Software
Houzz Logo Print
hudson___wy

Dwarf Tomatoes in a GH

11 years ago

We plant only indeterminate tomato plants in our GH because our GH is tall at the ridge (16'). Determinate plants are a waste of our GH space and are not as prolific as indeterminate plants. But we noticed the last couple of years that as the indeterminate plant grows and produces from the bottom up - by the time tomatoes above approx 4' are ripening - the tomatoes below 4' have been harvested and the leaves begin to yellow.

The lower leaves no longer provide a service and are extra baggage - so we cut them off.

This also seems to be wasted GH space below 4' on the tomato stems. We talked about ideas to take advantage of the space. We came up with the idea of planting Dwarf determinate tomato plants between the indeterminate's and planting them later than the indeterminate plants so the Dwarf determinate would fill the gap. We did some research on determinate Dwarf tomato plants - looking for our criteria of great taste & large tomato size on a Dwarf plant. We think we found the right variety!

New Big Dwarf - this is a heirloom variety bred in 1914 with a Pondersa and Dwarf Champion cross. The plant is 2-4 tall and has great reviews for fruit size, taste and is prolific.

This year we spaced our indeterminate plants farther apart in anticipation of planting NBD in-between. We have never tried this method before - nor - have we tried NBD. This is an experiment - but if it works - it should increase the capacity of our GH to produce more tomatoes in the same space and over a longer period of time. We will see.

This is how the NBD looked on May 15th. We are planting them incrementally to see the best time to plant them for future years if this idea proves successful.

I am sure there are those who have a GH that have attempted similar if not the same idea in the past. Please let us know of your experience and varieties - success or failures. We will update our progress for those that may have an interest in this method.

Comments (21)

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the very informative post and the great pictures. I will be interested in any future updates. I have always grown my tomatoes outside my greenhouse, but I think I will try your method with some of them this year.


  • 11 years ago

    This NBD may be as prolific as reviewed. This plant's 1st truss has 18 buds/blossoms on it so far !!


  • 11 years ago

    Our New Big Dwarf set its first fruit - it appears to be doing fine between the other tomato plants - so far.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago


    NBD progress update - good size and quantity of fruit developing !

  • 11 years ago

    I think this is a great idea. I usually only grow determinates in my greenhouse during winter because in summer it takes too much effort to cool it. Looking forward to your updates.

  • 11 years ago

    The concept may be successful - here is a progress report. We are harvesting the lower indeterminate tomatoes now and clipping leaves as they expire and become baggage to the plant. The New Big Dwarf are setting fruit and getting more breathing room and sun as we prune. They have several trusses and have grown to about 3-4' in height now. They are not as bushy on the bottom as I thought they were going to be - but do have room to grow behind our indeterminate Brandy Boys.


  • 11 years ago

    The biggest tomato on the truss is blushing - taste test won't be long now. The tomato size on this plant is impressive - for a Dwarf!


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Update: We discovered a couple of things by planting New Big Dwarf Tomato Plants between our Brandy Boy plants.

    1) New Big Dwarf is not a Determinate Variety as advertised by our seed source - it is definitely an Indeterminate Variety and competed with the Brandy Boys for space - NBD grew over 8' in height and needed support. I would not recommend planting NBD between indeterminate plants for the purpose explained in this thread. There must be a determinate variety that would work though - if we can find one that produces a medium to large good tasting fruit - like NBD?

    and

    2) We found out that New Big Dwarf is an excellent variety to plant!! NBD produces a good sized fruit, good taste and very prolific. We will plant it again - but not between our Brandy Boys - haha.


  • 11 years ago

    Those are beauties Hudson! How did you get them all to fit?

    Early Wonder is a small plant. I'm not sure if it's determinate or not but it might be worth a look. it's tasty but not too vigorous, which might be a benefit in your case.

  • 11 years ago

    Karin - I could have pruned the New Big Dwarf back but I wanted to see their growing pattern for future planting decisions. I expected that they would quit growing - at least by 4' high - as they were represented as a Dwarf Determinate that grew to approximately 2-3' by the seed supplier.

    It was a congested mess above 4'. I could not tie or prune the NBD properly because the Brandy Boys were already tied, pruned and established. Several long branches of NBD would come crashing down - loaded with tomatoes - because I failed to see/tie them.

    Other than the fact that they did not grow as expected - the plant it's self was a huge success. Very prolific, good tasting, good sized tomatoes from an aggressive growing plants. I did some research and found that most seed suppliers do represent New Big Dwarf as an Indeterminate variety. I sent an email to the seed source several weeks ago - challenging their listing - but they have never responded.

    I looked up Early Wonder with some research - it appears to be a good option to plant between my indeterminate plants but I think I will try a different strategy next season. Now that we have a thermostatically controlled heater - I think I will plant my indeterminate plants even further apart. This year we planted them 3' apart - next spring (unless we change our mind) we will plant them 4' apart in the GH the first week in March (as always) and then plant indeterminate plants between them in early June. I noticed that many of our tomato plants succumbed to disease by August and had to be pulled. I hope by planting a second group in June we will have strong producing plants through November.

    We are always trying different methods - it seems - but our goal is to have the best tasting tomato that is good sized (we prefer 10-16 oz) and very prolific before we will give it much space in our GH. We may as well try staggering indeterminate plants that we know meet our specifications than give much space to an experimental (to us) variety that we have no idea how it will perform.

    That is what we learned from this years methods - in the future we will most likely not plant more than one each of an experimental (for us) variety because of our limited GH space!


  • 11 years ago

    Oh I can only imagine the crowding you had! But then again, tons and tons of tomatoes!

    Your new method sounds promising and potentially hugely productive. Do you can or freeze tomato sauce? I know I've asked you that question but I can't remember.

    I'm looking forward to trying Brandy Boy next year. It's about time I checked this one out!

  • 11 years ago

    My wife bottles salsa and a tomato soup - similar to Campbell's Tomato Soup - but better because it is homemade. She doesn't currently make tomato sauce. We freeze the tomatoes as we have extras - then she makes a batch of soup when she has 16 lbs of frozen tomatoes. We give a lot of ripe tomatoes away to neighbors and our kids. We never have too many tomatoes in this garden tomato deprived valley !!

    After seeing/reading the success and failures of Brandy Boy as experienced by those on the "Growing Tomatoes - Brandy Boy Contest" thread and that of our neighbors - to which I have given starts - I realized that not everyone's growing conditions are the same as ours - even a neighbor that has a GH down the street from us! I am glad you are going to try a Brandy Boy though because I think you will love it as a slicing tomato if it likes your growing environment !! I have seen more success than failures though and those that do have success - it is usually a must have - winner! Even though you don't buy seeds from Burpee - I recommend that you do purchase Brandy Boy direct from Burpee for best opportunity for success. Please let us know how Brandy Boy performs for you in your GH !

  • 11 years ago

    The last harvest before frost. Temperatures will drop into single digits this week and stay there or colder. I decided to pull all the plants today - try some "Green Fried Tomatoes" and also try ripening some of the green ones (that haven't blushed) in newspaper - I have never tried that before.

  • 11 years ago

    Fantastic thread, and gorgeous pics of your tomatoes! You have me drooling! I have a new dome greenhouse going now. I've planted 3 different tomatoes and they are crowding everything! I've been having to prune them all back as they were covering my tropicals! I think they're really too large for my small greenhouse, but it's exciting since I haven't had fresh tomatoes in years! I've about given up on grocery store tomatoes. I'd love recommendations for tomato plants that stay much smaller!

  • 11 years ago

    Hi Karen - my challenge is that I like cherry tomatoes and slicing tomatoes (8-16 oz) and don't care for the 2-8 oz size. I thought I found the answer with New Big Dwarf because it is a Dwarf with slicing size tomatoes!! Turns out - as you may have read - NBD is not a Determinate Plant and is not small. Now I am on the search too for such a Dwarf. I am glad I discovered NBD though - it is a great variety! Thanks for your comments and let me know if you find what I am looking for! NBD is the only Dwarf I have ever planted so I am not much help to you :(

  • 11 years ago

    This year I just grabbed any tomato plant I saw. Now that I know better, I'll be looking for smaller sizes too. I have Sweet 100, Better Boy, and Red Cherry. They're all flowering and I have many tomatoes just blushing now. Meanwhile, I'm having to prune them almost daily to let the other plants have a chance! Right now I can't grow outside at all due to deer, rabbits and javelinas. If I get a fenced garden I can grow outside but I'll be fighting insects and birds and have to net them heavily. It's all a challenge, but I'll get there in time. :) I will try the NBD.

  • 10 years ago

    Are you growing them in soil? Is it potting soil or from your garden?

  • 10 years ago

    I don't have any garden soil at all. My land is all decomposed granite. They are in a custom mix of different potting soils, composts, worm castings, perlite, and more. The sweet 100 are doing well, but I'm having to hack it back almost daily. The Better Boy seems stunted, and the tomatoes aren't doing well. The Red Cherry is doing fantastic! There are so many tomatoes I've been having to thin them out to help the branches not be weighed down too much.

  • 10 years ago

    Would your wife share her fresh tomato soup recipe?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago
    • I had my greenhouse since 2004 and this is the first year I grew tomato and cucumber plants in my greenhouse. It gets to be about 107*F but they are holding strong. I have a tarp covering that part of greenhouse so there is not direct sunlight. Last week I installed a bathroom exhaust fan and wired it to an LFE digital temp controller. Goes on at 90*F and turns off at 87*F.