Software
Houzz Logo Print
volcoff

blue spruce in container

11 years ago


We bought this blue spruce for the holidays. Unfortunately, perhaps from being inside, a few branches died, but now it appears to be doing better and has some new growth.


It is now outside on a southwest facing balcony. It'd like to pot it in a larger container. Any advice on the size container (either the smaller or larger red one; the white one with stripes is now taken)?


Also, any advice on types of mix? Most of my indoor plants are in some version of 1/3rd pine bark, black lava rock, pumice, turface, or granigrit. I've seen in these forums that others have had success with conifers by mixing some soil conditioner and miracle grow potting mix into this. My concern is that pure gritty mix might be too dry in the hot summer? (zone 7a/7b). Should I still pot now even with new growth (there is even more now than in the picture)?


Thanks!



Comments (17)

  • 11 years ago

    I've seen in these forums that others have had success with conifers
    by mixing some soil conditioner and miracle grow potting mix into this.

    ==>>> i highly doubt that ... and i have been here forever ...

    use the GW search engine.. generally to find the million posts on al's gritty mix.. and decide if your formula is close to it ...

    i would be more concerned if your balcony is in full sun.. rather than heat ...

    be nice to know where you are ...

    personally .. i would up pot to a plastic pot.. and set it in yoru fancy pot ... it gives you much more flexibility ... and you can fill around such.. with some lose bark .. a way of insulating the plastic pot from the heat ..

    ken


  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the response.

    I was referring to NovaPlantGuy's post regarding his mix, which includes a small amount of soil conditioner and miracle grow. http://forums.gardenweb.com/discussions/1893274/conifers-in-containers-my-small-collection-share-yours-too?n=41

    I'm in northern virginia. I'm pretty familiar with the gritty mix, but was wondering if a formula with turface MVP, pine bark, and pumice (1/3rd each) might be too dry for outside (all my plants in this mix are currently inside). The balcony faces southwest and gets about 6-7 hours of full sun.

    Thanks for the plastic pot suggestion. Would it lose more heat if it were outside in a plastic pot alone vs. clay or ceramic alone? what flexibility am I gaining by having the plastic pot within the larger one?

    Thanks again

  • 11 years ago

    I grow primarily in containers, including all my dwarf conifers and Japanese maples. The gritty mix is ideal but you do need to pay attention to the watering. It is of far more benefit to the plant to have a durable, fast draining medium such as the gritty mix provides than to try and shortcut your watering routine with a slower draining, more water retentive mix.

  • 11 years ago

    What Pam just said ...........

    It makes no sense to buy ingredients specifically for their larger size and ability to hold air and reduce/eliminate perched water, then wreck their potential by adding enough fine ingredients to clog all the large air pores and invite a perched water table to take up residence. You might as well save the expense and effort and just grow in whatever potting soil is conveniently available. If you want something that offers your plants better opportunity to realize their genetic potential, why not make the effort to get all you can from what a soil has to offer?

    I'd tease some of the roots away from the root mass and pot up for this year (too late to repot). Next year, before buds open, I would remove MOST of the soil, fix any root issues (encircling, girdling, j-hooked, growing back into the center of the root mass) and repot into an appropriate mix. The gritty mix would work well. If you repot using a soil that supports perched water, you need to be considerate of root volume: soil volume so you don't over-pot. If you use the gritty mix or any other combination of ingredients that doesn't hold perched water, you can use a container as large as you like.


    Al


  • 11 years ago

    When it comes time to repot from one of those clay pots to a larger one, it looks like it might be difficult. The top is narrower than the middle. It won't just slide out.
    mike


  • 11 years ago

    Good point. I just broke a small white porcelain pot today for the reason you point to (expensive bugger it was, too) because the plant was valuable to me. The plant was a succulent and too delicate to just dig out of the pot. In this case, I think it represents more of a pain (like you said) than a danger to the viability of the plant after it's removed.

    Al

  • 11 years ago

    The top is narrower than the middle. It won't just slide out.

    ==>> one reason to do pot in pot ...

    anyway ... keep in mind ... this is a tree .. it will NOT want to stay sodden.. like your typical annual/perennial ... on some level ... they like a sip of water.. then near total drainage ....

    i have grown some trees.. in pots.. in full shade in wood chips .. i dont recommend it ... but that gives an idea of how much drainage they like ...

    growing a tree.. with hundred foot potential.. on a balcony ... well ... you are going to have to kinda wing it.. take all the info ... and do the best you can ...

    you might try to find experts on roof top gardening ...

    i think there is also a container gardening forum .. maybe you will find someone over there.. that doesnt hang in this forum ...

    man ... al pops in everywhere the mix is noted .. lol ... its like magic ... lol

    ken


  • 11 years ago

    This thread was also posted on 'Containers' where the OP noted it was posted here, so I thought I'd comment here as well.

    Al

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Al for your comments at both sites, as well as for everyone else's input.

    Just to clarify, when you say pot up, you are referring to placing it in a larger pot but without really disturbing much of the root mass. I assume I would use the same non-ideal draining soil/miracle grow that it currently came in for this? Whereas repotting would involve the actual near bare rooting of the tree and transitioning to gritty mix.

    Would the disadvantage of repotting now only mean decreased/arrest in growth that would resume at some later point in the summer? Wouldn't that specific disadvantage be outweighted by the benefits of being in a well-draining soil for the next year?

  • 11 years ago

    Ok, for the excess water retention part, do you mean placing a wick to help drain any excess water? Anything else other than that?

  • 11 years ago

    Dealing with excess water retention isn't going to be as effective as avoiding it altogether, but you can read up on various tricks that can help you deal with excess water retention at this link.

    Note how much excess water can be removed from pots by adding ballast and/or tipping the pot, in addition to using a wick (see B, D, and E):

    Al

  • 11 years ago

    I don't know what blue spruce it is, but observing the new needle growth I can tell it should a a fast grower and very soon, in a year(?), you need to put it in the ground or you will have a root-bound problem regardless what media you use.

  • 11 years ago

    That's painting with a brush that's much too broad. With proper root maintenance and top pruning, there is no reason the plant can't be kept viable and very happy in a small container for generations.


    Al

  • 11 years ago

    That's where root pruning comes in. You can keep an even very large growing tree in a container indefinitely as long as you pay attention to the media and root prune when necessary. I grow ALL my conifers in containers :-) Well, almost all - I just planted some Microbiotas.


  • 11 years ago

    Beatcha by 2 minutes!!


    Al

  • 11 years ago

    LOL!! You go, Al!!