Software
Houzz Logo Print
iowariver

Identify cotton ball insect?

11 years ago

My garden this year is infused with small 1/8th inch insects with a bright white cotton-like ball on their backs. They seem harmless and are sometimes so dense it looks like snowflakes. A little research suggests they might be a larval stage of the Lacewing, which would be good. Included is my poor photo of one and one similar from Google Images. My bugs seem to have black legs and head, however, and no garbage attached to the cotton part. Thoughts appreciated.


Comments (10)

  • 11 years ago

    Green lacewing larvae as pictured in your first image, are very distintive. I suspect that you have woolly aphids or adelgids or something else entirely.


  • 11 years ago

    I think you're right. Have looked at at photos of woolly aphids and that's them. It is said that they especially occur where apples and some other fruiting trees are in close proximity. They seem to only hurt small fruit trees. Put in two Golden Delicious this year. We have no other apples except many crab apples. I assume that is sufficient for attracting the aphids. And yes, the neighbor has a tall, sick elm on the border of our property.

    Since I'd like to remain organic, would you or anyone suggest a predator, such as ladybugs? The spiders seem to be doing a good job, as I see many caught in their webs.

  • 11 years ago

    I'm not a believer in bringing in ladybugs from an outside source. If you have a bunch of the pests, I'd consider insecticidal soap applied directly to the insects. See if they've infested the fruit trees.

    Commercial insecticidal soap is considered organic. The least you do, the more likely it is that beneficials will help out. That white fuzz protects these little creatures, though. Sometimes the insecticidal soap is called for.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the reply. The woolly aphids seem to have almost gone away. Maybe its just a seasonal phenomena. Could you tell me why you're not in favor of bringing in ladybugs from an outside source? I assume it is concern about introducing disease. We used to have tons of them, but in recent years have seen next to none. There is no concentrated accumulation of the woolly aphids yet, so the spraying of insecticidal soap would have to be widespread, presumably harming other beneficial insects, like spiders, etc. Will not go on and on about this thread. Thanks!

  • 11 years ago

    Much of the stock of purchased ladybugs are Asian imports, which have been pushing our native species out and have become something of a household annoyance.

    Wild harvesting of ladybugs can be damaging to the environment and native species. There are farm raised sources, but I think that they tend to be quite a bit more expensive.

    Introduced ladybugs are very likely to take off for parts unknown upon release. If you have a large property, the more likely you are to see any benefit.

    Yes about the woolly aphid issue being cyclical. I agree that it's the better choice to do nothing at this point.

    You might want to consider a dormant season spray with a good horticultural oil. Oil applications can smother overwintering eggs.....a task much approved of amongst organic growers.


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    This is not a wooly aphid. Wooly aphids look different and have wings.

  • 7 years ago

    Ah, I see, Rhizo. I also misunderstood where this thread was headed. Thought you were indicating that the larva pictured was a wooly aphid. (Definitely not based on the head of the critter pictured ... those are the mandibles of a predator. And lacewing would also have been my guess based on those.)

  • 7 years ago

    This thread originated in 2015.

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County