I suggest no shutters at all. Shutters, even decorative ones, should be wide enough to cover the window when closed. On several of the windows, there's no space.

Stick with black.

No Shutters, No Clutter. But if you want them, then stick with the black, but you do need some more landscaping, perhaps some larger shrubs in different shades of green. Stick to evergreens as they are beautiful all year round.
Consider a planter, large one or two for either side of your door.

Perhaps your door would be better in a contrasting color.. a fantastic shade of red or green.

Trees? Would add a nice softness to your front yard.

Posting pics of the Egbert Street Front...very different than yours, but you'll get the idea of how WOW good landscaping can make your home.

Warm Regards,

Karen & Joseph

for Decorative Philosophy

PS you'll note we only have shutters on the upper window....