Software
Houzz Logo Print
joshing

Need help with flooring color

11 years ago

I'm really bad with colors and I need some help with picking out the colors for my flooring for my rental. (I'm still confused by the whole find your season for color thing and how some colors had a blue undertone and other colors had a pink undertone.)

Right now, I have these tiles in my kitchen and adjacent dining room:


When you walk a few steps down from the dining room, you reach the living room:


Right now, there's carpet in the living room. But, I'm going to rip it out and replace with hardwood or a vinyl that looks like hardwood.

Since the two rooms are next to each other, should I be trying to match the hardwood flooring to the tile? If they do, I'm not sure how you'd do that since there's multiple colors in the tile.

There's all these different shades of wood colors from a dark brown/blackish to reddish to brownish to grayish to yellowish. I'm thinking that those dark brown/blackish woods might be too dark next to the tiles, but I don't really know.

I tried to do this with the wall color before and had the paint guy at Home Depot select the paint color for me and it, uh, didn't turn out so well. But, I know people here are much better at this stuff.

Comments (11)

  • 11 years ago

    I'll give you my opinion from a practical view....if you choose one of the darker woods, dust on the floor will be 'very' noticeable (unless you like to clean). My hardwoods are a natural finish & easy to clean. I would bring home several of the samples in the brown family (maybe similar to the color of the handrail in photo) & place against the flooring to determine what appeals to you.

  • 11 years ago

    I think I read in another thread that this is a condo near the beach that you're wanting to update, right?

    I definitely wouldn't do dark wood- they show dust, would visually chop up the space, and I think you want to go lighter, brighter, more beach contemporary.

    I'd go with a light to mid-tone wood that doesn't have a lot of pattern, like maple, or maybe bamboo. Take a tile to the flooring store, and find something that looks right. Stay away from anything very reddish or yellowish.

    Then you'll want to make sure your choice looks ok with the wooden railing between the rooms, or paint it white.

    LIVING ROOM - PENDANT · More Info


  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Maybe some medium tones woods like these.


  • 11 years ago

    I have vinyl that looks like wood and find it works great for us.

    If you are really bad with colors, then take a tile with you to the flooring store and have them help you pick a color. I'm pretty good with colors, but I was still at sea in the tile store, so I found a sales gal who was sympatico with me and she was a terrific help and I'm very happy with the results.

  • 11 years ago

    Color of the table or natural.
    You mentioned in another thread that you were trying to appeal to "better" renters. Therefore, I'd either consider hardwood with a waterbased commercial finish or look into the woodlike tiles. Or better yet, look at what your competitors have in their rentals.


  • 11 years ago

    So, it seems like the consensus is to go with brownish in a medium tone.

    I get why to stay away from something too dark- shows too much dust and too dark for a beachy vibe.

    And, I read that the reddish woods are out of fashion now.

    But, I don't understand why something yellowish wasn't suggested. When I brought this tile(all three pictures are of the same tile) to Home Depot to pick out a paint color, the paint person told me I should get a yellow paint. And, so the walls are painted yellow and I thought something yellowish for the flooring would match the tiles.

    And, why stay away from something with a lot of pattern? Is the same as saying to stay away with a strong grain? I was thinking if I did go with hardwood, a hardwood with a strong grain would help hide any scratches.

  • 11 years ago

    If I had to start all over again, I think I would go with wood tiles for the kitchen and dining space. But, I don't know if that was an option when I changed to this tile- I don't know if they had it or the wood tiles weren't very good yet.

    If I kept the current tiles in the kitchen and the the dining room and then installed wood tiles in the adjacent living room, wouldn't it be weird to have two tiles next to each other?

    Also, I'm debating whether or not to rip out the carpets upstairs as well and use the same flooring in the upstairs bedrooms as I'll use for the living room. In that scenario, I don't know if people would like to have tiles in their bedrooms.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I don't think the two different tiles would be a problem at all, but with tile it's easy to lay some samples down next to each other to see. Honestly, I was never a fan of these until I saw them being installed in the remodel, of a local JCP store. Not only did it look great, but it was actually difficult to tell that they weren't wood. I will definitely be using it in our upstairs bath if the opportunity arises.

    As far as tile in the bedrooms, I think that is a regional thing. In the south where there is a lot of humidity it makes sense because humidity isn't good for wood. In those cases, laminant, vinyl or tile makes much more sense and I think the wood looking tiles would be a perfect solution.

    In regards to your question regarding pattern and color. This is just my take on it, but flooring is a more permanent fixture in a room and something you're basically committed to regardless of your decor choices. If you use something with a lot of heavy grain or pattern, it can be limiting and very busy looking. For example, we have oak cabinets in our kitchen. I know they aren't the popular choice, but they're in good condition and we like them, however if we had used oak for the floors as well, the grains in the two woods would have been competing with each other. Instead we used a wood in the dining and kitchen that had no grain (Brazilian Walnut) and it worked out much better. What I find interesting is that we laid oak throughout the rest of our main level and the maintenance for both woods is almost identical. The difference in color and/or grain has made literally no difference with how much dirt shows or doesn't show and we've been very happy with both choices. Now in regards to color, would you really want a tile floor, wood floors and walls in yellow? If you already have yellow walls, and a tile with yellow tints to it, a medium toned wood will help break up the monotony of it and offer some contrast and interest to the space.

  • 11 years ago

    Bamboo from Costco?
    I have natural oak, i..e no stain, with a commercial finish and it's worn really well with kids, dogs, etc. Like this. It's perhaps more contemporary and brighter than stained floors.

    Hardwood Flooring · More Info


  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Of course we are relying on the color rendition from our monitors, so the color may be a bit different in real life, but I would never use yellow paint to go with that tile. Off White, Taupe, Grey, Beige, Not sure if you spoke with a man or woman at HD, but 30% of the male population is color blind and many men don't know if, so taking recommendations should be carefully evaluated.


Sponsored
Buckeye Basements, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars40 Reviews
Central Ohio's Basement Finishing ExpertsBest Of Houzz '13-'21