Software
Houzz Logo Print
berndnyz5

Lysol Deer Protection

11 years ago

I just got an Email from Hallson's Gardens about their Bearded Iris Sale, to which they attached their success in using a Lysol product for inexpensive protection against some diseases and deer. This is very good to know naturally for our hostas:

Lysol I.C. Disinfectant Cleaner for
Botrytis, Black Spot, Powdery Mildew... and Deer Control?

Don't you just love happy accidents?
This year we had one when we decided to try using Lysol® Brand I.C.™ Quaternary
Disinfectant Cleaner to prevent botrytis leaf spot on our lily crop. The lilies
we sprayed had virtually no leaf spotting, turning in an awesome display in the
gardens and one of our best potted crops in the nursery. But that wasn't the
surprise. The incredible side effect was that the resident deer didn't touch
them! The deer walked through the nursery and nibbled on Hydrangeas and
daylilies, munched on hostas and Fine Line buckthorn, but never touched the
lilies. In the display garden they were eating just about everything, but again
not touching the lilies. It took a few weeks for us recognize that the lysol
was acting as a deterrent. Only after other deer repellents were applied and
they still ate hostas and not lilies did we have that eureka moment and realize
it had to be the lysol.

How did we know to use Lysol I.C. on
our lilies in the first place? Years ago our chemical supplier recommended and
sold us Consan 20 as an all purpose fungicide to treat Botrytis leaf spot and
powdery mildew, among other things, and it worked pretty well. At the time we
were using Lysol I.C. as a surface and tool cleaner, for cleaning and
disinfecting used nursery containers, and for cleaning our hosta soaking tubs
and wash areas. After purchasing Consan 20 we noticed the liquids looked and
smelled the same so we checked the labels and noticed that the active
ingredients were nearly identical too. This year we mixed up the Lysol I.C.
concentrate at a rate of 2 teaspoons per gallon, the rate listed for Consan 20 for
plant treatments, and test sprayed it on different plants, starting with the
lilies. We sprayed the foliage to runoff in late April, mid-May, and again in
early June and in July. As I mentioned, the lily crop was beautiful this year.
The lysol also cleaned up powdery mildew on Monarda without any residual
problems and without damaging the Monarda flowers, which happened with other
types of fungicides we've tried. The lysol kept our oak leaf hydrangeas looking
especially nice and cleaned up leaf spot on some hostas damaged by frost.


You can read the whole story, especially also in respect to hostas at

http://www.perennialnursery.com/newsletter0815.html

Comments (16)

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for sharing this.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes thank you bernd for sharing and to Chris for the sharing of the original info.

  • 11 years ago

    u may want to use search on www.ewg.org for this:


    LYSOL IC Quaternary Disinfectant Cleaner


  • 11 years ago

    kinda reminds me of when I found out that the 'plus' ingredient in Ortho Bugetta Plus is deadly to honeybees.

  • 11 years ago

    So I was OK not buying the BG Plus recently, but the less expensive Bug Getta. Even Walmart has that Lysol stuff.

  • 11 years ago

    I tried looking it up Hostahillbilly... no luck finding specifics but I will try again when I have more time. I was excited when I read the email but immediately wondered the side effects.

  • 11 years ago

    Here's a link to MSDS for this product. Against federal law to use in a manner not consistent with label.
    MSDS

  • 11 years ago

    At first I was as excited as when windmill ppl started knocking on my door. Now, as then, 'the rest of the story' chills me.

  • 11 years ago

    Sorry to have created such a controversy. I did review the MSDS before using it, to know what I was handling, and should have posted a link to it in my article. Also I first learned of Lysol's fungicide properties when reading a study in a grower magazine where Lysol was used in a research study. And the farmer's almanac suggested soaking socks in lysol as a deer deterrent.

    If you are interested in trying this then please purchase Consan 20 instead. Same ingredients and same results. I'm going to update the article to say this too. There are often things we use as home remedies that are not specifically approved, such as using bleach on plants would also be a label violation, and I should have specifically mentioned this. Sorry again for posting this.

    Sincerely yours,

    Chris

  • 11 years ago

    As a law abiding citizen I would never use any product for unlabeled uses. Besides, the local Walmart doesn't carry it. I'm more interested in its fungicidal properties. Consan 20, here I come! Thanks for the info.

    Kathy

  • 11 years ago

    please Chris do not be sorry! you gave good information and it's up to us what to do with it. I'm glad you did!

  • 11 years ago

    hillbilly


    As a member of the lysol police, thank you for bringing this to everyone's attention. You wanna be a deputy?

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    How about insecticides? Bees are insects and probably get affected by insecticides. So I would not be permitted to spray little ant hills because a bee might land on it? I am just mixing up 2 gal of a Bayer Advanced Complete Insect Killer solution to spray my hostas against nematodes. So any bee better not land on any of those leaves.

    Disclosure, with 350 hostas I am not able to give them all hot water baths, and all recently described other chemicals are not available for home owners or too expensive, and I just have that Bayer bottle which helped somewhat against nematodes in past. I am using that Bayer spray consistent with federal law. I also have a bottle of Biosafe Disease Control, but in spring had problems with spraying it with a hose.

    As it goes, I got more concerned nowadays about sprays in respect to my own health than any critters. Thick leaved hostas are the way to go when looking for less maintenance in the hosta garden.

  • 11 years ago

    I'm wondering if this might help with slugs like ammonia does.

  • 11 years ago

    The household chemicals use label issue is a personal and common sense decision - no different than speeding. Using bleach as a disinfectant is plain common sense - no political correctness intended or observed in its use in any inside or outside application.

    It is bleach, with its own label use hazard warnings which are quite serious, but when followed are effective for the intended chemical use!!!!

    All those that have never sped over the limit are allowed to give garden web hosta growing advice which we will all respect - the rest of us lawbreakers will remain anonymous until big brother finds out that you have been poring hot water in holes in your gardens,,,,,.

    That is a climate change problem that our President has proposed banning for future use, so look for another option, away from using carbon burning energy. NO sunlight powered energy allowed, recall we are shady people.

    Today I killed a bunch of slimy critters while planting hosta; shhhhh..... don't tell anyone.