Software
Houzz Logo Print
shannon_moloney

HOUZZERS! BEWARE PAINT TREND INTOXICATION...

11 years ago
Thought I'd share my experience and give a little advice...to anyone who, like me, spends a lot of time ooohing and aaahing over the fabulous pictures on Houzz. I was inspired to paint my bathroom and bedroom gray, the new neutral (sound drumroll and symbols). I researched a lot of photos. I read articles about light, intensity, sheen, saturation, and wall preparation. I tested colors on all four walls of each roomand the ceilings. I chose two shades of gray. I bought 6 gallons of premium paint and went at it.

Well, guess what? I didn't like it. it looked awful, in fact, particularly the bathroom, which looked like a purple grape explosion. I repainted, swapping the colors between the two rooms. And still didn't like it. The bathroom looks purple, the bedroom looks too shiny. I decided to live with it for a couple weeks and see if it grew on me. It didn't. today I resolved to scrap the gray experiment and start all over.

Moral: choose what appeals to your eye when you are at the paint store, not what looks great in professional photos!

My eye is not drawn to gray (or purple, either). When I looked at the colors on the display, my eye was drawn to pale green-grays and aquas, and shades of mid tone blue. This time, I'm not buying test paint. I'm not over thinking it. I bought the colors I liked the most. And I asked the paint guy to tint the old gray paint as dark a bluish-gray as he could achieve, and I'm going to use it on the trim. I'll let you know how it turns out! I'll be using Sea Spray in eggshell on my stairwell and hallway. Montpelier Wedgewood in eggshell in the bathroom. Jekyll blue in satin for my previously stripped-shabby-chic Lenox French provincial bedroom furniture and for the window seat in the bathroom. the bath rug also shows the color of the floor tiles...it has stripes of a taupe-y tan that coincidentally matches the floor tiles, which I'm doing my best to minimize!

Comments (21)

  • 11 years ago

    Paint colors vary due to the light in in your home (natural & artificial) and other factors. Here is a link on the correct way to choose a wall paint. Many people think this is the best method: http://www.lindaholtinteriors.com/2011/07/testing-wall-color-101/

  • 11 years ago

    @Arizona ... I feel your pain! lol I like to say "I'm not color blind... I'm color stupid" ... so you can IMAGINE the troubles I have too! Hope you love your new choices! gl

  • 11 years ago
    Ugh! I am right there with you. I spent three months, 100s of paint chips, and 11 paint samples before I decided on a color for my kitchen.....and I hate it! I was trying not to pick one of my "go to" colors. Apparently, I like what I like.
    Thanks for speaking the truth! Hope it all turns out beautifully for you in the end!
  • 11 years ago
    @Tan, thanks for the suggestion but I did that the first time. I'm better off going with instinct.
  • 11 years ago
    So true! I had a similar experience recently. I wanted to branch out from my go-to colors, so I experimented with painting my dining room a peachy pink color. I bought about six samples, tested them on the walls, and convinced myself to go for one of them. I felt like I was living in a Barbie, Pepto-pink world. That color lasted one week. I repainted the room in a blue-green-grey, and I love it. I guess it was worth it to teach myself the lesson, but there's no point in forcing yourself to use a color you don't typically like or decorate with.
  • 11 years ago
    I think you said younare painting your new bathroom and bedroom. Are you moving into a new home? Are you purchasing new furnishings or do you have furniture? Paint is usually the last thing to choose when redoing a room. It is much easier to find a paint color you like, rather than exchanging furniture.
    May I suggest a professional color expert to come to your home to suggest colors. For a few hundred bucks, it will be well worth you while.
    Paint is expensive and it is so nice to have an expert to save you tons of time and money!
  • 11 years ago
    Sorry, one more comment. I find it very strange, all of the questions about paint color on this site.
    Of course you can't choose paint colors from a photo posted online.
    Paint looks different according to how much light the room receives.
    Also you must consider your furnishings, and what time of day you will be using the room. Will the room be used primarily at night with the drapery closed or will it be used in the daytime with tons of natural light?
  • 11 years ago

    I've used the method described by @tancalgal several times now, and have not had a fail yet. Before using that method, I'd go through 3 or 4 colors in a room before getting it right.

  • 11 years ago
    I'm not buying new furniture. I love my furniture and it goes well with the vibe of this house. I just want a change from the stripped-down ala shabby chic look I had. The beauty of good quality, older case furniture is I can do that as often as the mood strikes, and freshen the look when I feel like it.
  • 11 years ago

    Sometimes you have to go with your gut. People paint and repaint at all different stages of the design process. I have clients who set out to redecorate an entire space, and the paint color is chosen in tandem with the new fabrics and furnishings. Other clients just want to refresh their rooms with a new paint color while leaving everything else the same. And not every client can make a decision based on the method of painting sample swatches.


    Looking at pictures online is a great way to get inspired by colors, but obviously you can't go by what you see on the screen. Take a look at the comments on this photo: https://www.houzz.com/photos/farmhouse-reinterpreted-farmhouse-kitchen-burlington-phvw-vp~107140 If you flip through the Ben Moore fan deck to look up the colors, you'll see that they differ greatly from how they appear in the photo. That being said, the photo could inspire a paint color selection all the same.

  • 11 years ago

    I agree, Kate. Choosing paint colors is a challenge for many, that's why color consultants, color experts, and college classes on color theory exist in the first place. Houzz and professional designers are great for inspiration and ideas, but ultimately, it is our choice, whether we follow a trend blindly or we go by gut, or if we use any other method.

  • 11 years ago
    I have learned a few things, though...if choosing whites, grays, or yellows, I would next time call in the color consultant. Blues and aquas seem much more forgiving!
  • 11 years ago

    I"ve just lived with gray for a few years. Walked into the local Farrow and Ball dealer. Was immediately and excitedly informed that "gray is the new neutral*. Maybe I'll go with blues too. Ceiling and floors are white, so a light color will get washed out. I'd love to hear some thoughts on some mid-tone neutrals that won't look dated. Or read as gray. Any thoughts?

  • 11 years ago

    courtinghome-

    how about starting your own post with this question? What color walls will enhance your rug? your furniture? IDK about F&B, I thought gray was about due to be on the way out...

  • 11 years ago

    Good point, I will with a few photos.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    courtinghome: put the link to the new post here & then we will all be sure to see it. :)

  • 11 years ago

    I love the Sea spray color and wish I could use that in my remodeled master bath...But our bath and home for that matter has more of the warm tones and so it always seems like it ends up looking best with one of the tan colors for paint....which does get boring sometimes! So like your refreshing choices...


  • 9 years ago

    I had the exact same thing happen to me. I thought I was matching the gray in the fabric of our duvet cover, but the painter called me after he had one wall done and told me I had better come and look at it. It was definitely purple. He told me that it " looked like the inside of a french whorehouse". He was right. Feeling less confident, I showed him what I was trying to get and let HIM pick the paint. He was very good. He gave me exactly what I was looking for. Sometimes, I think it pays to take advantage of someone with a trained eye. I have been happy with almost all of my other paint selections since then, but I learned from that that what you THINK you see is not always what you get.

  • 9 years ago
    I have used an interior designer color specialist many times, with much success. It's funny how many times we would start painting with the color she suggested, and I would think"oh no...I hate this, it's awful". But after we were done, and the decor was up, I absolutely loved it. She can see undertones that I have no ability to see and has a natural talent for knowing what colors will enhance/coordinate with the room. For example, sHe recommended a gray that she knew would look blue on our breakfast nook and it does, looks perfect. She recommends ceiling colors, too, that I never in a million years would think of. She comes over for an hour, and while there, gives us specific recommendations, with SW paint names and numbers. She will walk through my whole house, giving advice, till the hour is over! She did magic on my friends house, also. Definitely worth it!