Software
Houzz Logo Print
minisoda

Selecting exterior color / materials

11 years ago

We are meeting with the builders designer this week to pick out exterior colors/material. We are doing LP lap/shakes that will be painted onsite and stone. It is REALLY tough to visualize how it will look on the house (even with 3D renderings we paid for).

We're doing a lot of driving around to find inspiration houses that we could copy colors on. Take a look at this house and let me know what you all think of the creme trim vs. straight white on the exterior. We love the slate color and just need to figure out white or creme on the trim. ALSO, need to figure out what color the primary paint is..... so if you have any thoughts there please advise!



Comments (27)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My personal preference is white trim but on a house that dark, it might look really stark so in this case, cream was probably better. That particular trim looks a little yellow and the siding looks green. That might just be my monitor. I have a slate color on my house. I'll try to find a pic and post it on here. MFatt, a member who just built a house, used a very similar color with her stone. That would be in the "how's your build" threads from late last year I think. Do you know what kind of stone yet?

    Edit to include pic (SW solid stain color matched to Home Depot's Thunderstorm Gray stain):

  • 11 years ago

    For a Modern home yours looks very nicely designed. I would avoid Modern sensibilities in choosing colours because your home doesn't need the clichés to be attractive. White trim = PVC trim; therefore, it's never a good choice. Traditionally, trim was often a lighter shade of the main colour. And the main colour would come from Autumn leaf colours, forest colours, or a frequent colour found in the stonework foundation.

  • 11 years ago

    I wouldn't do a stark white. Do you know what brand of paint you'll be using? I could check my color swatches for you if I knew if it's SW or BM. If it's another brand I can't help you. :)

  • 11 years ago

    White trim on our house is not PVC and we saw no PVC trim for sale anywhere. If so, I would have bought to keep from having to paint.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks all... to be clear, the photos above are an "inspiration home" that we're possibly thinking about duplicating colors on. I will find out what brand paint they use and report back ASAP.

    Here is a rendering of our home that's currently under construction. Current color is modeled after Hardie Iron Gray and probably a bit too dark. If you hate the design, no need to share. Foundation is poured and that ship has sailed!

    Also, thinking about stained garage doors, planters, corbels and gable details (instead of painting). Any thoughts on how that would flow? Seems a bit risky, but could be awesome if we pull off the right color scheme!

    Interior design style will be transitional... elegant traditional with a touch of modern.




  • 11 years ago

    Here you go. I like the changes you're thinking of.


  • 11 years ago

    We are doing a dark blue/gray house as well, and I think both white and cream can look beautiful as a trim color. We've tried Restful White & Westhighland White from SW and liked those (lots of warm yellowy undertones that mellowed out in the sunlight)… and Cloud White or Cotton Balls from BM read more "white" but are still not too stark. I think it's more important to match the actual window color (unless you are doing a contrasting, darker tone). I think bright white windows and cream trim around them look a little funny, so we are likely just going to color match the window color exactly. I think you have more choices if you are doing wood windows… but vinyl window companies are expanding their color ranges too.


    My guess on the body color would be something similar to Benjamin Moore Midnight Blue (which has a lot of gray in it) or possibly a Lead Gray or Gentleman's Gray if you are seeing that green undertone that my screen is showing. The Hardie Iron Gray has a lot more brown in it than the inspiration picture on my screen. I think they all would look marvelous on your home.

  • 11 years ago

    Great feedback! I did notice in the first inspiration photos that the windows were white and didn't match the cream trim. I don't believe the Andersen 200 mine has many color options but I will check.


    Really appreciate the SW and BM colors you mentioned. Will bring this to the designer tomorrow.


    Still really struggling with whether we should convert some of the accent pieces and maybe even porch columns to stained cedar.

  • 11 years ago

    Cpartist - thanks! I don't think we will go quite that blue and maybe a darker stain would work better than the medium tone....

  • 11 years ago

    Grey with white is classic. I would not pick cream just a warmer shade of white.

  • 11 years ago

    HELP! We had settled on the colors above, and now DW isn't so sure about the "dreary gray" and wants something with more brown/tan tones for the main color. This is one of those points in the process that we are not in agreement. I think the current color for siding, stone, roof and doors will work really well.

    Anyone been through a similar discussion on tans/browns vs. slates/grays? For what it's worth, framing is cooking along. Here is a shot from this morning.

    If you scroll up a ways in the thread, you will see a computer rendering.

    As always, really appreciate the feedback!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Royal Oaks Design, Inc. · More Info

    This one isn't too bad... of course, we're doing LP and not stained shakes, so I'm not sure if we could retain the rich look that this one has.

    Also, still need HELP! so please see post above this one.

  • 11 years ago

    Why is DW set on browns and tans? The blues are so much more interesting with your home style. Personally I don't like the browns at all.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hmmm, we ended up using a taupe colour for our main body colour. There is also red brick and grey trim on our house. It looks okay together, but I do wish we had put in more grey and less of the taupe. I was worried about the grey looking dreary. Now, when I drive arround or see houses on this site, I always think the grey is great and wish we had gone with grey for the main body colour. Your colour samples look terrific. I would stick with your initial plan.

  • 11 years ago

    Your initial samples are beautiful and much more interesting. Stick with the blue/grey.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the feedback... will do my best to convince her this is the way to go.

  • 11 years ago

    Fiddling around with some colors on the Sherwin Williams website, and I'm coming around on some of the brown tones. Check this out with Chateau Brown for the siding and an attempt to "paint" a lighter stone.

    Goes from a cottage to a little more "lodge" feel, which I'm good with... my "photoshop" skills are pretty rough, but gives an idea.... Thoughts?


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I still like the grey/blue better. As per the grey/blue option, is the roof to be black? That might be a bit dark with the dark grey siding. On the August building thread, there was some discussion on roofing colour choices. At least one person stated that when the siding is very dark, you don't want a very dark roof too (although a very light roof is not optimal either). What about a charcoal grey roof rather than the black shown in your original sample colours.

    Carol

    Oops corrected the word blue for black above -- correction in italics

  • 11 years ago

  • 11 years ago

    The dark paint color above has a distinct purple undertone on my screen.

  • 11 years ago

    I still prefer the blue. The brown goes on a lodge home yes, but your home doesn't read as lodge.

  • 11 years ago

    Have you used the color snap app from sherwin williams? It might be fun to take a picture of your stone and have the app pull paint colors from it for you.

  • 11 years ago

    That color snap app is life changing! Seriously, so awesome.

  • 11 years ago

    If you weren't already planning to do so, I also advise that you don't make a final final decision without getting a few of the color to go sample pints and put your top 2-3 on different sides of the house to see how they react in different light and relate to the stone. Colors can read so differently from a distance than up close.

    Ask the SW person about a coupon. I was able to use a few buy one get one free coupons for the sample pints when I was in the crazy making stage of exterior paint selection. I'm pretty sure the coupons were good through 8/31.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, actually the contractor does that. They bring out samples of our top selections and paint a section to see how it all fits before we make our final call. However, shingles will already be installed and stone is already ordered.

  • 4 years ago

    I see this is an old conversation, but what color did you choose!? We are considering Grizzle Gray, and I was hoping to see it on an exterior. We are also using LP Smartside shake siding.