Software
Houzz Logo Print
zack_lau

How good is your soil?

After 12 years of mulching with wood chips and another 5 years of top dressing with leaf compost, the soil in my back yard has gotten really good--no longer the heavy clay soil it used to be. It is also 4 to six inches higher--really important with all the water that accumulates back there. While we have only one big maple tree--we get the equivalent of another big tree's leaves from the surrounding properties.

Comments (12)

  • 11 years ago

    The base soil in our area is clay. However, I am lucky in that my garden has been actively gardened for 110 years. There are many trees and bushes, and we DO NOT pick up every leaf and "clean up" all of the time. Neither did my DH's ancestors. So, we have lovely clay based loam in most of the garden. There are obscure corners where I still find just clay (you could make dishes out of it!), so I am careful if I try to plant anything there.

    We do mulch the roses with compost made on site at least once a year. So, there are problems in my garden, as in all gardens, but they are not related to bad soil.

    Jackie

  • 11 years ago

    My native "soil" is sugar sand. I've been improving it with kitty litter and horse manure for the last 15 or 20 years. It's still not what I would call rich soil, but it's vastly improved. Obviously, the advantages of this type soil is it's very easy to dig in, and I don't have drainage issues.

  • 11 years ago

    Lake bed clay topped with whatever "top soil" the builder hauled in. It's not too bad but I occasionally unearth a brick or piece of concrete so they must have used some junk fill too. I've been mixing in bags of top soil, peat, manure, etc., for years too when I redo beds.

  • 11 years ago

    We're fortunate enough here in Nebraska to start with loamy clay, and as Jackie says I don't clean off leaf litter - I deliberately add huge bags of it each year. As long as there is enough moisture (and heaven help me, we've had plenty lately), I can scratch with my fingers to replant bulbs down to a good 6" if necessary. Filling a 5 gallon bucket to dig a rose hole takes maybe 2 easy shovel-fulls. I feel for the folks who have to dig their holes with a pickaxe. Good soil makes a huge difference.

    Cynthia

  • 11 years ago

    Cynthia, I couldn't agree more that good soil makes a huge difference. Unfortunately, I didn't realize that when I first began this garden and did not amend the soil in the garden beds, and just dug holes and amended them with bagged soil. Not nearly good enough when you have decomposed granite as "soil", and my roses don't grow nearly as well as they would in decent soil. The drought has exacerbated the situation, and all I can do at this point is mulch as much as possible and hope that the mulch will break down and enrich the soil. It's not an ideal situation, but the garden did reasonably well when there was ample winter rain. Since that has changed I no longer really have a garden to speak of, just struggling plants or young plants that aren't growing very fast in areas where the previous roses have failed. I'm not sure what the future will hold, but I'm not giving up either. Gardeners are always hopeful.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Pickaxe lady here! But it could be worse. The clay works really nicely once other things are mixed in with it. And I have a ton of grass clippings and leaves from regular yard work, so the clay will get better all the time. I do use a bunch of coffee grounds, too, because they are a great texture, I think.

    For my orchard way in back, I ran into areas that were dry clay but also with big granite and quartz rocks everywhere! Fortunately all but one hole was dug before I found how hard it is to dig in a rock outcrop, lol. Now THAT would be awful soil to try to garden in. It makes the side and front yards seem really easy, I tell you :)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have added 2 or 3 inches of compost top dress every year. I also mulch with shredded leaves every year. There is spent coffee grounds too. And eggshells. My soil is good. It didn't start out that way. It was sandy with a few inches of good topsoil. If for some reason I disturb a handful size area of the garden there is a group of birds to inspect where i just dug soon after , like office workers around the water cooler.

  • 11 years ago

    At the historic site where I'm blessed to garden, the red Virginia clay has been in cultivation for about 350 years. There's a layer about three feet deep that looks and feels like potting soil. My home garden is only about thirty years old and the topsoil is about two inches deep. In about three hundred years, I'll have soil to die for.


  • 11 years ago

    Native, brick hard red clay. All the plants (including the roses) get a combination of 50% bagged Garden Soil, 30% sand and 20% native red clay ground up. Every year all the beds get a top dressing of Black Kow, ground up leafs and ground pine needles, then a layer of mulch. Everything seems to like my redone soil.


  • 11 years ago

    For years we've been composting and amending at Humpty Dumpty House. My favorite method is the lazy way. We dig big holes, three to four feet deep, maybe four feet square, and fill them with all our healthy garden and kitchen waste. We always have several holes going. Some of the neighbors use our holes as well. We occasionally spritz the holes with water. In a year or two we have a fertile new bed. The beds where I planted new roses last year only took about a year of prep time, but those holes were not quite as deep.

    It just never made sense to me that planting in an amended planting hole would be healthy. Even if the planting hole has great soil, what about the rest of the bed? Are the roots meant to stay in just the planting hole for the life of the plant? If the amendments are well-draining and the surrounding soil is heavy clay, aren't you making a clay bowl that will hold water and drown the plant?

    Despite other "not so good" conditions like morning shade and full, blasting afternoon sun and reflective surfaces, the roses we've planted this way are thriving.


  • 11 years ago

    " three to four feet deep"

    Holy mother of god, and you call that "the lazy way?' LOL My back hurts just from reading that. I dug trenches last year, not as wide and deep as recommended, but as wide and deep as I was willing.

    I started with compacted black clay and basically threw the kitchen sink at it. It still has a lot of clay, but it seems to be doing OK. It gets mulch and compost, but it's still young.

  • 11 years ago

    Okay, it's easy to forget about the digging since we only do it every two years or so. If you want a permanent compost hole for waste collection and composting, you'd only have to do the digging once. After that it's so convenient to blow or sweep or toss our healthy garden and kitchen waste in -- much easier and better for our gardens and the environment than hoisting it up into the garbage bin. We don't turn the stuff in these holes or do much of anything else for a year or more as they transform from waste into beds with lovely friable soil.


Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert