as well as a classic white subway tile backsplash. I would prefer not to paint the cabinets but am not opposed, as I love the crisp clean feeling of white in a kitchen. Painting would also give me the opportunity to change out the trim molding up top and box the two deeper cabinets up to the ceiling. I am also not thrilled with the cabinets above the desk area. I also like designs that mix cabinet and counter colors.

Here are some pics. Any advise would be greatly appreciated. I have been agonizing over this for too long, afraid of making wrong decisions that are expensive and permanent....



Comments (29)

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    As with any decision cost always focuses what is important. You are right to make sure you want these cabinets before locking them in with granite. I usually ask 4 questions to those in your situation. 1) Are you wanting to move any appliance? 2) Are you planning on getting different sized appliances or adding/removing cabinets to your kitchen? 3) Have you looked at what cabinetry these days are offering? (i.e. frameless construction, soft closing features, more drawers than doors)

    If the answers is Yes to the first two and No to #3. then you may be more of a candidate to completely replace especially if you plan on staying in the home for the next 10 years.

    But like I said "Money is always the tie breaker." In your case I would estimate a good quality cabinets costing between 20K - 30k /installed to be safe. You could certainly spend less but to upgrade what you already have would be the point of replacing, NOT going back with the same thing but a different color.

    lmridgeway thanked Midtown Cabinetry & Designs
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    These cabinets have a really pretty profile, and would look great painted white. There are companies that will do a great spray job complete with a clear coat. If you do it yourself, beware of future chipping, etc. If the cabinets are still in really great shape, and you like the layout, it would be worth paying to have them professionally sprayed.

    lmridgeway thanked Design Inspirations Inc.
  • 11 years ago

    The color of blue you chose has a bit of a green tint, which is making the cabinets look pink. Either change the wall color slightly until you undo that effect, or paint them white. Agree that you should hold off on stone until you like how other elements play together.

    lmridgeway thanked acm
  • 11 years ago

    Thx MC&D for your response. Would love soft close and more drawers but upgrading is not in my plan. Cost to replace was over $30k. To reface was $20k. To paint $6k. My goal is to make what I have work as inexpensively as possible.

  • 11 years ago

    The style of cabinets are clean lined, I believe that the tone of the wood is bringing out the greens in your paint making it less calming. As others mentioned above white would be a great choice. It will really make your wall color look crisp. Also have you considered doing a brushed nickel hardware in a linear style handle? This would pull in your stainless steel appliances.

    -- Good luck on your project!

    lmridgeway thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Thank so much everyone for your input. I would definitely leave it to the professionals to paint the cabinets white. Any thoughts on painting the island another color? And what would you recommend for the counter and back splash colors.

  • 11 years ago

    My take - paint the island a deeper shade of the blue greens . . . back with a good one. Don't paint the cabinets, they are gorgeous and more subtle. My suggestion would be to repaint the trim in here an off white selected to work with the cabinet tone - much easier to do - the pantry door is absolutely needs to match the cabinets and the trim can be one shade lighter . the wall color is bright and will be fine with a different trim.


    lmridgeway thanked libradesigneye
  • 11 years ago
    Would you be ok with white counters?
    Or something Carrara marble-like because the blue gray veins look nice with turquoise. http://houzz.com/photos/26162226
    Black would also work, here they did black with a white island. http://houzz.com/photos/8810765
  • 11 years ago

    Here's a great shade for your island. http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/fortpiercegreen

    Even bm doesn't pair covington with white, and this is for good reason - it is a clear tone that paired with other muted off whites is sophisticated. Paired with straight white, it comes out a bit juvenile / resort ish . . I love it with your cabinets because it wakes up the room, but if you switch everything over then it won't be as great. Here's a link to show how a tan on trim / deeper on a door works well against color on the wall

    http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/for-your-home/rooms-by-color/warm-and-inviting-red-entry

    Some trim colors to test (but ideally you are trying to match the undertone in your cabinets)

    bm cream fleece http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/creamfleece

    going to the chapel - a different tonal way to mute the trim http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/goingtothechapel

    lmridgeway thanked libradesigneye
  • 11 years ago

    ps I like the stone you show - and by the way, you don't have to change the trim in the rest of the house . . one shift for this room is fine . .

    lmridgeway thanked libradesigneye
  • 11 years ago

    libradesigneye: I was thinking the island should be a neutral color as the wall paint will change over time but the island will not. But I am really liking the fort pierce green. I am surprised by your comment about BM not pairing covington blue with dove white as I paid a professional designer to help me with the colors.... I like the crisp look and will be careful to avoid a juvenile feel.

  • 11 years ago

    This same designer suggested I paint the cabinets to match the trim. I guess I'm hesitating in hopes of finding another solution other than painting.

  • 11 years ago

    W Brown, Thank you for the pics. I love both!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Don't get me wrong, white trim is always going to be an easy designer choice, it is just the wrong choice in this room because of your cabinet color. You selected a great color for your walls - I'm glad the fort pierce is working for you. If you try to mute the color down on the trim, I think you will be happier with the room than if you paint the cabinets. That is also - just one opinion - you live with your choices.

    To me, the thing that gives the charm here are the cabinets in this beautiful tone (sometimes pickling turns out pink or peach and isn't nice - these are truly gorgeous imho). It is also a much smaller job to add one coat over trim than to paint cabinets - You might test some new trim tones on the pantry door and trim since it is surrounded by the cabinets and you can stand back and see it.

    Sorry for any misunderstanding with the "juvenile" adjective - I don't mean to say that your room is an any way juvenile. If you had all white, the strong covington color just might not be your first pick - you would likely select something more muted. Since you have some other muted things, the strong color brings balance. Showing that bm pairings with covington are off whites was just a way to communicate that an off white here or soft neutral will totally work with your color (which again, I love here).

    lmridgeway thanked libradesigneye
  • 11 years ago

    libradesigneye - I am not offended at all by your juvenile reference. I too have had that concern with those strong blue and green colors. My new color palette might be knee jerk from having lived with a muted washed out look for so long. But I really do love it! Thanks so much for your advise.

  • 11 years ago
    I really like your cabinets! The trim on top is a little dated, but the style of the doors is not. The color does not look like it went off color, and is very nice. I like your paint color as well.
    Consider keeping the cabinets as is, putting in an soft white quartz countertop, and pulling the colors together in the backsplash. Also, replace the knobs.
    lmridgeway thanked sootsprite
  • 11 years ago
    Here is similar wood tone with white counters

    http://houzz.com/photos/16547740
    lmridgeway thanked sootsprite
  • 11 years ago
    Not the same wood tone, but similar enough, with white counter and coordinating backsplash

    http://houzz.com/photos/4930850
    lmridgeway thanked sootsprite
  • 11 years ago
    I agree the white trim is too jarring and is the culprit here.
    If you are planning to replace the counters anyways don't paint your cabinets. I don't think white subway tile is a good idea either. I think a glass tile perhaps mixing a hint of the green and a neutral creamy color, paired with a creamy counter color in lieu of the darker shade you have now, would do the trick.
    lmridgeway thanked User
  • 11 years ago
    As I have been looking for countertops recently I came across one that used recycled glass which would look good imho. It includes the blue of your wall and color's similar to your cabs. It from the maker of siltstone. Also ESO makes one that might work for you as well as ice stone. Good luck
    lmridgeway thanked vizkid88
  • 11 years ago

    I like the cabinets with the blue. I think what is throwing me off, is the countertops. Once you change them out, I think you will be able to pull it all together.

    lmridgeway thanked mamabear2014
  • 11 years ago

    i think you have lots of options.....the cabinets look fine as they are, and they are in great shape, so if you opt to keep them as they are you might want to consider a sleek white quartz countertop, enlarging the overhang slightly and adding a "waterfall" effect of the countertop material on the island, which will give the whole space a clean modern look and it would conceal the 2 tones on the island nicely. if you decide to paint the cabinets white they would look equally good, in my opinion. the granite you showed us could be great with white cabinets.....i guess i'm not much help. regardless which option you choose, i'd definitely make a few small upgrades also: remove all decor from the tops of the cabinets, remove the decorative cut-out above the plate rack, remove the track light from the ceiling and center a great chandelier or pendant over the island and replace the 2 pot lights over your peninsula with coordinating smaller pendants, and upgrade the cabinetry pulls....there are sooo many stylish hardware options! go for something with a bit more impact. you have a great space....please keep us posted! :)

    lmridgeway thanked potchiemagoodleberry
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    I would have them painted white. It'd really make the other colors pop instead of working against the cabs. The style of your doors are PERFECT for white cabs!
    lmridgeway thanked Amy Farell, Water's Edge Design
  • 11 years ago
    I would not paint the cabinets. They likely will be prone to chips and will make your kitchen look cold with the paint color. As long as the cabinets are in good condition I would go ahead and get granite countertops. What I really don't care for is the color of the blue green walls. I would also install a tile backsplash. If you had granite, tile and different paint your kitchen would look much better.
    lmridgeway thanked toriat
  • 11 years ago

    Hi, what did you end up doing imridgeway?

    lmridgeway thanked Allie D.
  • 11 years ago

    I am in a holding pattern. I choose my granite which is called Ciantus and am waiting for installation. I'm hoping this will help pull things together without changing the cabinet color. I'll update once it is all done.... Thanks for asking. :)

  • 11 years ago
    Paint the cabinets. Look at either white or a pale gray. Think you would be pleased with either. Love you other choices!