Software
Houzz Logo Print
kjd_0214

Inspector liable?

11 years ago

We hired an inspector to inspect our house before we bought it. Nothing major came from the inspection. We purchased the house and the day after we took posetion our 5 year old noticed a softball size hole in the soffit of the year of he house. This is not the soffit from the roofline but from the main floo. This is a raised ranch so its about 4-5 feet off the ground. Once our 5 year came and got me it was very obvious that he soffit was really rotted out. We contacted the inspecter and he came out to look at it. Agreed there was some rotting and sent his handy man the next day to gete a quote. Handy man agreed there was rotting but along the whole rear of the house, about 46 feet worth. He also noticed the deck was pulling away from the house due to the rotting. We have been going back and forth with the inspecter and he Has stood us up several times to o me out with our own handyman since his didnt want to quote the job out. Finally after a month he told s he would ive s $900 but th quote we recieved to repair the damage was $4k. Deck needs to be torn down and the the whole soffit needs to repaired and then the deck needs to be rebuilt. Can we sue the inspector? Do we have a chance to win. We are in illinois.

Comments (11)

  • 11 years ago

    Did your lender require a termite clearance? Not that you have termites but this is what such inspections cover. Or is this a general purpose building inspector?

  • 11 years ago

    The liability of home inspectors is usually limited to the fee that they charge. Refunding the fee would put him in the clear.

  • 11 years ago
    the lender did not require a termite inspection. the inspector has agreed to pay just about 3x the inspection fee but it's nowhere near the $4k repair costs
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Have you reviewed your contract/agreement with the inspector? LWO is correct that many home inspection contracts include a limitation of liability clause that maxes out the damages equal to the inspection fee. But not all inspectors include these in the contract and not all states/jurisdictions find such limitations to be lawful. Before I agreed to accept the $900, I would advise you to consult with a real estate attorney in your area who is knowledgeable in your state's specific laws. It's worth paying the attorney $300-400 to potentially save you the $3,100 difference between what inspector is offering and what you might actually be due.

  • 11 years ago

    Kudos for specifically stating your location as so many laws are different state to state. In my state, California, the inspectors are liable for virtually nothing unless you spend a bunch of money on attorneys. In that case, the attorneys always win and the inspector has a small chance to lose, but only if he has assets to lose. Mostly, you pay them very little and they do a decent job of pointing out the obvious problems. A good deal for an unsophisticated buyer and not a bad deal for the more knowledgeable buyer.

  • 11 years ago

    Please let us know if you or your attorney were able to figure out if you have a case against the inspector. This is an often asked question on this forum and I've yet to see any specific followup to close out those threads. One other idea for you that would permit you to not amass huge attorney fees is to file a claim in your "small claims court." They are all called different names in other jurisdictions, but you just need to find the court that handles small dollar controversies. You do not need an attorney to appear in these courts and the judges are usually patient because of this. Once your attorney figures out the law regarding liability, you should be able to take this information to court with you and argue it to the judge. Good luck!!

  • 11 years ago

    Our building inspector 'missed' that an addition to the house we bought had settled over an inch. (The seller had packed this area with furniture, or we would have realized that the windows wouldn't open in it.) The settling was clearly visible from the exterior of the house to contractors we brought in to estimate repairs: $20K to raise.

    We got back what we'd paid the inspector ($300) and decided to tear down and build new -- which is what the seller had always insisted we would do. We belatedly realized that crafty old woman had bribed the inspector prior to our arrival for the inspection. (No wonder he spoke in terms of 'possibilities for the property'. We totally missed his smirk until we reflected on his report.

    Lesson: Arrive EARLY for the home inspection, and assume *nothing*.

  • 11 years ago

    "We belatedly realized that crafty old woman had bribed the inspector prior to our arrival for the inspection."

    How did you discover that? What action re this did you take?

  • 11 years ago

    I too, am curious how you would be able to find this info out. And what benefit would this give the inspector for doing so?

    Like AtomicJay says... even though the inspector's contract may say that they can only be liable for the fee of the inspection, does not make it so. I have personally been told by two inspectors that they are encouraged to put that verbiage in their contracts even though the state courts would, or could, find it unenforceable.

  • 11 years ago

    You only realize some things in retrospect. Our seller was the most clever and manipulative person I have ever met -- aside from my MIL. She held social power in the town. We couldn't *prove* anything, and to sue her...well, who were these awful strangers accusing the poor woman?

    How much do you think it would take to bribe a poor home inspector to 'miss' a sinking foundation on an addition? $1000? $2000? More? It would be *nothing* on the sales price.

    Why do you suppose she had packed that area with heavy office equipment and furniture, other than to prohibit access to the stuck windows? It wasn't that way when we'd looked at the house before making an offer.

    During my first visit to the house, as I started towards this rear addition, the seller came bustling in with a watering pot, spilling water on the floor as I approached a window. Poor old widow lady...I helped her mop it up and let her lead me on to another room.

    The day we arrived to present our offer we weren't in the house ten minutes before our seller had to take a phone call in our presence. It was some friend of hers, supposedly urging her to wait for an offer from Doctor X. (Yeah, sure.) She had a whole gaggle of senior women who evidently thought it their pious duty to help her. You have to have known someone like this to recognize it. I was late to the party.

    Prior to the closing we had an appointment to bring an architect to the house. We all arrived and she was nowhere to be found! We were too polite to walk around on her property.

    We arrived early for the home inspection, yet...the inspector was already there. I wonder who told him to come early? I do wonder how much he made -- after refunding our $300.