Software
Houzz Logo Print
catlovejoy

Replacing floors

11 years ago

We just bought a house. It's our first. We want to replace the floors throughout the house (not DIY). It would involve tearing up current floors and replacing with hardwood downstairs and carpet upstairs and porcelain tiles in 2 and 1/2 bath. We are on a budget of about $8 grand (obviously less is better as there are other things we would also like to do). The house is about 1650 sq feet. We aren't sure where to start. Best place to buy flooring from? Where do we find someone to lay the floors, install carpet. How do we find the best people. HELP!?

Comments (26)

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Hi there,

    Congrats on your first home. Important things to remember when replacing your flooring is thinking about the traffic & wear/tear the floor will endure. Hardwood will scratch, dent, and ding much easier than a laminate or luxury vinyl tile floor. If you do not have a busy household with dogs, kids, etc., or are willing to accept the sensitive characteristic of hardwood, then definitely go with a hardwood floor. With 50 years of experience, our favorite hardwood to recommend is a Mirage hardwood floor. Mirage has an excellent finish which resists scratches and dings better than any other brand's. Pricing can vary depending on the style you choose as well as the installer's labor costs. Mirage will last for many many years and look beautiful. Other brands to look into that are great quality are Kentwood (more hand scraping, textured options) or Sommerset Hardwood. Most of those are made in the US.



    ^^Both Mirage. Top installed by us, other from Mirage Website: http://www.miragefloors.com/ENG/


    Regarding installation, many flooring stores recommend certain contractors to install. As a small business, we recommend going through a local company with experience in hardwood, that way you know exactly what you're getting rather than going through a large box store.


    Good Luck and Congrats!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ask friends/coworkers family for reputable flooring stores in your area. Often, they will carry all the different types of flooring you are looking for and sometimes they have someone to help put what you want together - helping make the floors blend well in the same house. They will also arrange for measurements and installation. It is a good idea to take some of your own measurements before you go so you can get an idea of cost. This is probably the best way for you to go.

    I have a flooring installer I know, so on some floors I have purchased just the material myself and my installer puts it in - and I've also DIY a couple of bathroom floors.

    Big box stores also have installers - some have them and some give you a list to find your own. Quality can be chancy. Some do carry name brands in limited styles - I think Lowe's has Shaw Carpets and Bruce hardwood. I've gotten good floor tile there too. My pre-finished hardwood I put upstairs was from Lowe's - Bruce pre-finished oak (4.29 sq. ft. ) and I asked my installer how it was measuring up. He said it was a good floor - very few warped or damaged pieces and many long boards. However, some of the cheaper floors will have lots of warped and uneven and short boards. So don't try for as cheap as you can get.

  • 11 years ago
    While I appreciate your candor Mr. cancork, thanks for making me feel poor. :( P.s. I typoed - it was supposed to say my budget is $8-13K but we would like to get the best budget we can. We want engineered hardwood and we have friends who can do the demo if need be. Living on the floors these people left behind is not an option. It's probably about 730 sq ft which needs the wood floors and then carpet on stairs and upstairs might be 650. We can hold off on the upstairs bathrooms if we have to as their tile is in ok shape. Downstairs Powder room needs tile and laundry room needs something. Maybe I'll just get some kind on vinyl for laundry room.

    I said it was my first go at this so I'd appreciate kindness and not condescension if you can spare it. I'm actually not a moron. Thanks.
  • 11 years ago

    Seems like he was giving you some good information about various options.

  • 11 years ago
    Not sure what options you mean other than telling me I couldn't even afford his cheapest floor and that basically it's impossible. I know it's not. Positivity people. Solutions! I'm happy to get my hands dirty and all I was asking was where to start.
  • 11 years ago
    Why are you replacing hardwood? Is it stained? Water damage? All this can be overcome. You can feather new wood where hardwood has been damaged - even by fire. If it is pet stains in multiples places, sand down and stain a lovely walnut to camouflage problem areas. If you do this, I would venture you could tackle carpet upstairs and maybe even get to bathrooms. Good luck. By the way, watch HGTV's Rehab Addict to get inspired by how Nicole Curtis transforms 100 year old hardwood back to their former glory!
  • 11 years ago
    Oops... You said replacing with hardwood.... I may have misread.... What is on floors now... Sorry.
  • 11 years ago
    Hmmm Cat Lovejoy, I think you should take another look at the tone of Cancork's answer. I needed wood flooring replacement advice and to have such an informative, lenthly, and descriptive answer, I would have taken not as a dig, but as a gracious offer of information and instruction. I appreciated the breakdown explained, and it does make sense. I wish I had someone local to coach me through my reno like that!
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree with @dreacorator!

    The person at Cancork (who is a SHE, by the way) spends an inordinate amount of time and displays a commendable amount of patience here on Houzz, trying to deliver accurate, helpful & qualified information & advice.

    Keep in mind, that as Pro's, the people trying to help have NO idea of the location being discussed, unless the original poster has the forethought to include it... and this adds another set of variables... as well as a multitude of other details needed.

    To simply suggest: "hardwood flooring & carpet" is painting with a very broad brush.

  • 11 years ago

    Cancork provided a lot of useful information in their post. Bottom line is that you cannot complete the scenario you posed in your original post within the budget you provided in your original post.

  • 11 years ago

    I just copied Cancork's cost estimates and put it in my 'decorating' file. Very useful information.

  • 11 years ago
    Ok people. White flag waived. I get it. I'm sorry Ms Cancork and thank you for your time. Yesterday was a very rough day.

    Let's start over, I'm Cat. I live in Colorado. I just bought my first starter home. I need to do new floors (engineered hardwood and carpet)
    Where do I start? Should I find a product first or a contractor first? Where are good places to look for those? What are best brands of engineered hardwood and carpet? What should I avoid? Can I do this myself? My husband, brother in law and friends are handy...

    I would like to spend as little as possible while still getting good products and good install. Remember this is a starter home so it doesn't need to be super fancy but the carpet that's there now has to go.

    Thank you. Please keep comments positive in nature.
  • 11 years ago

    I would go to some hardwood stores. Look at what you WANT. Proce that out. look at tile that you WANT. Get pricing. Now, can you afford what you WANT! If not, then do not do a remodel with finishes that are not what you want. If you can afford it, then do it. Do not settle, you will not be happy.

  • 11 years ago
    I guess one thing to think about, is how urgent is replacement in each area? Are the current floors damaged, or do you simply not like them?

    I personally would prioritize the areas that really require immediate replacement, and buy the best stuff I could afford (and in keeping with the price point standard in the neighborhood) for those rooms, then wait and save for the next round...the areas where the floor is simply not my preference.

    I would advise you to be very very careful about engineered wood floors. Recently, I think it was Magada or Grover or miacometlady, not sure, who shared with us, some new laminate floors which are actually environmentally friendly and long-lasting. However, many engineered solutions are highly polluting and in my opinion, neither safe not ethical considerations.

    Research first...
  • 11 years ago
    I'd like to close this question. Does anyone know how I delete it?
  • 11 years ago
    Compare the advantages of hardwood verses engineered wood floors. Go to a local flooring selection store, most will have both types of wood (as well as carpet & tile) and many offer installation too. Depending on your subfloor hardwood or engineered may be your best solution. Engineered is often a higher cost than solid wood. By the way, I just installed carpet in about 1500 SF & paid about $6k with tear out, furniture moving, disposal, carpet & install. I did not get my first choice to stay in that budget amount.
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Cat... and welcome to Houzz.

    1st of all, in my most humble opinion, I think I'd recommend putting more emphasis your the choice in wood flooring.

    NOT because it's what I do, rather... because it's what I do.

    I'm rarely a proponent of letting price be the driving force in the buying process, however, when dealing with a tight budget, I think you'll want to weigh the differences.

    Most folks will tend to lean toward low pricing across the board, whereas it may be more prudent to consider the fact that the hardwood flooring will be "in for the duration" (hopefully), whereas carpet is easier to change out (beside the fact that it's more likely to show wear & tear or go out of style quicker).

    I'd recommend looking for an engineered hardwood with a heavier face/top layer (4-5mm) vs. the low-priced rotary/peeled veneer (1-2mm) variety which many people are convinced are "just as good, you only see the top anyway".

    But that's not really true.

    Full disclosure: being a supporter of the "Made in America" concept, I tend to recommend against the low end imports for a variety of reasons (aside from patriotism).

    Depending on your lifestyle, you may want to consider a specie and finish type such as distressed, hand-scraped, smooth, etc., that will accommodate the rest of your décor and durability needs.

    I'm confident you'll hear more from Ms. Cancork (Stephanie).

    Sorry to be so "wordy"...

    (there's a disturbed old man in Ohio that it seems to bother... haha)

  • 11 years ago
    Cat, I think once we post a dilemma, it becomes the intellectual property of Houzz community, and we cannot delete the thread. We can, however (except for some reason on tablets), edit our own posts.
  • 11 years ago
    Thanks select hardwood and mrstem. Great advice!! And I am on an iPad so that's why I can't edit!! Sweet. Will try on computer later. Ok go for thicker top layer and hand scraping. Trying to reform my budget and with some creative rearranging I might have more like 15 K. It's being borrowed and paid back to a family member.

    Anyone know how installing hardwood will affect my homeowners Insurance rate?? How much will it go up?
  • 11 years ago
    I don't think unless you have a great increase in the insured value of your home, that your insurance goes up because of decor changes.
  • 11 years ago

    No one intended to hurt your feelings so please don't take offense. HGTV and The DIY Network are nothing more than glorified reality TV that distort the truth. There is a reason you didn't see tile and hardwood in 'regular' homes until recently as it's very expensive.

    I live in a 1350 sq ft older home and my husband is an avid DIYer so when we had a water leak from our ice maker that ruined part of our floor, my husband decided we'd tile the whole related area including the dining room, pantry, laundry area, coat closet and adjoining hallway that has 7 walls in it. We figured it would be cheap as we as the tile was only about $2 sq ft. We didn't think about the cost of hauling away the two layers of flooring we pulled up, the cement board and screws for the subfloor, the hundreds of pounds of thinset to lay it along with the grout. And because we [he] did it ourselves, we had to buy all the related saws and tiling tools so that added several hundred dollars to the cost. By the time it was done, I estimate it cost us at least $4,000.00.

    We just put down 3/4" hardwood in our living room and again, my husband did it. We got the hardwood [Mohawk white oak] on sale for about $7.50 sq ft. We put down 1/4" plywood for a subfloor and a vapor barrier for a total of another $1 sq ft. The tools [2 flooring nailers and one finish nailer] added another $3 sq ft to our cost bring it to about $11.50 sq ft, and that was with doing it ourselves!!

    Instead of taking offense at finding out that you can't do all you want, start by replacing the flooring that is the worst. From there, save for doing the other floors as you can afford it. And if you're at all handy [or your husband is], learning to do it yourself is worth it. My husband has taught himself all this, and he's done as good a job as anyone we could have hired.

  • 11 years ago

    First, what is the existing flooring? What condition is it in? What's your foundation type? You can find some decent just above builder grade carpet, installed for around $3 a foot. Hw many feet of carpet do you need? You can subtract that rough amount from your budget, and it can increase the budget for the wood. I've used Bruce Frontier Hickory in several projects, and it can be done for $5 a square, installed, in my area. None of those prices include any demolition, or tresholds, or all of the little thngs lie moving furniture, that raise the cost of the job. If you can do the demo yourselves, that can be a budget saver. If you can paint and install the quarter round later, that can help the budget as well. What else can you DIY? Well, how handy are you? What tools do you already own? How dirt and sweaty are you willing to get?

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    See there Cat... you've got help falling out of the sky like raindrops (everywhere except here in CA).

  • 11 years ago
    I'm going to get this done. I know it's possible and we can make it happen. Thanks for the mixture of advice.

    I've found great Mohawk flooring through a connection for $4.50/sq foot. I've also found some Shaw dark oak floors for $3.69/sq foot. I have several people coming to do estimates for me on Tuesday all of whom have said it's totally doable in my budget. So you can all forget about me. Thanks
  • 11 years ago
    No one is going to forget about you Cat. Congratulations on your finds, and best wishes!