Software
Houzz Logo Print
cadillactaste

Gun shy with maples...

11 years ago

Zone 5 , NE Ohio area...


We had a ryusen maple for a few years...lost all but a foot to winter damage/dieback winter 2013-14. Replaced with another and offered burlap protection the following winter...and it died back the same way. Now my husband is pondering placing a cold frame around one and offering protection all around instead of leaving the top open as suggested by the nursery with the burlap...using a thick black plastic. (But I read one should use white)

Is there any weeping variety that seem cold hardier? I know in my neighbors yard (previous owner planted) has a small red leafed maple unknown variety...wintered the past two winters without protection...is there a weeping form with the red leaves that might be hardier than the ryusen?

Does anyone feel a cold frame could work? I honestly don't wish to lose three maples back to back consecutive years.


Comments (16)

  • 11 years ago

    If you are on the University of British Columbia Botanical Garden message board there is a member over there (JT1) that has 60+ maples in his collection. He is from NE Ohio as well. He could probably offer some advice on what trees do well in your area.

    cadillactaste thanked bub72ck
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks! I'm not...but, might pay to become one. Thanks!


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Have you tried a weeping Acer shirasawanum or Acer Japonicum cultivar? They're more hardy, but have a very similar leaf shape to Acer palmatum cultivars. You might also want to try the Davidsan's app so you can pick the characteristics you want along with your cold temps.

    http://www.davidsansjapanesemaples.com/japanese-maple-tree-selector/

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I checked Ryusen on Dave's Garden, which can often give an indication if a JM is more of a zone 6 or zone 5 maple (though sometimes I've found it to be wrong). Ryusen is listed there as zone 6.

    If you're looking for a successful red laceleaf weeper, I've read in multiple places that Tamukeyama is one of the most cold hardy. I live in a 5b zone with a 5a zone just a few miles inland, and common survivors are Tamukeyama and Crimson Queen. We've had some killer winters the past two years and those two cultivars are still thriving in 5a areas.

    http://davesgarden.com/guides/pf/go/165646/

    As for a cold frame-- if you're worried about a maple, I would probably give it some burlap protection for its first few years in a spot. After that it should be more hardy. Do you have your maples in an especially open area where they're getting cold winds? Perhaps you could find another, more protected, area on your property to see if you can get a touchy JM to thrive. Otherwise I'd go for a hardier cultivar or a shira/japonicum cultivar.

    Good luck!

  • 11 years ago

    No matter what we plant...it will receive burlap protection...these strange cold arctic temps that move in...one just can't be to careful.

    I appreciate the two names of the maples you feel might do well. They both are lovely. I wouldn't mind one in the yard. So maybe I can take a leap and go with one of those mentioned and feel more at ease...than replacing with a third ryusen which had me quite uneasy.

    The nursery lady did say that she noticed the classification for ryusen is now being marked a zone 6. When it used to be a zone 5. Curious if ones losing the majority of the tree to winter damage...had them reclassified.

    Again...so appreciate the information you shared Magpiepix! You have given me a bit of hope. I will contact my nursery and see if they can get me one in. If not...then I will find one at another nursery.


  • 11 years ago

    http://www.davidsansjapanesemaples.com/shop/product/green_cascade/

    Want a hardy dissectum type that is not a palmatum that will grow anywhere and you never have to worry about late freezes and frosts damaging it. Then this Japonicum is for YOU...never worry about this one succumbing to a late frost ... it's all around color is great and can take some sun and wind . In fall it’s a knockout. It does get big though and is a fast grower. This is among the best most reliable weeping Japonicum and very easy to grow!! It gets wider than tall. so not for skinny siting.

    This I found on that link...sounds promising.

  • 11 years ago

    It's one I've considered-- if you do a google image search for it, the photos are outstanding. I think the leaf has a very, very unique shape to it, and the way the tree layers its leaves makes it unique as well.


    I've also always been curious about Green Snowflake, and nearly ordered it for my garden.


    ...maybe you need two? ;)

  • 11 years ago

    Lol my husband spoke of my having my lavender twist and his maple in that area...not sure I'm ready for two maples. Lol though...you never know.

  • 11 years ago

    Well...I went to the nursery and fell in love with a Tamukeyama. Not the small tree we has wanted for that area. But...if I forgo the Lavender Twist and put it in it's place...it can get taller than the smaller height we were after. But, I doubt I let it reach 10' tall. I'll most likely prune off leaders that grow to weep and add additional height, but it will be allowed to get taller than we originally planned for the maple. I loved it's "bones"...(The nursery lady said since I know bonsai and pruning...I shouldn't have any trouble understanding what to do when I decide I like it's eventual desired height.) Now, to decide exactly where it will be set in the ground.


    I do appreciate the advice...just hearing from you helped me decide I love maples...and I can find one more hardy for our area.


  • 11 years ago

    In the ground and LOVIN' IT!!!


  • 11 years ago

    I'm happy for you! It looks great, and Tamukeyama is a wonderful cultivar. I have mine in full shade, where it's a really smokey green/red, and even then I love it.

    So.... what's next? ;)


  • 11 years ago

    Thanks! What's next...finding something small to fill the void where that Ryusen once stood. I currently have a lilac (still in nursery pot) that I plan on eventually turning into a bonsai. So I stuck it there. Thinking to dig the hole to hold the pot and cover with hardscape until after the graduation party. It won't thrive there...with being in the drip line of the walnut tree. But...keeps the area from looking totally bare. It will allow me to find so,etching appropriate for the area.


    My husband was thrilled with this tree. Seems the client he's building an addition for has one in their landscape. He teased her she could give it to him. So he's excited to go to work today to tell her that his wife brought one home from the nursery. :) Seeing it's quite hardy. Some say they are a zone 4 and have had this for 6 years through the winter. So...I am hopeful that it will handle the Arctic air when it blows through...but, I still plan on offering this burlap protection.

  • 11 years ago

    Question: I am assuming that left side of my tree will grow out and hoping it has a wider arch to the weeping branch. Am I on the right thought process? My husband wants the to wire/tie it down so it weeps more. But, I would imagine it should do it naturally.

  • 11 years ago

    Tamukeyama grows rapidly when it's young, so yes-- it will weep more, and probably within the next season or two. Mine put on well over a foot of growth this year.


  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Magpiepix! Good to know...I thought so, but then was second guessing myself.

Sponsored
NME Builders LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Remodeling Company in New Albany, Ohio