I agree... middle color looks the best. The top color is too dark and would blend in too much with the stone, and the bottom color is too carmel-y colored.

Middle!

If you have a lot of shade on the house the middle colour, go with the darker if you have a lot of sun.

Spring Meadows Spec 2012 · More Info

I too, vote for the middle color.

I like the top color.

I would choose the middle color. It will make the roof line pop and accentuate the beautiful rockwork too.

We were leaning toward the dark one until the stone went up. I do like the middle one but it has green tint to it.

This is the dark one closer to the stone.

Do the dark one and use the middle one for hardie shakes on the gables.

@kellykins1 - the darkest, which is called Timberbark, is the top one of the three colors. It's also the one color that is alone on the left of the the three colors.

I really like the Timberbark siding and am leaning toward that one, which is the darkest. I'm thinking of doing Sherwin Williams Cremy color for the trim. The middle one is monterey taupe, which definitely has a green tone to it.

Elegant Story & a half · More Info

Did you try the home colour tool on the website for James Hardie?

http://www.jameshardie.com/Design-Ideas/Home-Color-Tool

This photo is Timberbark siding colour and trim is Benjamin Moore Ivory Porcelain 239, roof is Landmark Weathered Wood.

If you put James Hardie or bucks county country ledgestone in as a search in Houzz, lots of home photos are available.