Software
Houzz Logo Print
jacqueline9ca

Could this rose be Eugene de Beauharnais?

11 years ago

I took a cutting of this rose to the Celebration of Old Roses in El Cerrito (which by-the-way was fantastic, as always), and a couple of people thought it might be EdB.

My confusion is that EdB is listed as a china. My rose does not grow like my other chinas, which are twiggy, and send canes out at all odd angles to each other. Mine is a fairly upright, small bush about 3-4 feet tall, which sends up straightish canes. About twice a year it rewards me with a sucker which has made a new plant, about 10 inches away from the original one. Also, it is incredibly fragrant, which none of my other chinas are. Someone also told me it looked like a bourbon, which seems a much better guess than a china.

Any thoughts?

Jackie



Comments (15)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    That looks about right. The habit of EdB is like a really puny hybrid tea with upright stems about 1/8 or 3/16". It has a distinctive fragrance, dark, funky, musky. Think beef stew with cumin. Well, not exactly that, but not like any flower I've smelled.

  • 11 years ago

    Gorgeous rose but smelling like beef stew? Just when I thought I heard everything...lol.

  • 11 years ago

    That's what that is, yes.


  • 11 years ago

    Jackie's specimen looks like a lusty grower compared to the one I tried to grow. It would manage about three of those little shoots in a season and then get killed back by winter or canker. Interesting little fellow, though. Probably best in a pot to get it up where it is noticeable, and given winter shelter in zones 7 and colder.

  • 11 years ago

    But, if it's EdB, where is the rust??? I personally have never seen one without it, almost a diagnostic feature to me. Yours is a beautiful specimen, Jackie!

  • 11 years ago

    I have never seen rust on this rose in 25 years. The only roses which get rust in my garden are 2 mid 20th century HTs which we keep because they are "family heirlooms".

    Jackie

  • 11 years ago

    Jackie, now that I see the plant, I am even more willing to accept this as EdB.

    I am making an interesting experiment here, with the help of Kim Rupert.

    We removed EdB from our garden long ago, because when we quit spraying, it began to rust. Inexorably. It was the only rose I have ever seen whose leaves rusted even as they began to unfold.

    Kim's theory was that if EdB was budded onto real powerhouse rootstock, it might not rust. So, he budded it on Fortuniana, which is a happy monster here.

    The very first leaves rusted.

    I removed them, and subsequent leaves have not rusted -- so I am cautiously optimistic.

    And I theorize that if your plant is really an old one, and possibly budded to start with, it might have the rust-resistant that we hope Fort is imparting to mine.

    An interesting side-story. When we grew EdB before -- and sprayed regularly -- we also exhibited regularly. The best spray of EdB I ever saw was DQ'd at an ARS rose show, because the judges asked someone about it, and that person said that she didn't know the rose, but it didn't "look like a China" to her.

    To say that I was ticked off is putting it mildly.


  • 11 years ago

    Jeri, we have three plants of this rose. The oldest one may be budded (or have once been budded), who knows? However, I know the other two are on their own roots, because I dug them up as suckers and planted them. Neither of them has ever rusted, and one of them is over 10 years old. We don't know when the original one was planted - could have been anytime from the 1910s to the 1970s (when my FIL bought a bunch of OGRs from RoY&T and planted them). Definitely not after the 1970s, though. Possibly a healthier cultivar? I love these mysteries!

    Jackie

  • 11 years ago

    There were a few roses called "Chinas" because they were smaller and bloomed repeatedly -- despite having "other blood" in them. EdB is really a small Bourbon that resembles a China, like "Sophie's Perpetual". They might have a lot of China blood, but real Chinas don't have Damask fragrance. Another I think of off the top of my head is 'Louis XIV' -- which is probably the same rose being sold as 'Nigrette'. Some call it a China because it's small and twiggy and blooms repeatedly, but the former was a seedling of a Hybrid Perpetual, the latter an old Hybrid Tea. I'm not sure which name is correct for the rose being sold under both, but in any case, it's not really a China.

    :-)

    ~Christopher


  • 11 years ago

    Oh, and I'm hoping this year my EdB won't have its unopened buds "harvested" by the neighborhood squirrels who must think they are berries. Since I've mulched that area with coffee grounds, the squirrels don't walk there anymore. Last year, I think I got to see 3 blooms all year. This year, every about-to-open bud is in perfect shape.

    :-)

    ~Christopher


  • 11 years ago

    Eugene rusted in Newhall. It rusted in Pacific Palisades. It rusted in Encino when the heat was high and water stress extreme. The SAME plant and the one from which Jeri's plant was budded, was dug and nearly bare rooted this February, stuffed into a two gallon can and moved north where it is often twenty degrees cooler and always damper. There is a little mildew on the plant and NO rust. Others are rusting around it, but not Eugene. My only thought is the thing isn't water stressed, so it isn't rusting. Kim


  • 11 years ago

    Here on the east coast, "water-stressed" would be taken to mean "planted under where the roof gutter drains." Perhaps this is why I've never seen rust.

    ;-)

    ~Christopher


  • 11 years ago

    Sure a pale color, tho ... isn't it, Kim? We had early bad heat, and a LOT of things here bloomed paler than they normally do. (OTOH, my possible Ragged Robin, which often DOES bloom pink, stayed deep red. Go figure.)
    Anyhow, this plant is going strong.
    And, btw, the budded "Schmidt's Smooth Yellow" is REALLY growing fast. And, since it went into the ground, so is 'Eyes For You.'


  • 11 years ago

    Even though it is COOL and usually damp here, the UV is intense. Things which darken with it are DARK. Those which fade, fade quickly. Laughter Lines is usually heavily painted in Torrance. Here, by the end of the first day, it is nearly solid red. There are Double Delights in the neighborhood which are usually solid strawberry instead of ivory-white with strawberry brushing. Kim